Avi Shlaim, new historians and Liberal racism
In an article by Shlaim a few years ago, he summarized what seemed to him the five main arguments of the new historians:* The official version said that Britain tried to prevent the establishment of a Jewish state; the "new historians" claimed that it tried to prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state* The official version said that the Palestinians fled their homes of their own free will; the "new historians" said that the refugees were chased out or expelled* The official version said that the balance of power was in favor of the Arabs; the "new historians" said that Israel had the advantage both in manpower and in arms* The official version said that the Arabs had a coordinated plan to destroy Israel; the "new historians" said that the Arabs were divided* The official version said that Arab intransigence prevented peace; the "new historians" said that Israel is primarily to blame for the dead end.This group has meanwhile disintegrated. Morris' ideological revolution after the outbreak of the second intifada, during which he in effect justified the expulsion of the Palestinians in 1948, distanced him from Shlaim. "He went off his rocker, and expressed racist views," says Shlaim. "That undermines him as a scholar."In Shlaim's opinion, Pappe made a mistake by politically defending the research of Teddy Katz about the massacre in Tantura, and made an even bigger mistake when he supported the academic boycott of Israel. "That is a totally stupid and absurd idea," he says. "Under no circumstances am I willing to support an embargo on dialogue." He maintains good personal relations, by the way, with both of them.From the start, Shlaim was interested in the last of the five points discussed by the new historians: He was interested in the history of the dead end in the relations between Israel and the Arab world. "The Iron Wall" is an abridged history of this dead end. The book took its name from the famous article published by revisionist leader Ze'ev Jabotinsky in 1923. "Their voluntary agreement is out of the question ...," wrote Jabotinsky in that article. "This colonization can, therefore, continue and develop only under the protection of a force independent of the local population - an iron wall that the native population cannot break through."Jabotinsky was in the minority at the time, Mapai (the forerunner of the Labor Party) was in the majority, and Ben-Gurion disdained Jabotinsky. But in effect, claims Shlaim, Ben-Gurion and the Zionist movement, and the State of Israel in its wake, adopted the theory of the "iron wall." In other words, they believed that the only important thing was to "establish facts on the ground," and therefore, there was no point in entering negotiations with the Arabs. They only forgot the end of Jabotinsky's article, remarks Shlaim, where he said that after the Arabs had come to terms with the "iron wall," it would be possible to speak to them about mutual concessions.
No peaceful solution
By Meron Rapoport
Gaza
Unprecedented Gaza
Most repond to "The dream of Zionism is not just a pretty homecoming story. It is very literally the dream of ERASING someone else's country, EXPELLING millions of people because of their race."First of all Palestinians are not a race, this is a modern fiction. Palestinians in 1930 were composed of Circassians(ethnically Russian type people), Egyptian immigrants and others from the Maghreb, Arabs, Bedouin, Jews, Christian Arabs, descendants of Europeans, descendants of Turks. Palestine was in fact a great melting pot, only today have all Palestinians suddenly become only palestinian as a distinct race. Forget the fact that Race and ethnicity are two different things. Ethnically palestinians are Semites, like Jews. Racially they are white, caucasoid, like the English, as opposed to being 'like' Africans or Asians. Sorry to burst someones bubble.Second I think the dream of Zionism is most likely like any nations Dream to have its own country. I recon the Kurds want their own country, but we arn't taling about Turkish 'racism' against Arabs. The idea of the nation state is something remarkably new, and although its premise may be ethnic/religious/linguistic/historical it is a fact that all peoples wherever they live are living on land that was someone elses, like the native americans. Even the person who posted the above statement is living on stolen land. Where is the settlers "OWN country". Is that Germany? Is it Iran? I guess its time to start doing lots of blood tests, but then I guess we had better evict the Poles from what used to be Prussia, and the Russians from Kaliningrad. I guess I'd better start packing to go back to Russia and France and Portugal and the Phillipines. THat'll be fun!
Liberal rage:
AnomalousNYC says:
I'm all for reconciliation and reaching out to our Jewish partners in peace, but I really don't think that swallowing and stroking the fictions of Zionism is the way to do it. The truth is ugly and brutal, and it alienates the many Jews who refuse to hear it, but this is THEIR choice, and struggling without the willfully blind is better than participating in this tidal wave of lies which has buried the entire conflict.We can talk about "dreams" but lets be frank about this. The dream of Zionism is not just a pretty homecoming story. It is very literally the dream of ERASING someone else's country, EXPELLING millions of people because of their race.For Gazans, this is more than just a sign of oppression. Its presence there over the heads is a tangible evidence of their subjugation and erasure as a culture, as a people, as a living presence on their own land.That flag, no matter how sweetly you want to talk about it, despite all the cozy bedtime stories about "biblical homelands", is a banner of ethnic cleansing and of militant ethnic supremacism. We've seen such "dreams" before and we know where they end up.To hell with that flag. And to hell with those who deliberately conflate the "longing for a homeland" with the longing to ethnically cleanse someone else's homeland. Israel has already achieved its "dream": they have their country, for better or worse. THIS flag has nothing to do with THAT dream, and the destruction of THIS flag will have NO IMPACT on the continued existenc eof Israel. It has to do with another dream entirely: the racist dream of Lebensraum which is the curse of all ethnic supremacist movements. So dry your weepy eyes of those inappropriate tears, and send those blood-engorged war criminal settlers back to their OWN country. There they can wave it all they want, so long as they leave the Palestinians alone.
And later:
AnomalousNYC says:
Kung Fu won't save you now, mutherfucker
This picture is part of the ongoing myth that Palestinians and Israelis are of different race.
The suicide bombers who blow up Israeli buses are the ones who deny the humanity of others. It is interesting how the 'peace' activists celebrate when a bus full of Israelis(Jews and Arabs) is blown up and call that 'fighting for human rights'. Why is it that Hamas is not called 'racist' but those 'rights wing fundamnetalist zionist' Israelis are 'racist'? Is Bin Laden 'racist' for preaching a war of world domination? 99% of those who hate Israel and blog their hatred here and elsewhere have never actually been to Israel and been to arab and Jewish villages in ISrael, they have never bothered to question the racist dialouge of the left which claims that 'zionism is racism' they have never bothered to wonder if Palestinians and Israelis and Jews and Muslims and Arabs are actually different 'races'.
In Hitlers book Mien Kampf semites were all the same race. Jews in Europe were subjected to the Holocaust because of their race(not their religion since many victims had converted). Today we are told by the international media, the UN and the 90% of all college students that Israeli 'zionist' Jews are 'supremacist' implying they are 'white' and the palestinians are 'brown'. Apparnetly the racial characteristics of Jews changed in 50 years from being semites to being 'white'. Apparently the 800,000 Sephardie Arab Jews who immigrated to Israel from the Arab countries became 'white' in 50 years. They must have spent a lot of time in the shade. There will come a day when Arabs and Jews in Israel will reject the race division rhetoric of the west and of the liberals and leftists and neo-nazis who hate Israel and they will unite in opposition to the racial categories imposed upon them by the outside world. The west created race, one day race will die.
Read this gentlement, tonight we hunt, tonight we find the liberal who wrote this and we will kill him, sharpen your tomahawks good for tonight we shall find our honor:
Agreed! Of course the same must also be said about the extremely complicated situation in Occupied Palestine, where subjection to constant terrorism is not just a hyped-up and politically-manipulated anxiety, but an ongoing daily reality which has gone on for more than half a century.Just over 500 people have been killed by slightly more than a hundred suicide bombers in Israel in the first four years since Sharon sparked the intifada. Terrible and unacceptable, and yet almost trivial when compared to the overwhelmingly greater and more systematic daily terrorism inflicted upon tens of thousands of Palestinians in the same period. If Israel wanted an end to terrorism they could have had it a thousand times over. If Israel wanted to normalize relations with its neighbors, they could have had it long ago. It has been repeatedly offered. But Israel is unwilling to pay the price, which is an end to its multiple occupations, the long-postponed acceptance that Israel does indeed have borders, the renunciation of their dream of regional expansion and absolute regional military domination, and the acceptance of international law. Ultimately, Israel wants the land and resources of the Occupied Territories more than it wants peace. Ultimately, Israel desperately needs this conflict to continue if it is to justify its ongoing territorial expansion. So however commendable it might be to try to sympathize with the anxieties of Israel, these endlessly-discussed fears are largely inconsequential to resolving the conflict, because the real driving force of the conflict has nothing to do with Palestinian terrorism or fear of Palestinian terrorism. The engines of the conflict are elsewhere: the American-economy-driving corporate interests of Big Oil and American military contractors and consultants, the political aspirations of the American Christian right, the populist fascism and militant Jewish supremacism of mainstream American and Israeli Zionists, the brilliant machinations of neo-cons to reshape the world under American military hegemony, the carefully-controlled construction of an lawless and yet untouchable American military enclave in the Middle East, and ultimately the unwilligness of the American tax-paying electorate to look more deeply than Page One or to take responsibility for the conduct of their government.When I think of the teetering state of Israel today, hovering painfully between various internal catastrophes as well as juggling a host of external conflicts, I often recall that Americans created something similar in Afghanistan, where it thought it would be clever to arm, train and fund a bunch of religious fanatics against a common enemy. The peculiar branch of Islamic fundamentalism which Al-Qaeda represents, like that branch of fanatically militant Jewish fundamentalism which was stabbing queers in Jerusalem last weekend and lynching Palestinian teenagers in Gaza, bears a common stamp: Made in America.
A little reminder to my fellow Americans: Money is removed from every single paycheck you have ever recieved, and sent to Israel. The State of Israel recieves more money from American taxpayers each year than most American states. American taxpayers send more financial aid to Israel than to any other country. Israel, one of the world`s smallest and wealthiest countries - recieves more money each day from US taxpayers than the 150 poorest countries in the world COMBINED. Five million Jews in Israel, a country enjoying one of the world`s highest standards of living, recieve more money from Americans each year than three quarters of the world`s population in Asia and Africa. We are now paying Israel roughly $660,000 an HOUR, every hour, every day, for decades. This money is being used to fund the criminal land-grabs of a lawless terrorist regime that has been the subject of more United Nations condemnations than any other state in the last half century. LEBENSRAUM - a term devised by Adolf Hitler to justify his occupations of neighboring territory. The German people, he explained, were in danger of imminent desruction unless they could have more "living room." By reason of the innate cultural and biological superiority of the "Aryan" race, Germany was entitled to militarily invade and occupy adjacent, weaker countries. In the pursuit of Lebensraum, entire countries were crushed by Hitler, their populations slaughtered and subjugated, and whole ethnic groups were incracerated in a vast network of concentration camps and walled urban ghettoes. Sound strangely familiar?To a great extent, the body of international law which exists today arose out of the horror of the world at the behavior of the Nazi State and of the masses of ordinary Germans who were swept up in its racist triumphalism. Those who today spit on international law are, in the most profound sense, upholding the traditions of Naziism, under which fantasies of a "natural" racial or cultural superiority were used to justify any manner of atrocity and to completely ignore the laws of nations, the rights of human beings, and the collective interests and will of the entire world. .... There are 9,700,000 Palestinians in the world. Half of them are refugees, part of the largest mass of refugees in human history. America and Israel think they can play this game of torturing them for another thousand years. But in fact Israel has only two real options: kill the vast majority of Palestinians, or radically change course. True to form, Israel prefers denial. Israelis imagine they can maintain the status quo forever simply by imprisoning all the Arabs. This is, in fact, where the third Reich's own solution to the "race problem" began, with the construction of the Ghetto systems. Today, more and more Israelis, frustrated that the "schwartzes" refuse to accept perpetual enslavement, are dreaming of Hitleresque remedies to their own intense racial anxieties. It is a dream doomed to failure, because the future of the middle east and of the world has no room for Zionism and it never will. Humans are meant to live as equals and neighbors, not as ethnic Fuhrers ruling over incarcerated slaves. Once Jewish ethnic supremacism is definitively rejected and its monstrous schemes of regional domination renounced, then we can hope that once again Jews will return to living like normal human beings alongside their muslim and christian neighbors - not as ethnically pure overlords and untouchable racial masters, but as an integral part of Levantine society, mere equals. Until then, may each thrown Palestinan stone finds its target, and may the blood and frustrated tears of each Palestinian child finally turn the eyes of the world to the intolerable ethnic crimes of Zionism, and to the crimes of all the other ethnocidal racist regimes of the world, beginning with our own. ORIGINAL IMAGE: Agence France Presse(unattributed) IMAGE ALTERATION: /anomalous
"The notion of being "neutral" is soothing to most people because it is ostensibly fair, it is optimistic, it is positive, obviating the need for negativity and unpleasantness. But a balanced position in an unbalanced situation inevitably is a miscarriage of justice. Neutrality in Palestine-Israel is no different from refusing to take a stand between slaves and slave owners, or between children and abusive priests."--Kathleen Christison, former CIA agent
"The Palestinian-Israeli conflict is not just an issue of military occupation and Israel is not a country that was established normally. Apartheid is a crime against humanity. Israel has deprived millions of Palestinians of their liberty and property. It has perpetuated a system of gross racial discrimination and inequality. It has systematically incarcerated and tortured thousands of Palestinians, contrary to the rules of international law. It has waged a war against a civilian population, in particular children ... Palestinians are not struggling for a "state" but for freedom, liberation and equality, just like we were struggling for freedom in South Africa ..." --Nelson Mandela, March 2001
...A little reminder to my fellow Americans: Money is removed from every single paycheck you have ever recieved, and sent to Israel. The State of Israel recieves more money from American taxpayers each year than most American states. American taxpayers send more financial aid to Israel than to any other country. Israel, one of the world`s smallest and wealthiest countries - recieves more money each day from US taxpayers than the 150 poorest countries in the world COMBINED. Five million Jews in Israel, a country enjoying one of the world`s highest standards of living, recieve more money from Americans each year than three quarters of the world`s population in Asia and Africa. We are now paying Israel roughly $660,000 an HOUR, every hour, every day, for decades. This money is being used to fund the criminal land-grabs of a lawless terrorist regime that has been the subject of more United Nations condemnations than any other state in the last half century. LEBENSRAUM - a term devised by Adolf Hitler to justify his occupations of neighboring territory. The German people, he explained, were in danger of imminent desruction unless they could have more "living room." By reason of the innate cultural and biological superiority of the "Aryan" race, Germany was entitled to militarily invade and occupy adjacent, weaker countries. In the pursuit of Lebensraum, entire countries were crushed by Hitler, their populations slaughtered and subjugated, and whole ethnic groups were incracerated in a vast network of concentration camps and walled urban ghettoes. Sound strangely familiar?To a great extent, the body of international law which exists today arose out of the horror of the world at the behavior of the Nazi State and of the masses of ordinary Germans who were swept up in its racist triumphalism. Those who today spit on international law are, in the most profound sense, upholding the traditions of Naziism, under which fantasies of a "natural" racial or cultural superiority were used to justify any manner of atrocity and to completely ignore the laws of nations, the rights of human beings, and the collective interests and will of the entire world. .... There are 9,700,000 Palestinians in the world. Half of them are refugees, part of the largest mass of refugees in human history. America and Israel think they can play this game of torturing them for another thousand years. But in fact Israel has only two real options: kill the vast majority of Palestinians, or radically change course. True to form, Israel prefers denial. Israelis imagine they can maintain the status quo forever simply by imprisoning all the Arabs. This is, in fact, where the third Reich's own solution to the "race problem" began, with the construction of the Ghetto systems. Today, more and more Israelis, frustrated that the "schwartzes" refuse to accept perpetual enslavement, are dreaming of Hitleresque remedies to their own intense racial anxieties. It is a dream doomed to failure, because the future of the middle east and of the world has no room for Zionism and it never will. Humans are meant to live as equals and neighbors, not as ethnic Fuhrers ruling over incarcerated slaves. Once Jewish ethnic supremacism is definitively rejected and its monstrous schemes of regional domination renounced, then we can hope that once again Jews will return to living like normal human beings alongside their muslim and christian neighbors - not as ethnically pure overlords and untouchable racial masters, but as an integral part of Levantine society, mere equals. Until then, may each thrown Palestinan stone finds its target, and may the blood and frustrated tears of each Palestinian child finally turn the eyes of the world to the intolerable ethnic crimes of Zionism, and to the crimes of all the other ethnocidal racist regimes of the world, beginning with our own. ORIGINAL IMAGE: Agence France Presse(unattributed) IMAGE ALTERATION: /anomalous
Comments
Ms Entropy says:
I really love your work.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
Johnnie Utah says:
the extremely complicated situation in israel shows how twisted things can get when a constant fear of terrorism infects everything one does.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Agreed! Of course the same must also be said about the extremely complicated situation in Occupied Palestine, where subjection to constant terrorism is not just a hyped-up and politically-manipulated anxiety, but an ongoing daily reality which has gone on for more than half a century.Just over 500 people have been killed by slightly more than a hundred suicide bombers in Israel in the first four years since Sharon sparked the intifada. Terrible and unacceptable, and yet almost trivial when compared to the overwhelmingly greater and more systematic daily terrorism inflicted upon tens of thousands of Palestinians in the same period. If Israel wanted an end to terrorism they could have had it a thousand times over. If Israel wanted to normalize relations with its neighbors, they could have had it long ago. It has been repeatedly offered. But Israel is unwilling to pay the price, which is an end to its multiple occupations, the long-postponed acceptance that Israel does indeed have borders, the renunciation of their dream of regional expansion and absolute regional military domination, and the acceptance of international law. Ultimately, Israel wants the land and resources of the Occupied Territories more than it wants peace. Ultimately, Israel desperately needs this conflict to continue if it is to justify its ongoing territorial expansion. So however commendable it might be to try to sympathize with the anxieties of Israel, these endlessly-discussed fears are largely inconsequential to resolving the conflict, because the real driving force of the conflict has nothing to do with Palestinian terrorism or fear of Palestinian terrorism. The engines of the conflict are elsewhere: the American-economy-driving corporate interests of Big Oil and American military contractors and consultants, the political aspirations of the American Christian right, the populist fascism and militant Jewish supremacism of mainstream American and Israeli Zionists, the brilliant machinations of neo-cons to reshape the world under American military hegemony, the carefully-controlled construction of an lawless and yet untouchable American military enclave in the Middle East, and ultimately the unwilligness of the American tax-paying electorate to look more deeply than Page One or to take responsibility for the conduct of their government.When I think of the teetering state of Israel today, hovering painfully between various internal catastrophes as well as juggling a host of external conflicts, I often recall that Americans created something similar in Afghanistan, where it thought it would be clever to arm, train and fund a bunch of religious fanatics against a common enemy. The peculiar branch of Islamic fundamentalism which Al-Qaeda represents, like that branch of fanatically militant Jewish fundamentalism which was stabbing queers in Jerusalem last weekend and lynching Palestinian teenagers in Gaza, bears a common stamp: Made in America.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
We must get rid of Palestinians "the same way you get rid of lice." -- Israeli Minister of Tourism Rehevam Ze`evi concerning Arablabor inside Israel, July 2, 2001Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Ma`ariv, October 6 2000:60% of Israeli Jews polled endorse involuntary relocation (i.e. ethnic cleansing) of all Arab citizens of Israel to areas outside the state (this is euphemistically known as "transfer" in Israeli political discourse).Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Pedhazur & Canetti, October 2001:65% of Israeli Jews polled endorse encouraging Arab citizens of Israel to emigrate to locations outside the borders of the state.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Ma`ariv, August 2002:72% of Israeli Jews polled say that the existence of Arabs inside Israel poses a danger to the security of Israel.Over 1 million Palestinians make up over a fifth of Israel's population. There are active political parties in Israel whose sole platform is the promotion of the expulsion of Arabs. Among these are the Molodet Party, led by Israel's Minister of Tourism Benny Elon.www.csmonitor.com/2002/0206/p05s01-wome.htmlPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"[Palestinians] are beasts walking on two legs." --Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin, speech to the Knesset, quoted in Amnon Kapeliouk, "Begin and the `Beasts,"` New Statesman, June 25, 1982.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The notion of being "neutral" is soothing to most people because it is ostensibly fair, it is optimistic, it is positive, obviating the need for negativity and unpleasantness. But a balanced position in an unbalanced situation inevitably is a miscarriage of justice. Neutrality in Palestine-Israel is no different from refusing to take a stand between slaves and slave owners, or between children and abusive priests."--Kathleen Christison, former CIA agentPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The Palestinian-Israeli conflict is not just an issue of military occupation and Israel is not a country that was established normally. Apartheid is a crime against humanity. Israel has deprived millions of Palestinians of their liberty and property. It has perpetuated a system of gross racial discrimination and inequality. It has systematically incarcerated and tortured thousands of Palestinians, contrary to the rules of international law. It has waged a war against a civilian population, in particular children ... Palestinians are not struggling for a "state" but for freedom, liberation and equality, just like we were struggling for freedom in South Africa ..." --Nelson Mandela, March 2001Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"If we can start to change the most powerful country in the Middle east, the others will follow. Americans 20 years down the road won`t have to deal with a day like Sept. 11, 2001."--George Bush, April 13, 2005(I like the quote because it would have been somewhat true if he were talking about Israel, which of course IS by far the most powerful country in the Middle East. Instead, in his usual mendacious way, he was discussing his vivisection of Iraq. I wonder where he thinks Israel IS, if not in the Middle East?)Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"South Africa Needs More Arms, Israeli Says" By Drew MiddletonNew York Times, December 14, 1981The military relationship between South Africa and Israel, never fullyacknowledged by either country, has assumed a new significance with the recent 10 day visit by Israel`s Defense Minister, Ariel Sharon, to South African forces in Namibia along the border with Angola. Mr. Sharon made several points concerning the South African position. He said that South Africa is one of the few countries in Africa and southwestern Asia that is trying to resist Soviet military infiltration in the area. Mr. Sharon, in company with many American and NATO military analysts, reported that South Africa needed more modern weapons if it is to fight successfully against Soviet-Supplied troops. The United Nations arms embargo, imposed in November 1977, cut off established weapons sources such as Britain, France and Israel, and forced South Africa into under-the-table deals.Israel, which has a small but flourishing arms export industry, benefited from South African military trade before the 1977 embargo.According to The Military Balance, the annual publication of the International Institute for Strategic Studies in London, the South African Navy includes seven Israeli-built fast attack craft armed with Israeli missiles. The publication noted that seven more such vessels are under order.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"In their hysterical attempts to brand pro-Palestinians as anti-Semites, then, Zionists reveal themselves as ultra-Semites: they view themselves as racially superior to their victims, and harbor deeply racist attitudes toward them. Moreover, they claim their victims aren`t really victims at all precisely because they consider them to be wild animals (or worse) compared to themselves. And because of this moral blindness, support for their victims is automatically and instantaneously construed as an attack on them, when it is in fact only an "attack" on their racism - also known among normal people as a defense of the oppressed. This utter inability to distinguish an "attack" on Zionist racism between an attack on the ethnic group and nation Zionism claims to represent indicates just how deeply Zionists are entwined with their racism.When confronted with the accusation of anti-Semitism, we should call a spade a spade and insist on our opposition to all forms of racial supremacy, including ultra-Semitism."--M. Junaid Alam, "The politics of smears and self-absorption: Anti-semitism or Ultra-semitism?"www.counterpunch.org/alam04292005.htmlPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The war made possible for us the solution of a whole series of problems that could never have been solved in normal times." -- Joseph GoebbelsPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Israel should have exploited the repression of the demonstrations in China, when world attention focused on that country, to carry out mass expulsions among the Arabs of the territories." -- former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin NetanyahuPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Why of course the people don`t want war ... But after all it is the leaders of the country who determine the policy, and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is to tell them they are being attacked." -- Hermann GoeringPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The efficiency of the truly national leader consists primarily in preventing the division of the attention of a people, and always in concentrating it on a single enemy." -- Adolf HitlerPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"A lie should be attempted in a place where it will attract the attention of the whole world." -- Israeli Prime Minister Ariel SharonPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Ariel Sharon is a killer obsessed with his hatred of Palestinians. I had promised Arafat that his people would not get any harm. Sharon, however, ignored this commitment entirely. Sharon`s word is worth nil."-- US Ambassador Philip Habib, Reagan's Middle East Envoy, at the time of the Sharon-directed massacre of 3000 Palestinian women and children in Sabra & Shatila refugee camp, 1982.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
What I did on Holocaust Day By B. Michael Yediot Ahronoth 6.5.05 Translation from Hebrew: Diana Rubanenko "This is how I shot at two kids who might have been throwing stones because, personally, I`ll never again go like a lamb to the slaughter. This is what I did on Holocaust Day. I marked Holocaust Day this year by shooting at two kids. OK, maybe they weren`t kids. Teenagers, possibly. I`m not totally sure how old they were. Fourteen, sixteen, something like that. They didn`t die from my bullets, which are sometimes rubber-coated and aren`t even lethal. Just wounded. A lot of blood was spilt. But by the time the ambulance arrived, and until I allowed it to drive in, and until I authorized it to drive off, the kids (the teenagers, I mean) died. I mean, after they used an ambulance to get a Qassam missile through - we all saw the `stretcher` on TV - there`s no choice: you have to check their ambulances really, really thoroughly and very, very slowly. One of them was calle d Uday, like Saddam`s son, and the other Kamal, like the cigarettes. Their surname - Azassi. They shared the same surname. They were cousins, from the village of Beit Likia. Now they`re both dead. They had it coming. Because they, or their friends, were throwing stones. And stone-throwers deserve to die. I think they were throwing stones because of the fence - because of which most of their village`s land has been taken and all the olive trees have been uprooted. Everyone knows, though, that fence saves the lives of Jews. So someone throwing stones at it, I mean, objecting to it, actually objects to saving Jews` lives. He`s risking my life and my family`s. So let him croak. It`s him or me. Because personally, I`ll never again go like a lamb to the slaughter. Specially not on Holocaust Day. After they died, I went back to guarding the settlement. The settlers threw a garbage can at me, broke my glasses, slashed my car`s tyres, spat in my eye, fractured two fingers of my left hand, and smashed a building-block on my head. Still, I wasn`t angry. Poor people, they`re suffering so much. The government`s decided to move their gardens and Jacuzzis elsewhere, so you can really feel their pain, as they say. They`ve got to let off some steam. It`s OK. We`re all Jews. Then I watched the Holocaust Day programmes on television, and I was in total shock until I fell asleep."Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"As in South Africa under apartheid, denial and indoctrination is so powerful that it is not natural to expect that a movement within the society (in South Africa's case the white society, in Israel's case Jewish society) will arise that is strong enough to stop it. The consequences go beyond even the atrocities suffered by the Palestinians. I believe what Israel is doing will destroy the Jewish people in the near or distant future as well. Even with 250 nuclear weapons and the support of the world's only superpower. For the sake of Jews and Arabs, the world has to play a role in dismantling apartheid." --Ilan Pappe, Professor of History at Tel Aviv UniversityPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The Palestinians are animals. They are less than human. They are savage beasts. Israel is a land of love. People in Israel love one another. But the Palestinians do not love. They hate. They should be destroyed. We should put fire to them. We should take back Beit Jala, Bethlehem, take back all the land and get rid of them." --reporter for the Israeli Arabic Press service quoted in A GAZA DIARY, www.bintjbeil.com/articles/en/011001_hedges.htmlPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"I can`t stand to see the children get shot. I don`t care about the others. But when the children get shot I cry. I can`t take it. I feel like I am sixty." -- Mohammed Abu RichPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"[The Zionists are making] bestial attacks on Arab villages, in which they show not the slightest discrimination for women and children, whom they kill as opportunity offers."--British Major R.D. Wilson, December 20, 1947Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"a dastardly and wholesale murder of innocent people."--Official statement of the British Government concerning a Zionist terror bombing campaign directed against Arab civilians in Palestine, 1947.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Can it be that the dispossessed will keep silent and calmly accept what is being done to them? Will they not ultimately arise to regain, with physical force, that which they were deprived of? Will they not seek justice from the strangers that placed themselves over their land?" --Yitzhak Epstein, delegate to 1905 Zionist congress re Zionist abuse of PalestiniansPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"the widespread terror and willfull murder [has] shocked the entire world."--UN RESOLUTION 181, re Jewish terrorist atacks on Arab civiliansPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"It is my hope that more and more people will reject the notion of a state based upon violence."--President George Bush, May 27, 2005Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"the daily humiliation of Palestinians..."--UN Comittee on the Rights of the ChildPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The first priority is to use force, might, beatings..."--Yitzhak Rabin, Minister of Defense 1988Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Today or tomorrow. What does it matter when I die?"--Palestinian refugee Jihad Abu MoussaPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Zionism is a form of racism."--United Nations General AssemblyPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Enter not houses other than your own, until ye have asked permission and saluted those in them."--Holy Quran xxiv, 27Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"We think that the Arabs are all savages who live like animals and do not understand what is happing all around them. This is a great error. What do our [Jewish] brethren do in Palestine? Serfs they were in the lands of the Diaspora, and suddenly they find themselves in freedom, and this change has awakened in them an inclination to despotism. They treat the Arabs with cruelty and hostility, and even boast of these deeds; and nobody among us opposes this despicable and dangerous inclination."--early Zionist settler Ahad Ha`am, 1922.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same way that England belongs to the British, and France to the French."--Mahatma GandhiPosted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"[Palestinian] refugees wishing to return to their homes...should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date."--United Nations resolution 181Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"It is wrong and inhuman to impose the Jews on the Arabs. What is going on in Palestine today cannot be justified by any moral code of conduct."--Mahatma Gandhi, 1939Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The seizure of Arab land does not increase friction with the Arab population; it will prevent such friction in the future."--Ariel Sharon, Ma'ariv, cited in International Herald Tribune, January 26, 1981.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"We should urge them [the Arabs] to get out of here. The Arab public must feel that the land (really the land) is being pulled out from under their feet.… The very fact of their presence endangers our life everyday… For our own safety there is no place for the Arabs with us in this country."--David Rozentzweig, Nekudah, December 1983.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Quiet with the Arabs is based on one principle only: deterrance." --Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Septemeber 2002Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country."--International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article 12(4).Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"...State Parties undertake to prohibit and to eliminate racial discrimination on all its forms and to guarantee the right of everyone, without distinction as to race, colour, or national or ethnic origin, to equality before the law, notably in the enjoyment of... the right to leave any country, including one's own, and to return to one’s country."--International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, Article 5(d)(ii).Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"...ethnic cleansing is a purposeful policy designed by one ethnic or religious group to remove by violent and terror-inspiring means the civilian population of another ethnic or religious group from certain geographic areas ... in order to accomplish the occupation of territory to the exclusion of the purged group." --United Nations Report on Crimes in Bosnia, 1992Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The General Assembly,RECALLING its resolution 1904 (XVIII) of 20 November 1963, and in particular its affirmation that "any doctrine of racial differentiation or superiority is scientifically false, morally condemnable, socially unjust and dangerous",RECALLING ALSO that the General Assembly condemned the alliance between South African racism and Zionism,TAKING NOTE of the Declartion of Mexico which promulgated the principle that "international co-operation and peace require the achievement of national liberation and independence, the elimination of colonialism and neo-colonialism, foreign occupation, Zionism, apartheid and racial discrimination in all its forms, as well as the recognition of the dignity of peoples and their right to self-determination",TAKING NOTE ALSO of the Declaration of Non-Aligned Countries, 30 August 1975, which most severely condemned Zionism as a threat to world peace and security and called upon all countries to oppose this racist and imperalist ideology,DETERMINES that Zionism is a form of racism and racial discrimination."--UN General Assembly Resolution 3379 (Nov. 10, 1975) (edited)Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country."--UN Resolution 194, passed on December 11, 1948 and reaffirmed every year since 1948Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"The subjection of peoples to alien subjugation, domination and exploitation constitutes a denial of fundamental human rights, is contrary to the Charter of the United Nations and is an impediment to the promotion of world peace and co-operation. All armed action or repressive measures of all kinds directed against dependent peoples shall cease in order to enable them to exercise peacefully and freely their right to complete independence, and the integrity of their national territory shall be respected. Any attempt aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and the territorial integrity of a country is incompatible with the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations. "-- Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples, endorsed by United Nations General Assembly resolution 1514 (XV) of 14 December 1960Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"No State, institution, group or individual shall make any discrimination whatsoever in matters of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the treatment of persons, groups of persons or institutions on the ground of race, colour or ethnic origin. All propaganda and organizations based on ideas or theories of the superiority of one race or group of persons of one colour or ethnic origin with a view to justifying or promoting racial discrimination in any form shall be severely condemned."-- Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, United Nations General Assembly resolution 1904 (XVIII) of 20 November 1963Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
"If thou refuse to let my people go, behold, tomorrow will I bring the locusts into thy coast."--Exodus 10:4Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
zloovi says:
I’ve wandered around your site, enjoyed the photos immensely and also found great interest in your commitment to the Palestinian issue. I don’t know what your background is – I presume it’s either Palestinian or Israeli-Jewish, since I can’t imagine anyone else so immersed in the whole subject of the occupation. I am Israeli; I’m radical left wing and an avid anti-occupation activist. I wanted to ask you how is it that in all these texts, in case I haven’t missed any, the existence of anti occupation Israelis is totally missing. There is a group of people, Jews too, fighting for the inhalation of this colonialism. It is Important that people know this, otherwise, the rise of hatred would be blind and racism, whish I’m sure you object to, will be inevitable. No group of people deserve racism. And It doesn’t even help the cause.Not everybody is so fluent in the details, I'm betting some of the people here use you as a an information channel, which is great – you give out very important information – but don’t forget that showing the big picture is crucial. Thanks for your time.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Zloovi:Wonderful to meet you here, and I am happy to hear your comments. I am neither Jewish, muslim, Israeli or Palestinian. Not even a christian. Just an ordinary American.I accept your critique in principle but you are incorrect when you say "the existence of anti occupation Israelis is totally missing." Look up this very page, for example, and you will see quotes by progressive Jews and Israelis, including Ilan Pappe and Yediot columnist B. Michael, as well as venerable early critics of Zionist racism, Ahad Ha'am and Yitzhak Epstein. There are others in other of the posts here. One whole post is a quote from Michel Warschawski. When I describe the remarkable ongoing protests against the wall, I routinely mention that the Palestinians are often accompanied by progressive Jews and Israelis.In fact I rely very heavily on the work of progressive Israelis and Jews and work alongside many of them. I agree that it is important to draw people's attention to the struggles of progressive and/or anti-Zionist Israelis and Jews. It is somethign I do quite a lot.But what you are seeing here is just the tip of an iceberg. I have been doing this sort of thing on other forums, mainly fotolog, for a long time, and I am only now beginning to share some of this project here on Flickr. If you are interested, there is a TON of this kind of thing in my archives at:www.fotolog.net/anomalousand in recent months I opened a secondary site to focus exclusively on this:www.fotolog.net/anomalekYou might find some interesting stuff there. It is sort of an ongoing process and my tone and tactics change all the time. I am sure some of it is awful.I have only begun to explore flickr in the last few weeks and am not exactly sure of what kind of audience I have here, or of what kind of expression best suits this forum. Gradually I would like to move a lot of these images over to flickr just to have them all stored in one place. I am taking my time because I don't want to freak too many people out at once. Most Americans have never heard a word of the things I write about - mostly because the American press is so much less free than your own, and because the American media tries to insist on a kind of uncritical support of Israel to a degree that you would not find even in Israel.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
niffer says:
anomalous, ooops! I took too long to post this, you beat me to it but I'm posting it as I wrote it anyway:zloovi, hats off to you. Many Israeli people go to great lengths to help the Palestinian people and take many physical risks. Just one example of an Israeli who has suffered tremendously is Tali Fahima. There is a huge effort in Israel to stop these atrocities against Palestinian people. You can see some photos from demonstrations in ISMNC's photostream.However, I disagree with your statement that someone who dedicates so much time and energy to the human rights of Palestinian people must be from either a Palestinian or Israeli background. Many people are dedicated to this struggle, some of them have literally sacrificed their lives...off the top of my head: Tom Hurndall, Rachel Corrie and James Miller ~ none of them either Palestinian or Israeli......Anomalous, I stumbled across a digital copy of "Checkpoint Syndrome" today. If you haven't read it yet, I'm sure you'll be interested. It's a very quick but very emotionally tough read. You can download it here.Your work is really impressive!! Your writings and photo manipulation are brilliant. As Mohammed Omer would say: "Thank you for all you are doing."By the way, Israel is about to ask the US for several hundred million more dollars to pay for disengagement and homes for the relocated settlers. Our tax dollars at work...don't we need them in our own country? But Gaza seems to have been the testing ground for what's now going on in Iraq, so in a twisted way, it makes sense that our taxes go to Israel.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
leleblixa says:
thank you so much for this information. i wish more people understood this.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
and thank YOU so much for reading it. most people avoid this stuff like the plague.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
dearanxiety says:
thanks for that. i couldn't agree more, and it's not always the easiest position for an american jew to take. all the quotes are amazing and will be really really useful i'm sure at some point in my constant debate on this.Posted 6 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
Just_Jane says:
What about the Unwra paying 57 years to the Palestinean and not doing anything to make teach those people to be selfreliable. Nobody is doing anything to make their life better. only complaining.Israel gave them jobs,food, housing and medicare , more than even America has for his own people.If they had not started a intifada again they would not be in this misserable situation. they are biting the hand who was feeding them. With terror they are distroying even more the chance of rehabilitation.Sharon is not the crimminal but everybody and everyone who support, those terrorists with a cheap excuse....Yes America could use his money better , to take better healthcare of his people , but Oil seems to be more important..and sorry guys we have no oil so you can not expect us to pay for your greedPosted 3 weeks ago. ( Permalink )
AnomalousNYC says:
Jane:The views you are expressing are quite typical mainstream Israeli attitudes towards this conflict. The overt racism of your remarks about those you expelled and subjugated is depressing and a little frightening. I am often left with this feeling after dealing with mainstream Israelis, just as I often feel the same queasiness after talking with Americans from outside New York City. Your colonial fantasies of the benevolence of Israel towards "those people" are so far from reality that it amazes me that even the most ardent Zionist could make such nonsensical claims, and your evident malice towards your victims only highlights their falsehood.Palestinians are not your pets, and since you are literally STARVING them at the moment, I would ask you to at least have the simple decency to refrain from claiming that they are "biting the hand that feeds them."
In a survey of Palestinian women it was noted that 45% of college graduates accepted that they should be beaten by their husbands for misbehaving.
In Ramallah alone more then 30 women are murdered a year in so called 'honor killings'. It is quite common throughout the region for a women who is raped or who is not a virgin at marriage to be murdered by her own family. Anyone can pick up the book Burned Alive : A Victim of the Law of Men by Souad for an account by a palestinian women of her life.
Palestinian society like 100% of all societies in the world has problems with murder and violence against women. The person who posted this photo and beleived the propoganda of it wants us to beleive that ONLY Israeli Jews could be responsible for this murder becuase the idea is quite clear: 'Israeli Jews are not human beings, they and only they could do this becuase they hate children'. It is ironic that the person who posted this would call the exact same poster of a murdered Jewish child 'racist' if it implied palestinians murdered her.
THink about it. THink long and hard. If this power had hebrew on it and was about an 8 year olf Jewish girl found burned and killed near an arab village what would you say? Wouldnt you say 'how dare those racist israelis imply palestinians would ever kill anyone'. Its always interesting to confront the Israeli-hater and wonder what he would say if every statement of Hamas was made by a Jew and every statement made by Sharon was made by a Palestinian, if every 'martyr' picture of a palestinian was a 'martyr' picture of a Jew who had blown up a bus full of civilians. THink long and hard Mr. Israelhater.


1 Comments:
Is there any way we can shut Thomas Olson up? He has to be the most annoying human being in the world. He is a white American fighting for another race. What a loser and he'll get what he deserves....
4:19 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home