Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Tuesday, July 12, 2005

Diversity versus Equality

In many cases the question of preserving cultural diversity comes down to eliminating equality, in a sense many cultural norms are based on the 'innate' inequality of men and women. In Islam and in CHina and in other places this has obviously been the case. When Muslims were challenged with losing their personal law, where women are 'inherently 'unequal' or have 'different rights' they protested that the personal law is the same as muslim culture, to strip muslim women of hajib, purdah, or simply to allow them equal rights in divorce, to get rid of polygamy, to end the abuse of women, that these things actually are the 'islamic culture' and without them muslims cease to be muslim.

IF we move on from this and we see that in China the cutting of peasents hair the unbinding of womens feet by communists 'modernized' china and therefore by ending equality also ended 'traiditonal' chinese culture. THe same can be siad of Jews, if one were to enforce certain modern standards among the Haredi, perhaps they would lose certain essential parts of their culture. In many places the process of creating euqality is hand in hand with westerniztion and therefore people become indistinguishable culturally, perhaps they look racially different, but the people of Japan and the U.S and elites in India and Russia, are they not visiting strip clubs, indulging in divorce, having abortions, dancing, and getting rid of 'traditional' roles and therefore are we not seeing the end to parts of the their culture.

In many cases we must choose diversity or equality. TO modernize people is to end their diversity, even in the arab world this is the case. Not so long ago minorities predominated, their existed circassians, Asiatic Jews, Assyrians, Greeks, Maltese, former african slaves in southern iran, berbers, Druze, all sorts of christians, copts, armenians, all sorts of people, swamp arabs, nubains etc... TOday diversity is disappearing, the blending, the creation of natioanl society, modernization. In america certain dialects die out, and formerly diverse places in cities are over run. Certainly we are seeing the disappearence of native languages, customs, and dances, many things are disappearing. As the Peruvians discard their bowler hates for modern wear, they discard culture. Culture and equality and diversity are in conflict. However equality must win, but with its triumph and the revolution it entaisl minorties disappear, as we see the homogenization of the cuacuses, central asia, and eastern europe into nation states, so modernity equals the destruction of minoriites and diversity but perhaps it bring equality and only in this name is it positive.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home