Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Tuesday, May 03, 2005

Is Huntington correct?

Family
Clan
Tribe
City-State
Empire
State(Westphalia 1648)
Nation
Nation-State
Civilization

Huntington has tackled the last of these, realpolitik and the theory of the Balance of Power primarly applied to the State system.

Others have argued for a 'regional analysis' whereas Zgniew Bryzinski argued for a 'chessboard' where certain regional powers were of importance. In The Pentagons New Map the bright young naval researcher showed a view of the world divided into a core and periphery where the core was the stable nations and the periphery, not actually the geographic periphery, was the unstbale ones, cpable probably of exporting terror and strife.

Huntingtons thesis was assaulted for being 'racist' becuase he dared to include a chapter entitled "Islams Bloody Borders". However when we see the vitriole applied to Bernard Lewis, Daniel Pipes or David Horowitz, nay even Podhoretz perhaps, Huntington got of light.

Huntington realized early, before Sept 11 that the world was no longer a system of States as it had been since Westpalia and since Vienna in 1815-1816, Mitternecht had gone out sometime during the Cold War. Huntington saw the fualt lines as civilizational and he explained the Greek-Turkish war and the Serbian conlfict as well as Kashmir and Sudan through that lense.

Huntington was correct. However there are caveats. Iran supported Armenia against Azerbaijan. Israel was also an ally of Iran and Turkey, and even of the Kurds. We can draw numerous examples of people siding agains their civilization for purely balance of power reasons. Iran is not Arab, therefore Israel seemed a logical ally. America and Saudi Arabia are allies, Saudi is a conservative kingdom and opposed the Pan-Arabism of Iraq and Syrai(Ba'ath) and of Egypt.

Huntington was basically correct. For these examples to not take away from the overall fact that in the end despite blips of countries siding against their civilization the over arching conflicts oft he 21st century will be civilizational, they already are and it is indeed interesting to see that the Liberals assaulted Huntington in their effort to deny history. Who can deny Kashmir, Israel, Sudan, Chechnya, Cyprus, Kosovo, Xianxiang, Phillipines, East Timor, Southern Thailand? The liberals argue that it is a case by case scenario, and that is about as intelligent as arguing the inquistion was simply a state by state phenomenon, just becuase they happaned to burn protestants and Jews at the stake in Spain and France, it was for different reasons, we must not castigate the Catholic church for such behavior, since that was only a small number of catholics involved in the inqusition. If you understand the latter, you understand the former.

Seth J. Frantzman



Seth J. Frantzman

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home