Debates on Israel and the Spanish Civil War
Noam Chomsky, famous Holocaust denier, and Alan Dershowitz, defense attorney for the murderer O.J Simpson, debated Israel yesterday at the John F. Kennedy School of government. This debate may not have been as scholarly or honorable as the famous Herzog-Toynbee debate in Canada in the 1960s, however it deserves mention. We have here two big minds debating a good topic. However what we really have is irrational-liberalism versus conservative style leftism. By all notions Dershowitz is a leftist, at least an old school leftist, despite his beleif that torture is acceptable to save lives. Chomsky is such a leftist that he supports Saudi Arabia, blames america for Sept. 11, compares Israel to Nazism, hates Vaclav Havel(the Czech dissident) becuase Havel likes America, and defended Holocaust deniers 'right to academic freedom'.
However we know that in the history of mankind Liberalism and Conservativism have only once been allowed to square off on equal footing against one another, and that wonderful moment was the Spanish civil war. Even if we take out the fascist/Nazi-versus-Stalinist/Communist confrontation that took place in tersm of support and supply we can see on the ground the true once in a lifetime confrontation between the forces of hateful liberalism and the forces of conservativism. The Spanish civil war was special. In most cases we have conservative governments suppressing liberalalism, or we have liberal-extremist governments committing atrocities on conservatives, or we have liberals infiltrating a democratic society to destroy it from within. A few examples will siffice. In the Iranian revolution radical leftists teamed up with 'revolutionary' Islamists and the leftists helped them against the conservative Shah(who dared beleive in womens rights) and in the end the Leftists destroyed from within by sending millions to die fighting Iraq, and ushering in the most backwards form of government the world has seen since the 15th century(of course with the exception of the Taliban and Saudi Arabia). Liberals worked from within to destroy womens rights and democracy.
In case number two we see the Soviet Union where extreme-liberalism executed and slaughtered the remnants of the conservative aristocracy and the peasentry, putting them in gulags or forcing them into flight.
In case number three we have regimes like Egypt or the Czech republic after Dubcec, imprisoning any voices for democracy, or we have China killing those demonstrators at Tien An Mien. This is the conservative regime murdering liberal voices. We have the same situation with Fidel Castro, a conservative(despite being a commie) killing pro-democracy voices.
In Israel and America of couse we have the phenomenon of the liberal who works from within to destroy his state.
However in Spain this was not the case. In the 1930s we had a series of elections that led first to a left wing government, then a right wing one and then another left wing one and then finally civil war. The left wing in spain was deeply extremist, the left leaning government contained socialists, anarchists and communists. It allowed in parts of the country for 'peoples courts' to take 'aristocrats' for traial and have them shot after hour long hearings by 'peasents committees' this peoples justice began executing all land owners in the countryside in some places. In the cities extreme leftist groups asaulted churches and raped nuns, murdering hundreds of preists. Militant unions took over the very places that provided them with work.
Against this backdrop the right wing and conervative forces remained powerless. Right wing elements existed in the paramilitary police units and also in the army. However half of the police force and army were ideologically leftist. At the same time fledgling parties such as monarchist militants and the fascist falange began to form in the countryside and cities to defend the traditional way of life. A large middle class catholic party formed. The rebellion of Franco and the 'nationalist' military units in 1936 ushered in war. However war was not just fought between the left wing and right wing military units. It was also fought between the civilian militias. And here we have the only instance where a conservative force was able to confront on the field of battle a liberal force. We see here the great battle between the forces of conervativism and liberalism. The war of religion versus secularism.
An ultimate test. In the end the 'republican' leftist government was defeated. For numerous reasons, not least of which was the stalinist line forced on it by Moscow, and the fact that its various parts fell into disorder and regionalism. We also see that the nationalists won because of greater financial backing, and much more useful and meaningful military support from Mussolinis italy and Nazi germany.
By no means are we neccesarily saying the nationalist victory was good. However we can safely assume that all worries of a nazi-Franco alliance were allayed in 1940 and after when Franco denied Hitler an alliance, and Franco in fact allowed 50,000 Jews safe entry,(clandestinely) into Spain.
Franco put the leftist prisoners to work building a massive monument to the nationalists who died in the war. We know that on both sides atrocities were committed. The leftists frequentyl killed all land owners in any town they over ran and killed any members of right wing parties, the right wing did the same when they entered a town, they killed all members of any union, socialist, anarchist or communist organization. They didnt however kill the peasents.
The Spanish civil war is the ultimate contest. It shows the true nature of extremism when it is loosed upon the state. It also shows how the conservative forces and elements have a ahrd tiemr esponding to leftist extremism becuase the conservative is not by his nature militant or extreme, when the conservative becomes extreme, he becomes revolutionary and in a strang eironic sense he therefore ends his association with conservatism.
Nov. 30, 2005 18:23 Updated Nov. 30, 2005 18:33Dershowitz and Chomsky battle it outBy MATT RAND
Two noted academics offered vastly different views on the history and path forward in the Arab-Israeli conflict recently as Alan Dershowitz and Noam Chomsky debated each other at Harvard's John F. Kennedy School of Government.
Whereas Chomsky claimed "Israeli rejectionism" was the source of Arab-Israeli tensions, Dershowitz derided the Palestinian rejection of the peace offer made to Yasser Arafat by Ehud Barak at Camp David.
Dershowitz also called on academics to stop demonizing Israel. "At the moment, I am sad to report that many academics around the world are contributing to an atmosphere that makes peace more difficult to achieve," Dershowitz said. "Thank G-d Israel has to make peace with the Palestinians, and not with the professors!" Dershowitz went on to say that peace "will require that both sides give up rights."
Chomsky and Dershowitz were each given ten minutes for opening remarks, followed by forty-five minutes for a question-and-answer session with the audience, and two minutes for closing statements.
To a skeptical audience however Dershowitz refuted Chomsky's line of attack.
"President Clinton told me directly and personally," Dershowitz said, "that the cause of the failure of the Camp David talks was the refusal of the Palestinians and Arafat to give up the right of return…It wasn't borders, it wasn't Jerusalem, it was the right of return… If you think America has rejected the two state solution, I say welcome to Planet Chomsky."
Chomsky rebutted by saying it was hard to trust hearsay. "You can believe what the [research] shows or you can believe what Mr. Dershowitz says someone told him," he said.
Chomsky suggested that Israel was "outside the international consensus." He argued the Israeli Supreme Court's decision to reject the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice is consistent with "Chief [Justice Aharon] Barak's doctrine that Israeli law supersedes international law particularly in eastern Jerusalem... and that is a violation of the security council's orders." Chomsky also claimed that there were "Jewish only" roads in the West Bank, later saying they were the "roads of the sovereign state of the Jewish people".
Dershowitz was skeptical. "I challenge you to find a place where it says Israeli Law trumps international law," he said to Chomsky. Dershowitz clarified that not only was the ICJ opinion non-binding, the other issue was that Israel could not accept a opinion from a court of which it was not allowed to participate.
Chomsky, who Dershowitz claimed was: "picking tidbits out of context, knowing that we are not going to check up on him," said Arab states and the PLO had attempted to make peace with Israel on a number of occasions. He alleged that in 1971 the Israeli government rejected a peace offer by assassinated Egyptian President Anwar Sadat. "Israel rejected the offer, choosing expansion over security…those decisions led to the 1973 war," Chomsky said.
Returning to his previous theme, Dershowitz assailed academics for making the Arab-Israeli conflict worse. "They [academics] are encouraging those who see the end of Israel as their ultimate goal to persist in their ideological terrorist campaign." He proposed a peace treaty among academics who purport to favor peace between Israel and the Palestinians.
Chomsky alleged that, in 1976, Israel rejected outright a peace offer by Arab states. He said Israel missed a later opportunity when, in 1988, the PLO went from "tacit approval to formal acceptance of the two state solution."
(Continued from page 1 of 2)
He also claimed that the negotiations at Camp David in 2000 foundered on territorial issues, not Palestinian refugees and their descendents "for which Arafat agreed to a pragmatic solution." "No Palestinian" could have accepted the Camp David offer, Chomsky said.
Dershowitz again refuted that logic. "Bill Clinton has told me," he said, "Dennis Ross has told me…it was completely in the hands of Arafat."
"Many of those who support the Palestinian cause [on campus] tend to be opposed virulently to Israel," said Dershowitz. "Most of those who support Israel are supportive of a peaceful Palestinian state."
Chomsky said ultimately the United States was to blame. "The [settlements] will continue as long as Washington insists on marching along the road to catastrophe…by rejecting minimal Palestinian rights. And if that march to catastrophe continues, we will only have ourselves to blame," Chomsky said.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home