Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

The meaning of 'Justice'

Justice seems to a ubiquitous word nowadays. Organizations speak of 'Peace and Justice in the Middle East'. Or a 'Just and lasting Peace'. Or the 'Harvard Initiative for Peace and Justice'. People for Peace, Justice, and Healing, Artists for Peace, Justice & Civil Liberties, MD United for Peace & Justice, United for Peace and Justice, Fellowship of Reconciliation - Peace, Justice and Nonviolence, Peace and Justice Studies Association.

The list is endless. Most of us have an idea of what 'Peace' means. Peace is the absence of war, conflict and violence. In 1993 Russell Kirk offered up his own opinion of the problem with the use of 'Justice'. Searching for its definition and explaining the problem he elaborated:
"We hear the cry "Peace and Justice!" from folk who would destroy existing societies with fire and sword." From scripture he quotes "Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, even so do to them." and "the general rule by which we endeavor to do justice is this: "to each man, the things that are his own." or to give "every man his due"


There exists concepts of Social and Criminal 'Justice' and of course classical Greek concepts of Justice and Christian and Hebrew concepts, and even Muslim ones.


However, the truth of the matter is that most people understand justice to be some form of legal proceeding whereby someone who deprives another of something, or commits a crime, is thereby punished and receives 'justice'. Hence in the American West we had posse's and we still have a 'Justice of the Peace'.

When used in conjunction with the word 'Peace' what does justice mean. In General after September eleventh the protestors who called for no act of retaliation and claimed 'retaliation will only cause more violence' or that 'violence is not the answer' were the same people who supported the concept of 'Peace and justice'. If justice for the killing of 3000 American civilians is to grant peace to the murders then is that a concept of 'justice'? Perhaps what these groups really meant was that because the terrorists supposedly came from impoverished homes, deprived of their pride by imperialism, that they had enacted 'justice' upon America and therefore we must give peace in return. Only through this logic does it make sense to confront 9/11 with the idea of 'justice' and 'peace'. Chaim Herzog when commenting on his time at the U.N as ambassador for Israel explained that he came to understand "A Just and Lasting Peace meant the destruction of Israel". In a way we see how the riddle of Orwell's 1984 has consumed the language of the peace protestors. Justice usually entails some form of revenge for them, usually the killing of many civilians, and the destruction of nations, whereas The West or whatever society the protestors come from must be subjected to this in the idea that by offering ourselves up for slaughter we are allowing others to get 'justice' upon us for all the wrongs we created. In a sense 'justice' for imperialism should mean that whenever terrorists want to kill civilians they should be allowed, because that makes up for colonialism. The meaning of 'peace and justice' is 'war and revenge'. Like 1984 one must never trust what the organs of the masses are pumped full of by those intellectuals who try on college campuses and in the newspapers and online to claim that the world needs 'peace and justice'. Peace is not the answer to terrorism, justice has nothing to do with peace, the concepts are contradictory. Peace may result from justice, but one does not have both being enacted at the same time. The Nuremburg trial brought justice upon the Nazis criminals, it did not bring peace to the 7 million victims of them.

Seth J. Frantzman

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home