Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Thursday, June 02, 2005

Orientalism the true way

Orientalism was originally the method by which Europeans who were interested in other non-western cultures approached those cultures. They approached them with their own cultrue as a starting point and described the differences. They adopted 'exotic' clothes, and they condemned 'barbaric' practices.

Then there was Ed. Said. Said claimed in his Orientalism that this process was wrong, that only the oriental could judge the oriental and that if the westerner dared to judge the oriental he must do so from the orientals point fo view.

This is in vogue now. No one will dare to be an Orientalist and to be one is to be accused of imperialsim, racism' and to be insensitive. In a sense moral relativism is the antithesis of Orientalism.

But is Orientalism wrong?

Let us imagine the Oriental, Arab or Asian or African, coming to Europe or America, like ssay Said Qutb did. IS he not also an orientalist, in the sense he judges western culture by his own?

Said saw nefarious ideas in the Greeks who dared to critique the Persians, in the Roman application of 'barbarian' to non-Romans and the Uropean application of 'backward' or 'uncivilizaed' to other civilizations.

Now let us imagine there is a grain of truth here, that the haughty arrogant european wading ashore to see the Aztecs and declaring human sacrifice barbarian, is wrong.

Now let us apply the orientalist judgement to everything. Imagine that orientalism never existed. Imagine that no one had ever dared to call a culture backward to try and reform a culture, under the notion( we hold today) that culture is unchangeable and should never be reformed(becuase reform=bad european western application of western ideas).

How would the world look?

Chinese women would still have their feet bound.
Indian women would be forced to commit Sati.
The Southern U.S would still have slavery.
Catholic nations would be dictatorships, with the Pope and ruler.

This is the world the liberal wants. How dare we have judged the KKK for killing blacks, after all isnt that 'southern culture'? Isnt german 'culture' to kill Jews? Isnt it american culture to have slaves. The orientalists dared to say that people should reform.

Todays liberal, todays european, todays inellectual, todays academic, dares not question ot judge or , worst of all 'generalize' because to judge is to force european values on others. Therefore honor killings and female circumcision must not be critiqued, in fact they must be preserved as part of 'culture'.

This is the lie, the neo-liberal lie. It is the heresy that claims that we as intellectuals must never generalize, therefore we can never say anything about anything, we cant say 'this culture puts a high value on honesty' or 'to have shame in this culture is considered bad'. that would be generalizing. But let us generalize about one thing. Liberalism is the most backward, uncivilizaed, barbaric, ideology to ever grace the planet, worse than theocracy, worse than imperialism, worse than nazism, becuase it begets and enables and appeases them all. The neo-liberal ideology would have us beleive that genocide is part of 'culture' that treating women as slaves is 'culture' that beating ones wife is 'culture' that racism is 'culture' that stoning homosexuals to death is 'culture'. Culture itself is the lie, for if culture is taken to mean that we cannot reform it then culture must go. Culture and liberalism are in this rubric the enemy. How can culture coexist next to modernity and progressive ideas such as equal rights when it is taken to mean that which is unchangeable. The catholic nations when told the church would be seperated from the state whined that the church would die. The church did not die. They were wrong.

Those that oppose reform are wrong, and as the liberals lead us into moral oblivion with their moral relativist rhetoric, as they lead us to theocracy, as they try to bring back all that which the world fought against since 1776(1789 for some), as they seek to re chain the working man, and put the woman back into the second class status, we must struggle against this ideology of hate, the ideology that says orientalism is wrong.

Seth J. Frantzman

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home