Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Thursday, June 02, 2005

Is religion illogical?

Someone recently said "Esau and IShamel they represent the first rejection of god and one that adhers to god". "Esau is christianity and under Christianity Jews left G-d, while under Islam(Ishmael) Jews embraced G-d. The Mizrachi and Sephardi have more faith."

Dare we reason with this obvious logic?

If one accepts the idiocy that Jesus 'rejected G-d' or rejected the Oral Law, then we can understand that Ishamel did not, however G-d siad "Ishmael will be a nation, his hand against everyone". Was G-d prescient?

Now did the Ashkenaz leave G-d? The Ashkenaz were liberated in 1789 by napoleon, allowed to be equal, in their ghettos, suppressed, they had G-d. Outside the ghetto equality became the new god and socialism and they came to observe the heresy of communism. However at the same time it led them to the nationalism that created Israel. They did not abandon G-d, but they abandoned fundamentalist beleif, the ghetto Jew mentality, the spending all day in Shule, praying. They dared to be equal, and yes they assimilated. In the land of 'Ishmael' they did not assimilate, they could not without converting. Instead they were, dhimmi, suppressed, not allowed to ride horses, have large homes or even to engage in certain trades, they were beaten, discriminated against, and they had to wear distinctive dress. This was their lot. Tey embraced G-d for they had no other.

Religion is illogical. The man who claims this idiocy that suppression is preferable to equality becuase under suppression people have more faith(akin to the position in Egypt perhaps), they are showing religion cannot exist beside logic, for the religious would rather be suppressed, and call suppression upon their community, if only to preserve fanaticism. Hence many religions prefer their congregants poor, it keeps them religious.

Faith is good, G-d is good, religion is not always logical.

Seth J. Frantzman

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home