Many problems with 'Pity of it all'
The book pity chronicles the German Jews from 1743-1933. It is written by acclaimed Israeli author Amos ELon who now lives in Italy becuase he hated Israel and his racist warped view of the world Israel was ruined by the 'dirty' sephardim and the Russians and the religious becuase they destroyed 'his country' in a sense he is just a German Jewish elitist racist who, like the German nazi theories, believes his view of the world is better and that how dare the people, the democracy challenge him, like a typical liberal he beleives only in democracy when it chooses leftists pacifists like himself, if it doesnt then its not 'democracy'.
Now his book reflects this idea in general. The writing is superb, poetic and beautiful. No doubt here.
However the models, the points made, the polemics put in between the pieces, is all crap. First of all he shows us how the 670,000 German Jews, the cream among them, were in fact traitors to their country, they preached pacisfism and they preached going along with reparations. Now thats all bunko. Maximilian Harder and others were preaching that the war was their fauillt, like the liberals in america they hated their own nation and they should have left it and I dont feel bad for them that they were killed by nazism , but in fact they were nott he pcifisit preaching, nonsense loving, society hating german intellectuals, Jews among them, escaped Geramny becuase of their wealth, as Germans starved in the street and one dallar was worht 4 billion marks they magically had fur coats and lived the good life like all RICH LIBERALS, and then they ran away after creating a republic that died, their pie int he sky ideas like teaching children to be pcifist and begging the european powers to like germany again werew what cuased the breakdown in germany, then they ran away after being the vultures that prayed on the coprse of their naiton and the Jews were murdered for their behavior.
After all it was their ultra intellectualism and their challenging eveyr norm in society, making berlina sexual cesspool of depravity where laws didnt extend to anyone, it was that that destorye dhte naiton. The conservative army elemtns were seen as the enmies by Amos and those he identified with but had they been employed against the extremes of nazism before it was too late everything would ahve been fine, but that state hating liberals destroyed the old imperial government in favour fo a weak repiblic and then proceeded to themselves hate the republic and call it weak, a republic they created and fianlly the simple people had had enough and thent nhe wrath came,. Cosnervative forces could have saved germany bu the liberals and nazis destroye dit and only simple peopel paid the price in the end of being sent off on far away wars campaigns and being gassed.
Amos judges wrongyl. He hates the zionists, but they were correect in calling on peopel to live and forcasting the end. He hates the right wing and the conservatives, and he worships einstines pacifism, well pacifiism is nice in science, but it doesnt owrk, how would pacifism have worked agains thitler, in fact the liberals tried it, they did nothing and they lost. THere were also leftist terorism, 90 murders during the time as compared to 574 right wing murders. Well it goes to show.
Yes Amos hates the Jews who didnt assimilate, he brags about those who did and those who converted and then he worhsips those tha tdestorye dthier naiton and their uber intelelctualism that rbought germany to its knees and he tries to paint this picture of them and how their world is the one he loved and he tries to ignore the millions of gemrans who voted for hitelr and doesnt want to condemn germas, it si all ap bunch of crap. But if pone can wade through the liberal anti-israel polemics(useing the word palestinians in a time when the only palestinians were jewish immigrants is one example), get thrugh his worshuiopping of the elefitst blubber and his hatred of religion, perhaps it is a wonderful book.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home