Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Tuesday, August 30, 2005

Some of the lies of Tom Segev and 'One Palestine Complete'

One Palestine, Complete' is Tom Segev, a Haaretz Journalists, book about the Mandate period in Palestine/Israel. He describes many characters and events and tries to prove his main point, that the British were pro-Zionist. In order to do this he recounts how some British soldier and diplomats were indeed Zionists, Mr. Wingate and Churchill among them. That is where logic ends and the lies begin.

Lets dissect a few of the more obvious lies.

The cover photo is of the Dome of the Rock and the Al-Aqsa Mosque, the 'third' holiest site in Islam. How does Segev describe the same site? It is where 'The prophet ascended to Heaven'. its not where 'according to Muslim tradition the Prophet Mohammed ascended to heaven'. It apparently 'IS' where 'The prophet' really did ascend. Now lets examone how Mr. Segev treats the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. If he was being honest and keeping to his tradition of accepting verbatum religious tradition and the 'truth' behind 'holy sites' he would describe it thus: "The Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the site of the Crucifixion of Jesus. The Tomb and site of the Resurrection". However he describes it as 'where Christians believe...". Now this doesnt seem to be very honest. Either one accepts all the religious nonsense and just says 'Mt. Sinai is where God met the children of Israel, Nazareth is where the son of God Christ was born, the Temple Mount is where the prophet went to heaven' or you dare to be skeptical and say 'according to so and so tradition'. Let the reader judge. The problem with the left wing self hating appologist today when dealing with Islam is they accept all this theological garbldy gook that they wouldnt from their own faith.

Next lets see how he treats the fact that Arabs were 60% pro-Hitler and the Mufti went to Germany and Nashisubieh read Protocols of the elders of zion and beleived it. he calls these as exmaples of the two 'communities growing apart'. Well would it then be fair to say the election fo Hitler and the love of Mien Kampf by germans was just 'communities growing apart'. According to Segev its not 'anti-semitism' its just 'growing apart'. Well when does 'growing apart' become genocide and anti-semitism and irrational hatred and intolerance and bigotry? Is it only when the gas chambers have been built, or it after millions are dead?

According to Segev we must never judge hatred if its Muslim Arab-Palestinians, but he judges and judges Jewish terror and Jewish hate during the mandate, in fact he concentrates disproportionatly on it.

Like those before him, Kimmerling, Oz, Shlaim and Pappe they seek to lie and overturn the truth for its own sake and change facts and have history 'judge'. It is lies. Think about it. We knew in 1956 or at least Edgar O'Ballance knew the arabs had been evicted and expelled, did it take Morris to tell us? We knew in the 1950s about Dier Yassin and it took up large parts fo Kaufman and La Pierre's books. So what is so new. The 'collusion' with Jordan we knew about. What is new about the 'new' Historians. Nothing, just more hatred, more fact finding(on Morris's part) and more press.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home