The Quran and liberalism part I
We hear sometimes that the central theme of the Quran is to raise the rights of women, now if we accept this as the truth then we should wonder 'how bad was it before'. I mean let us imagine that the Qurans ideal society is something like Saudi Arabia or even Iran, where such wonderful things as a womans testimony being worth half a mans, death penalty for adultery and of course no abortions are the law, then let us wonder...it could be worse, No? We know for instance that it could be slightly worse, for instance the women of India who used to be kept in 'purdah' another Islamic idea, or the Chinese women with bound feet, or the Russians who published accounts of the best way to beat ones wife. Ok it could be worse, I mean female circumcision(practiced, hmmm, by Muslims) is worse. So if the main message of the Quran is raising womens rights, despite warfare being the main subject, then ok, lets give Liberals who preach this idea the benefit of the doubt. But what does this say?
What does it say for instance about the Bible? What was the main message of Jesus. Apparently it wasnt to raise the standard of women. And Mohammed he raised the standard of women by marrying those 12 girls, including Aiesha who was 9. Now apparently it was worse before that, so that women were being married at perhaps 3 years old and men had fifty wives who they divorced at will, this is Jahaliya(ignorance) no?
But then why did Europe give women equality? Since we must not credit the Bible for that, then what must be credit? Let us examine those Chinese women again with the bound feet. If that tradition existed in Islam, or if it still existed in China(had not Mao Tse Tung and the Communists gotten rid of it) then surely Liberals would be telling us that it is racism to dare judge the Chinese 'primitive' or 'discriminatory' for binding a foot of a girl, after all in Chinese culture women have a seperate role and Confucious, his main message was to grant women rights, and the right to have their feet forcibly bound was the most important. See this is the irony. Had the catholic churches Irish practive of kidnapping wayward women and forcing them into slavery in convents survived into this era of Moral Relativism, then Liberals would tell us 'how dare you judge the catholics primitive...dont you make such a value judgement, that is their culture'. Ahh culture, it must not be touched.
In a way Islam could not have been more perfect for liberalism and moral relativism, for by surviving in its present Islamist form it is a perfect match for a world where 'no ones culture is superior, no ideas are correct, everything is equal'. Yes, everything surely is equal and that southern plantation culture of slavery was noble, like Bedouins, and therefore how dare we critique the slave owning culture. Had Lincoln been a Moral relativist he would surely have said so and done nothing, and we would have wonderful noble southern culture today, with that wonderful institution, slavery. Just becuase culture does something does not mean it must preserved, we Americans should realize that more then anyone, having cast off so many practices. Why today do people retreat and legitimize slavery, and all these horrors?
It is amazing that China, that India, that Catholicism, that it was all reformed by those horrible 'colonial' western ideas like equal rights...maybe we should go back to binding feet and enslaving immoral catholic women. Heck lets bring back the inquisition, after all that was an important cultural artifact, and let not forget Nazism, becuase that to was 'cultural' since Hitler wrote about Volkisch, therefore imagine the Moral Relativist confronting Hitlerism.
Churchill: We must stop Hitler before its too late
Moral Relativist: How dare you judge
Churchill: But the Nazis are overunning europe
M.R: But that is their culture, who are we to judge
Churchill: But they are slaughtering people, they are barborous
M.R: We must not generalize, that is racism
Churchill: racism? We must fight the Germans
M.R: No, no not all Germans are Nazis, only a small percentage and we must encourage the German people to judge them. We must not judge or be racist or dare to condemn.
Churchill: But they are committing Genocide
M.R: That is their culture.
And actually a similar argument is played out over Sudan...the world widdles away.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home