Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Saturday, June 25, 2005

Towards a general theory

From an email:

Thank you for your well thought, very pleasant letter. I have penned you another very lengthy email and I hope you will find time to read through the whole thing and not be put off, I look forward to your thoughtful response and a common ground between us...

You see a contradiction where I do not. We must judge people one at a time. That being said religion and ideology are not people, they are things. Society, culture, all this is a thing. People are all equal, every single one, born with whatever skin color they can be raised anywhere and therefore take on that culture/ethnicity, or political ideology. Every German was a person in 1939, however Nazism(an ideology) was repugnant and since it was able to mobilize those PEOPLE was able to commit crimes. Most Germans were Nazis in the period 1939-1940, even the current Pope(who I support and agree with) was a member of a Hitler Youth organization(he was forced to join).

Islam is a religion, and it can be judged. Muslims and their behavior and their laws and their states can be judged. Nations, peoples, countries can and must be held accountable. This is the problem. The liberal(moral relativist) will say "never generalize, generalizations lead to racism and hate". But if we never generalize then we can never say anything about anyone.

Let us look at the Chinese in 1900. At this time 90% of Chinese women were having their feet bound, and they were permitted few if any rights. Communism brought women equality in china, it ordered the peasant men to remove their long hair(that was a sign of religion) and it ordered the binding of feet to stop. Here we can judge, Chinese communism was modern, progressive and ensured equality(over the bodies of millions who died of course...like in most communist revolutions). Modern China was forcibly modernized, as I would argue so was modern turkey and Modern Europe. Modernization in ALL NATIONS was brought by the sword, it did not happen passively. Women rights is the same, when I said 'we' I of course include the hundred years of the women’s movement, and the fight for suffrage by women, and of course the male legislators who GAVE women the right to vote, just as today the males of Kuwait have given women this right. Women gained their rights from men, just as slaves and non-land owning whites did in other places, and serfs. The struggle for rights was one in which the privileged classes gave rights to the non-privileged, sometimes through violence, but frequently otherwise.

Now you see we must judge. We must Catholicism, not every catholic but the institution, for what it did, for the inquisition for instance. We must judge Islam accordingly. Let us imagine that in America women were subjected to honor killings and forced to wear veils and not allowed to vote. I would opine that you would judge America and our nation if we did such things. Saying 'there are many people who disagree' does not leave the nation unaccountable for its actions. Germans were responsible for the holocaust. No nation can have barbarous backwards laws unless the people agree. All these conservative fundamental regimes and backwards ways of treating women take place because society allows them to. If every man suddenly allowed his wife to get a job and let his daughter live on her own and said "NO" to the government the abuse would stop. Remember it is the man who commits the honor killing. In Egypt tragically it is the women and the man who take part in the female circumcision. Every day an Egyptian may wake up and say "I have decided not to cut off the clitoris of my daughter". Every German employed by the SS could have said "I have decided not to kill Jews". Every Communist Russian could have said "I will not fulfill Stalin’s Quota today". The Greeks remarked on this when Xenophon and his 10,000 were traveling in Anatolia in the 5th century he wrote "The one word the Persians have yet to learn is 'no'". How prescient he was. Human rights violation occur because people stop saying no. Americans said 'no' to Vietnam and the war ended. Saying 'no' is not easy, but it is necessary. Sometimes when the government will not permit 'no' then the people must remove the government, and that is how we Americans achieved our independence. Have you forgotten that the slogan of republican Spain was "NO PASARON". Need I translate the statement. 'They shall not pass'. Who is 'they'? The forces of reaction, the forces of conservatives. 'They' is the catch all for all the evils that afflict society. And today 'they' is militant Islam. In 1933 it was fascism. In 1950 is communism. Today it is Islamism(as differentiated from Islam, Islamism is a political ideology).

As you might have not guessed, I am an idealist raised reading Locke and Russuea and Marx. I am a violent believer in the rights and revolutionary thought, and I find that today actually we in the west have abandoned these ideals. We used to bring light to the world. We in the west reformed ourselves. Other nations however did not successfully reform themselves. Western ideas brought reform, whether in China, or India(abolition of the caste system) or Africa(ending slavery). The West created bad things and we undid them.

Now you remark that the message of Islam, Christianity and Judaism is equality. I do not think this is so. Judaism and Islam particularly are not religions based on equality. Neither for that matter is most religion. We are told that Islam brought 'more' equality to women in Arabia then previously. Perhaps this is true(since Islam erased pre-Islamic sources in many of the societies it conquered we do not actually know the position of women before). But let us say it is true, because we do know that women had a lowly status in much of the Middle East in the 6th century. Islam was reforming the status of women. Let us say before Islam the status of women was 10(on a scale of 1 to 100, 100 being equal). Let us say Islam brought women’s status to 50. Let us say that Judaism did the same thing. Now in the modern western concept of equal rights a woman is at 100, although due to lingering discrimination her real position is maybe an 85 or a 90 depending on the country in the West. These religions are not bringing the message of true equality. Look for instance at polygamy or divorce. Jews outlawed polygamy(at the behest of Christians) in the 12 or 13th century(only among Ashkenazim). Polygamy is not equality, unless of course women may engage in it too. Now let us examine the Islamic and Judaic process of Divorce:

The Muslim man may divorce the women at least 3 ways in Islamic law. The Talaaq is the most common. In Talaaq divorce in its most extreme example he merely says "talaaq" or "I divorce you" three times and he is divorced. Under a more idealized version he says it three times over a three month period(actually three cycles of menstruation for the woman). The man may divorce his wife at any time for any reason. The woman may sue for divorce under only very few circumstances, usually abandonment or for immoral reasons or sometimes if he wants a second wife. Abuse(physical) is not a reason because under Islamic law a man may beat his wife if she disobeys, the bad translations of the Koran claim Sura 4:34 says "scourge" your wife, but it says 'beat/strike' in the Arabic.

The Jewish man may also divorce his wife with relative ease. However a Jewish women cannot be guaranteed a divorce. In Jewish law a woman must obtain a 'get' from a man, basically a release. Usually in both the Muslim marriage and the Jewish one the Woman pays the man for the divorce, in Islamic law she simply gives up her right to 'mahr' the dowry that was legally given to her(not actually given her) in the marriage. In many Jewish societies when a man will not give a 'get' a rabbi will order other Jews to pressure and if necessary imprison him until he gives it, and sometimes he will be beaten up. In a Muslim nation(and you should watch "divorce, Iranian style") the Qadi or religious judge will also encourage the man to give the wife a divorce, sometimes the wife’s uncles and family members will beat the husband up to get the divorce.

These are tribal societies after all. They are not EQUAL societies or religions. I am a Jew and I am proud of my people and our achievements, but if Jewish women deserve civil marriage contracts in Israel they way they have them in the West. Muslim women deserve the same. Women deserver absolute equality. I am a feminist in this respect.

I am sorry that you were brainwashed by your Muslim friends or by academics or the media to believe that the main message of Islam or Judaism is Equality. The main message of both is to believe in ONE God. God did not grant women equality, and that is a tragedy, perhaps in an esoteric way God worked through us and got us to reform our societies, but only in that light can one argue god was involved in equalizing the sexes.

IS Buddhism and Hinduism and other religions equal. No. No religion to my knowledge is equal. This is why religion needs the state to keep it in check.

It is a tragedy that in the west after fighting so long for freedom from religion that people such as yourself have been seduced by Islam and seduced by religion and seduced by this ideal that it is such a good thing. Why have you been seduced by Islam? Why have you been seduced to tell me that 'my Arab friends are modern'. People who wear Arab friends around their neck like a badge of diversity 101 are simply betraying the idea that people are equal. An Arab is not special and having an Arab as a friend does not make one understanding of Arabs. I've known people from every religion and every culture and I've lived abroad most of my life, and I don’t think knowing a few of these people makes much difference, because in general the only thing I've learned upon meeting an Arab or a Hindu that hates the backwardness in parts of their societies is hope that they may change it. I cant change it.

Let me relate a small story. We had a class in Hebrew here for people learning Hebrew. The class was 25% Arab, 30% Russian and the rest were Italians and Americans. The teacher related a story of an honor killing in Ramallah and asked what we thought. The three Arab men in the class all agreed(Wael, Ahmed and Mohammed were their names) that if their sister dated someone and lost her virginity or dated a non-Muslim they would approve of killing her. They might not kill her, but they approved of the action. Now I would recon to guess that some American white racists would also say "If a nigger dates my sister I'll kill him(not her, but its the same mentality)". Ask your Arab friends what they would do if their sister or daughter dated a Jew or a Christian. I beg you to ask. Go about Spain and Europe and see how many Muslim women-non Muslim men relationships you find. Not very many. Now you will find may 50,000 or more Muslim men with non-Muslim women, which is only a remark on the fact that western women have been seduced by Islam. It is not a surprise that most western women would marry a Muslim and put on a headscarf and put a headscarf on their daughters. Our culture is in the process of committing suicide. Between the fact that so many western women are involved in porn and stripping and prostitution, or involved in putting on headscarves only shows the deep chasm of self doubt in our society. We are self doubting whether we made the fight choices.

I am a minority in the belief we did.

I dated an Arab girl once. I am of that second minority of western men who dated Muslim women. But she didn’t wear a headscarf and I would never date a woman who did. How can someone wear a headscarf? How can a woman prostitute herself by putting on a religious garment and not demanding the same of her husband? See I will praise the Saudis on ONE thing. They require the men and the women to dress modestly. In Iran and in other Muslim societies this is not the case. The Muslim men in Europe go about as Europeans, in tight jeans and western shirts. Yet they demand that their women wear headscarfs. How can you justify this? Is this equality? Why must the women be modest but the man not? Why does the Muslim man expect his wife to be a virgin but he is NEVER a virgin? Why does the Muslim man have relations with non-Muslim women but demand his sister to not do the same. This is the essence of Arab and Muslim culture and it is a culture that should be criticized.

How many years ago was it that western women wore headscarfs? About 100 years ago or more. If you journeyed back to Sicily and other rural parts of Europe in 1900 you would find the women in the headscarf. Not the Muslim one mind you, the Christian version. What encouraged the western woman to remove her headscarf? We can only guess. Whatever it was, it made our women equal, it brought them out of the house and into the street, it brought them to college and into the workplace. In Muslim nations not so long ago the headscarf was beating a retreat. Under the Shah of Iran and under the Communists in Afghanistan and under Jinnah of Pakistan(Bhutto too) the headscarf went away. Under Nasser and those secular men of Tunisia and Algeria, and in Turkey the headscarf went away. Under Communism in Yugoslavia and Albania it disappeared. The one day it came back. How wonderful it was when the world was idealistic. In the Palestinian territories the women who were communist like the Ashabs removed the headscarfs. But it is back in all these places. Like the reaction of the 1930s we see reaction in Islam.

Reaction is that great terrible thing that must always be fought and purged. We are seduced today by Islam because it is non-western as part of our deep low self esteem in the West we find ourselves seeing in religion what was stripped from us and suddenly religion seems like something we want to bring back. Like some sequel to a film where the villain returns, we see the return of religion.

The West must either declare ‘no pasaron' or it must die. Churchill said of Nazism "Hitler knows that he will have to break us in this Island or lose the war. If we can stand up to him, all Europe may be free and the life of the world may move forward into broad sunlit uplands. But if we fail, the whole world, including the United States, including all that we have known and cared for; will sink into the abyss of a new Dark Age…'"

We can say the same of the rise of Islamism among the peoples of the world. You may think such a few racist(ask yourself what race is Islam, it is not a race) or intolerant. I admit to intolerance. I admit to being 100% intolerant of the evils of Nazism and Islamism as they represent the same evil. You do not see the evil. However there comes a time for intolerance. When democratic open societies are threatened by demographic destruction at the hands of those that would make them undemocratic(as the Nazis swepped the polls in democratic Germany promising to end democracy) we learn from history that democracy must defend itself or die. Equality and democracy are fleeting fragile ideas, like flowers, preservation of them is not easy.

You will not be convinced. The People of Iran were convinced that their revolution in 1979 would bring democracy, but it brought purges, dictatorship and religious fascism. Islamic fundamentalism brought nothing but evil to Iran(read 'persepolis' a wonderful book by an Iranian author and you will get the idea). Who were the biggest supporters of the Iranian revolution in the West??? The left. Just as the Left today supports the rise of Islam in Europe and support unwittingly the rise of religion and the rise of reaction, it supported the Ayatollah.

Regarding India and the destruction caused by Islam. Perhaps your forget that almost every old Church in the Middle East has a minaret within ten feet of it. Why? You should read about what Mohamed of Ghazni did to India when he invaded it half a dozen times, taking tens of thousands of slaves and destroying temples. How is it you can justify such behavior. When Christians destroyed pagan temples in the Americas we do not deny it, why do you deny that Islam destroyed temples? What happened to the Zoroastrian temples of Iran. They don’t exist as they used to? What happened to the Christians of North Africa? It is amazing how ignorant people are that they deny history. Do you deny that Islam enslaved Africans in the millions? Do you deny that Islam colonized Eastern Europe and enslaved its people? Do you deny that Hagia Sophia is today the largest Mosque in Turkey and was once a Church? What happened to the many Hindu temples that did stand in India? Of course many still stand and many were built because the British allowed them to be and because the Hindus under Shivaji threw off the Muslim colonial yoke. Do you deny that Islam colonized India in the same way the Spaniards did the Americas, or the British Africa? It is so amazing how when a Muslim empire colonized non-Muslims and enslaves them we simply deny it and pretend like Islam was always there, or that everyone happily converted. What revisionism! What do you think happened to the Assyrians of Iraq or the Armenians of Turkey? What happened to he Sikhs of Pakistan? Did they all just vanish one day? How is possible that Europeans are so blind to the terrible genocides of Islam, genocides that are exactly the same as the Rwandan or Cambodian one and only slightly dissimilar from the Nazi one? Islam as a conquering religion built its mosques atop pagan temples and near or beside Churches. This was its deliberate policy, and most conquerors do the same. But why deny that Islam did it. We acknowledge the Romans did it and the Europeans and the Chinese, and others, why pretend like Muslims have clean hands in conquest. It is like you are yearning to have Islam conquer Europe. Don you know what the Muslims did in the 8th century when the rampaged through Spain on their Jihad. The enslaved and they raped. Of course they teach you revisionist history in Spain, they teach you the period of Muslim rule was a 'golden age' and that everything Catholicism did was bad. But what if Spain was still Muslim? It would look just like Morocco or Algeria. Is that how you would want it? How can a European sink so low? How can Europeans become such revisionists? How long will it be before the Nazi invasion suddenly becomes a 'golden age' for France? How long until Stalin’s time is remembered as the 'golden age' of Russia. Find me a 'golden age' and I will find you despotism, slavery, rape and genocide. Under the every great age lies the lie, the lie that is history. History is the story of the victor. Islam erased the History of the places it conquered, it erased the History of north Africa(as the Romans did before) and the history of Iran and North India, and Egypt. Only recently have these people rediscovered their history under the aegis of Un-Islamic 'secular' regimes such as Nasserism, Ataturkism, the Phavlavis and others. In Russia they re-write the time of Stalin even today, and Stalin himself was a great re-writer of history. Islam is no different, it is exactly the same. The 'official' history of Islam only spread propaganda of nations happily converting, of pre-Islamic barbarism, and all these lies. Islamic history is like Roman. Before Rome and after their was barbarism, but Rome, Rome was perfect. Islam is perfect. Or perhaps it is not. Do not be taken in by the lie, you must challenge everything you are taught. Every accepted 'truth' is a lie(like in 1984). The majority is always wrong, if the majority believes something then the majority is assuredly wrong. If history tells you that Islam is perfect and Catholicism is evil, challenge such a black and white interpretation. Catholicism brought an end to barbarism too in S. America, by ending cannibalism among the Natives. Islam perhaps did the same in parts of Africa. But both Islam and Catholicism introduced other abominable things in the place of barbarism.

Christian civilization apparently did one thing correct, it encouraged reason and logic. Apparently despite the attempt of the church to stop such free thought it got through and we see the Darwin and Luther and Copernicus emerged from such a civilization, ney Marx and Neitche as well.

Challenge, doubt, question, never trust.

Seth J. Frantzman



might add Dar al-harb vs Dar al Islam

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home