Heroes of the right and other musings
New heroes of the right:
The right wing pantheon of heroes, such as Churchill and Cato the Elder and Axel Springer is added to forthwith:
Martin Noemoeller's quotation :
In Germany, they came first for the Communists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Communist. Then they came for the Jews and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist. Then they came for the Catholics and I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me and by that time no one was left to speak.
Hitler Came for Niemoeller: The Nazi War Against Religion (Paperback)by Norman Vincent Peale (Foreword), Leo Stein
Martin Niemoeller
(1892-1984)
Martin Niemoeller was a Protestant pastor born January 14, 1892, in Lippstadt, Westphalia. He was a submarine commander in World War I. He was anti-communist and initially supported the Nazis until the church was made subordinate to state authority.
In 1934, he started the Pastors’ Emergency League to defend the church. Hitler became angered by Niemoeller’s rebellious sermons and popularity and had him arrested on July 1, 1937. He was tried the following year and sentenced to seven months in prison and fined.
After his release, Hitler ordered him arrested again. he spent the next seven years in concentration camps in “protective custody.“ He was liberated in 1945 and was elected President of the Protestant church in Hesse and Nassau in 1947. He held the title until 1964. He was also a President of the World Council of Churches in the 1960’s.
Niemoeller was a pacifist who spoke out against nuclear weapons. He is best known for his powerful statement about the failure of Germans to speak out against the Nazis:
“First they came for the Communists, but I was not a Communist so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Socialists and the Trade Unionists, but I was neither, so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Jews, but I was not a Jew so I did not speak out. And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me.”
He died in Wiesbaden on March 6, 1984.
Source: Wistrich, Robert S. Who's Who in Nazi Germany. NY: Routledge Press, 1995.
www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/ jsource/biography/niemoeller.html
Col. Richard Meinertzhagen
http://66.249.93.104/search?q=cache:UzP2TlX9IqsJ:christianactionforisrael.org/isreport/mayjun04/meinertzhagen.html+meinertzhagen&hl=en
In Memoriam: Col. Richard MeinertzhagenMarch 3, 1878 - June 17, 1967By Joseph Alexander Norland - June 17, 2004
This article is a tribute to Col. Richard Meinertzhagen, marking the 37th anniversary of his passing away on June 17, 1967. Like Orde Charles Wingate, JH Patterson and Wyndham Deedes, Richard Meinertzhagen made vital contributions towards Jewish Nationhood in Mandatory Palestine, and through his books he continues to inspire.
Since I first posted the tribute to Col. Meinertzhagen on June 17, 2002, Israel’s situation has deteriorated considerably. At that time, Bush had not yet delivered the speech in which he endorsed the creation of a “Palestinian” state in Yesha (June 24, 2002), and the Roadmap was merely a vague threat. Sharon's surrender plan was not even a concept. Now, the Roadmap is being rammed down Israel’s throat, with daily demands being made on her for concessions; Sharon's surrender plan is becoming a lethal reality with every passing day.
With this in mind, remembering Richard Meinertzhagen is doubly important, for it calls to mind how non-Jews of good will can, should and must help our besieged sister-democracy, Israel.
May the example of Richard Meinertzhagen inspire others.
Synopsis:IntroductionA Thumbnail Sketch of Meinertzhagen’s lifeMeinertzhagen’s Support for ZionismA Personal NoteSources
IntroductionOn December 3, 1947, four days after the UN voted in favour of partition in Palestine, Dr Chaim Weizmann cabled Col. Richard Meinertzhagen to say, “To you dear friend we owe so much that I can only express it in simple words - May God Bless You”.
In his autobiography (see “sources” at article’s end), Chaim Weizmann refers to Col. Meinertzhagen in four instances; in one of these, Weizmann states, “Whenever he [Richard Meinertzhagen] can perform a service for the Jews or Palestine [,] he will go out of his way to do so.”
Who was Richard Meinertzhagen and why the accolades from a top Zionist leader who would become the first president of Israel?
A Thumbnail Sketch of Meinerzhagen’s lifeRichard Meinertzhagen was born to a prosperous, British family. To some, the name sounded Jewish, but as Meinertzhagen noted, “Maybe if I had Jewish blood in my veins, I might be more intelligent than I am; but there is none”.
Meinertzhagen aspired to become a scientist but had to submit to his father’s pressure and joined the family business at the age of 18. Six years later, he left the business to join the British army, became an intelligence officer, and rose to the rank of Colonel. In the course of his intelligence work, he experienced an encounter with anti-Semitism that left a lasting impression on him. In 1910, on his 32nd birthday, he was dining with the British Consul General in Odessa when a pogrom broke out. Meinertzhagen recorded in his diary:
“I have been shocked beyond belief. I have seldom been so angry... I witnessed a Pogrom in the streets of Odessa... Russians, many with bludgeons or knives or axes, were rushing all over the place, breaking open barricaded doors and chasing the wretched Jews into the streets where they were hunted down, beaten and often killed... The climax arrived when a Russian passed the Consulate dragging a Jewish girl of about 12 years old by her hair along the gutter; she was screaming and the man was shouting. I have no doubt she would have been outraged and then murdered. I could not help it... I dashed out, kicked the Russian violently in the stomach with my heavy Russian boots and landed him a good blow on the jaw; he went down like a log and I carried the child into the Consulate... I am deeply moved by these terrible deeds and have resolved that whenever or wherever I can help the Jews, I shall do so to the best of my ability.”As luck would have it, the opportunity to keep his word came in the seven-year period, 1917-1924.
In May, 1917, Meinertzhagen arrived in Cairo to join General Allenby’s Intelligence Section. In this context he became acquainted with the realities of the Jewish settlement of Palestine and with the support given by the Jews to the Allies in World War I. His life-long support for Zionism started in this period. As for the Arab support for the Allies, On December 2, 1917, Meinertzhagen recorded as follows:
“The Arabs of Ramleh gave us an amusing incident yesterday which accurately reflects their attitude towards us. A large batch of Turkish prisoners was being marched through the village but they were not preceded by their British Guard. The Arabs, thinking it was the return of the Turkish Army, turned out in force, yelling with delight and waving Turkish flags: it was not till the end of the column appeared and they saw British soldiers with fixed bayonets that they realized their mistake and great was their confusion.”Following Allenby’s capture of Jerusalem in December 1917, Meinertzhagen was assigned to the War Office in London, and subsequently became a member of the British Delegation to the Paris Peace Conference, with responsibility for the Middle East. This work brought him in close contact with Zionist leaders such as Weizmann and with Arab leaders such as Feisal, son of the Sheriff of Mecca and brother of King Abdullah I of Jordan.
Next came his nine-month assignment as Allenby’s Chief Political Officer, beginning in September, 1919, and spanning the period of the 1920 Arab riots against the Jews. As will be detailed in the next section, his crucial support for Palestine’s Jews against the overt anti-Semitism of the British administration, cost him his job.
Following this assignment, Meinertzhagen was appointed to the Colonial Office under Winston Churchill, where he encountered and documented the anti-Semitism of the Colonial Office and the extent of the British betrayal of Zionism. He quit the Colonial Office in March, 1924, to rejoin his regiment.
The British army had changed since Meinertzhagen departed in 1912, and he no longer felt at home. In 1926, at the age of 48, he decided, therefore, to resign his military commission and devote his time to “natural history” and travel. Indeed, he became famous as an amateur ornithologist, with books and an extensive collection to his credit. His retirement was interrupted during WW II, when, at the age of 61, he was recalled to the War Office and worked in intelligence planning. During that period Meinertzhagen also joined the Home Guard and participated in the Dunkirk evacuation.
His support for Zionism and his contact with Zionist leaders continued throughout his life, as did his friendship with Weizmann, until Weizmann’s death in November, 1952.
Meinertzhagen married in 1921 and fathered two sons and a daughter. His wife of seven years died in an accident in 1928, and his eldest son, Daniel, was killed in action in October, 1944. In 1964, reflecting on his life and on the world around him, Meinertzhagen wrote, according to his biographer, John Lord, “We are now entering a world if indecision, dishonesty and irresponsibility, a world I shall not be sorry to leave”. In 1967, at the age of 89, Col. Richard Meinertzhagen died, shortly after Israel’s decisive victory in the 1967 War.
Meinertzhagen’s Support for Zionism
As a public servant in the War Office, Meinertzhagen considered it his duty to execute the official British policy. At a meeting on February 7, 1918, he therefore queried Lord Balfour, the foreign minister, as to the meaning of the Balfour Declaration, which was issued only three months earlier. Meinhertzhagen recorded Balfour’s response and the subsequent discussion:
“[Balfour:] ‘Both the Prime Minister [David Lloyd George] and myself have been influenced by a desire to give the Jews their rightful place in the world; a great nation without a home is not right.' I said I was glad to hear that. I then asked, 'At the back of your mind do you regard this declaration as a charter for ultimate Jewish sovereignty in Palestine or are you trying to graft a Jewish population on to an Arab Palestine?' Balfour waited some time before he replied, choosing his words carefully. 'My personal hope is that the Jews will make good in Palestine and eventually found a Jewish State. It is up to them now; we have given them their great opportunity’. “As Meinertzhagen soon observed, however, the “facts on the ground” were very different from the vision Balfour enunciated; the diary entry for 17 March 1918, eight months before the Allies’ victory, records:
“There are already signs of serious anti-Semitism in Whitehall and efforts to stultify the Balfour Declaration.”By the time Meinertzhagen joined the British delegation at the Paris Peace Conference, he supported Zionism for more reasons than the Balfour Declaration being official British policy. On February 12, 1919 he recorded his reasons:
“In the first place I regard the position of the Jews in the world mosaic of nations as most unsatisfactory. That a great people like the Jews should not have a house of their own is a monstrous injustice. They must not only have a home but it must be their own where they can exercise sovereign rights. Secondly, a contented prosperous Jewish people in Palestine would lend great strength to the British Empire in the Middle East.”In modern parlance, the second reason would be rephrased to mean that a Jewish state in the Middle East is a major asset to Western democracies, a point that many have not grasped to this day.
While at the Paris Peace Conference, Meinertzhagen was instrumental in drafting Feisal’s letter to Felix Frankfurter (a leading US Zionist), dated Mar 1, 1919; the letter stated, inter alia:
“We Arabs, especially the educated among us, look with the deepest sympathy on the Zionist movement. Our deputation here in Paris is fully acquainted with the proposals submitted yesterday by the Zionist Organization to the Peace Conference, and we regard them as moderate and proper. We will do our best, in so far as we are concerned, to help them through: we will wish the Jews a most hearty welcome home.
“With the chief of your movement, especially with Dr Weizmann, we have had and continue to have the closest relations. He has been a great helper of our cause and I hope the Arabs may soon be in a position to make the Jews some return for their kindness. We are working together for a reformed and revived Near East, and our two movements complete one another.”
Meinertzhagen was soon to learn just how savagely the embryonic Jewish/Arab co-operation was sabotaged by the British officials in the Middle East. Within days of his work as Chief Political Advisor to General Allenby, Meinertzhagen learnt that the British military staff (who ran Palestine’s affairs) refused Weizmann entry into Palestine. Regarding this prohibition as “monstrous”, Meinertzhagen secured an explicit order from the Foreign Office to revoke the prohibition and Weizmann was allowed into Palestine.. This particular episode is also mentioned in Weizmann’s autobiography.
While foreshadowing events to come, this incident pales by comparison to the events that occurred just a few months later. In April 1920, during Easter week, Arab riots, instigated by some officials of the British military government, broke out. Upon investigation and verification, Meinertzhagen wrote to inform the Foreign Office on April 14, 1920; in his own words:
“I recorded that the officers of the administration are, almost without exception, anti-Zionist in their views and are encouraging the Arabs. Zionism is being brought into the world as a discontented child, accustomed only to trouble and disappointments.... The Arabs are encouraged and imagine that by acts of violence they can sabotage Zionism... It was known that Easter is the season of disturbances. It was known that the police were untrustworthy... The aftermath of these events is typical. The Moslems formally demanded the removal of the Zionist Commission...”.
Meinertzhagen went on to record the details of the British perfidy: Col. Waters-Taylor of Allenby’s staff was in contact with haj Amin el Husseini (later the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and a Nazi collaborator), and encouraged him to use the Easter occasion to show the world that Palestine’s Muslims will not tolerate the Zionists. Waters-Taylor explained that if the disturbances were sufficiently violent, Allenby would use them to advocate the abandonment of the “Jewish National Home”. To ensure the riots took place, Waters-Taylor even informed Husseini that the Jews intended to assassinate him.
Essentially, Meinertzhagen, a colonel, accused the staff of his superior, General Allenby, of contravening the official British policy of support for Zionism. The consequences, which Meinertzhagen had foreseen, were a compliment for his honesty, and dismissal for his insubordination; both occurred the very next day. In the course of sacrificing his career to support the Zionist enterprise, Meinertzhagen succeeded in convincing London to terminate the military administration in Palestine and install a civil government with Herbert Samuel as High Commissioner. In his diary, Meinertzhagen wrote:
“Allenby clamoured for my removal and I go, but meanwhile I have done what I set out to do, namely, I have set Zionism up in Palestine against a solid block of local opposition... Both the War Office and the Foreign Office tried to uphold me but Allenby’s threat to resign forced them to recall me and abolish my appointment... However, I achieved my objective... The military administration fell... Palestine is freed from the anti-Zionist policy of its enemies... Zionism is forever rooted in the soil of the Holy Land... Zionism need not waste its thanks on British Officials out here. They have all worked against it, hoping to crush it at its birth...”.Subsequently, working in London for the Colonial Office, Meinertzhagen remained in contact with the affairs of Palestine and Zionism. In particular, the British mandate over Palestine had to sail through the machinations of the League of Nations, a voyage that ended only on 22 July 1922. On this occasion he observed:
“I am more pleased than I can say at the passing of the Mandate. It will once and for all convince the Arabs and their English friends that the Zionist policy has come to stay and that all their obstruction has been of no avail”.Many years later Meinertzhagen reflected:
“The Balfour Declaration grants to the Jews a right to establish their national home in Palestine. Every obstacle has been placed in their way by successive British Governments. Then Churchill in 1921 hands over Transjordan, an integral part of Palestine, to an Arab sheikh who is made a 'king'. Then Bevin, unable to keep order in Palestine and influenced by anti-Semitism in his office, scuttles out of Palestine leaving the Jews at the mercy of six Arab States who promptly invade Palestine and attempt what Bevin wished, to drive the Jews into the sea. Israel had to fight for her life in 1948, and lost much land including the whole of eastern Palestine, Old Jerusalem and the Gaza strip.”During the period 1945-1948, the Jewish underground was engaged in a war against the British government. Underground fighters who were caught were subject to capital punishment, and in one case the underground kidnapped two British sergeants as hostages against further executions of their men. In July 1947, the British executed three more underground fighter and the underground made good on its threat by executing the two kidnapped sergeants. Torn between loyalties, Meinhertzhagen observed:
“I am terribly sorry for those two men who only did their duty and I am terribly sorry for our soldiers in Palestine who have to carry out this revolting policy of the Government. The real men responsible for the killing of those two sergeants are the politicians who sit in Downing Street, the Government of this country and ultimately the British public. All my sympathy is with the Jews who have been driven by apathy, anti-Semitism and broken promises into a state of exasperation. If I were a Jew I should be a terrorist, a violent one, and I would aim at Whitehall”.As the Israeli war of independence ended and Israel prevailed, Meinertzhagen greeted her triumph thus:
“But thank God I have lived to see the birth of Israel. It is one of the greatest historical events of the last 2,000 years and thank God I have been privileged to assist in a small way this great event which, I am convinced, will bring benefit to mankind”.
During the years 1949-1956, Israel was subjected to terrorist attacks to which she responded with reprisals. Meinertzhagen was not blind to these developments and commented in his diary entry of 18 October 1953:
“On the night of the l4th, some Israeli troops raided into Jordan and beat up the villages of Qibya and Shuqba; ... forty-two men, women and children were killed and some forty houses destroyed. This is most deplorable but I can quite understand the factors which had led Israel to take such drastic action. Raids by Arabs from Jordan into Israel during the past four years have led to the murder of nearly 500 Jews and the theft of much valuable property. Neither the Jordan Government nor the Mixed Armistice Commission have been able to control or check these raids into Israel who was left no other course but to teach the Arabs a lesson...”
When the 1956 Suez/Sinai war broke out, the 79-year old Meinertzhagen was following the events carefully, his heart with Israel. His diary comment on October 29, 1956 reads:
“Israel has launched an offensive against Egypt, penetrating far into Sinai... Well done Israel! I am delighted and thrilled... I hope Israel will go forward”.
In the following months, Israel was subjected to brutal pressure to withdraw unconditionally, i.e., with no security guaranties. In his diary entry of January 19, 1957, Meinertzhagen commented on this injustice:
“When Egypt flouted the United Nations and closed the Canal and the Gulf of Aqaba to Israeli shipping, though this constituted an act of aggression, no action was taken, and when the Egyptian Government trained and used bands of fedayeen (bandits) to raid and murder in Israel, the United Nations did nothing.”
In February, 1957, as the pressure increased, Meinertzhagen observed:
“...every device of pressure is being used to rob Israel of the safety which her army recently won for her in Sinai... I am sick of the whole business which distresses me acutely”.
In June 1957, shortly after Israel withdrew from Sinai and Egypt walked into Gaza in defiance of the agreement with the UN, Meinertzhagen reflected:
“For many years the West has made the error of thinking Arab friendship can be gained by political appeasement with economic and military gifts and loans. This glaring fallacy has been exposed on many occasions but the policy persists... No amount of appeasement will make any Arab State love us; they hate us; but worse, they despise us. We should not mind hatred, but we can make them respect us”.
These very words apply today too. In fact, reading through Meinertzhagen’s published diaries, one is constantly aware of deja vu. This is perhaps the most important and the saddest conclusion one comes to on the 36th anniversary of his death.
A Personal Note
It is quite inappropriate that I interject into this tribute to Col. Meinertzhagen a personal note, akin to “Me and Meinertzhagen” of primary school days. And yet, I cannot conclude without underscoring the impact that Col. Meinertzhagen’s ”Diary” (see reference below) on my own education. At the end of July 2000, after Arafat had walked out on the peace offer submitted by then Prime Minister Barak, I embarked on researching the Middle East conundrum. Seeking initially works by non-Jewish and non-Arab authors, I came across Meinertzhagen’s Diary. Quite apart from the information imparted, I was deeply inspired by the author’s attachment to the Zionist project, and I have never ceased quoting his words,
“But thank God I have lived to see the birth of Israel. It is one of the greatest historical events of the last 2,000 years and thank God I have been privileged to assist in a small way this great event which, I am convinced, will bring benefit to mankind”.
In this respect, I concur with one correspondent who wrote to me, “From my readings elsewhere I believe you are by no means the only reader who’s been similarly inspired by "Middle East Diary", and for that alone RM deserves to be applauded. In that respect he has done and continues to do good works for the Zionist effort.”
Sources
Most of this piece is based primarily on the following two sources:Meinertzhagen, Richard. Middle East Diary. London: Cresset Press, 1959; Lord, John. Duty, Honour, Empire. New York: Random House, 1970.
The first book consists of entries culled form the 70 volumes that Col. Meinertzhagen had compiled by 1958.
The citations from Weizmann’s autobiography were culled from:
Weizmann, Chaim. Trial and Error. New York: Harper, 1949.
It is more than obvious that autobiographies, as well as biographies, are based on agenda, and absolute fidelity to historical facts may or may not be one of the items on the agenda. In fact, following up on one particular detail, the origin of the Meinertzhagen family, I was made aware by the family members currently living in Britain, that the family originated in Germany, and not in Denmark, as stated by both Richard Meinertzhagen and Chaim Weizmann. The case of the family origin confirms the obvious: facts have to be verified through independent sources and the reasons for the inaccuracies must be explored. In fact, the reasons for this inaccurate claim are interesting , though less than significant for the purpose of outlining Richard Meinertzhagen’s contribution to the Zionist endeavour. Meinertzhagen’s “Diary” remains an inspiring document even if many of the details cannot be verified.
Several Web sites provided additional material. A Google search under “Richard Meinertzhagen” yields a rich crop of such sites.
Rahavam Zeevi, known as "Gandi"(Rachavam Zeevi)
Orde Wingate: http://members.aol.com/ordewingate/israel.html
W ingate spent the first several months living in Haifa, and eventually was based in Jerusalem as part of the General Headquarters staff. From both places he traveled all over northern Palestine gathering information, studying the situation. As intelligence officer Wingate studied the tactics of the Arab guerillas who were striking Jews in Palestine and evading successfully British troops. He ventured across northern Palestine to discover Arab arms smuggling routes, including traveling to border areas. Several times he clandestinely observed the movement of rebels and arms crossing the border without being detected. He visited Jewish communities and was struck by the activities and accomplishments of the Yishuv. He became deeply impressed by their energy, by their actions to bring prosperity to the land, intrigued by their establishing of distant settlements in strategic locations. He began to take a strong interest in all things Jewish, from developing friendships to trying to learn Hebrew.
photo captionSabotaged railway line in Palestine. By mid-1938 much of the village countryside in the northern half of the country was falling under control of the rebels, with even towns being raided.Photo courtesy of the Imperial War Museum, London
Respect grew for the spiritual actions of the Zionists who were working to fulfill the prophecies of the return of the Jews to the land of Israel. Being in the Holy Land also was bringing a special meaning to him, the history & impact of which he had grown up with and studied. "He saw the Bible not as a prayer book, but as a history of a great people who had lived in Palestine & have now returned to the country again." (General Yigal Yadin in Haganah Museum doc. 143-12) Orde Wingate fell in love with and grew committed to the Zionist goal. He declared "When I came to Palestine, I found a whole people who had been looked down upon and made to feel unwanted for scores of generations, and yet at the end of it, they were undefeated and building their country anew. I felt I belonged to such a people." (Sykes, p.110) Wingate wanted to help the Jews in Palestine fight to defend themselves & fulfill their Zionist dream. Soon after his arrival in Palestine he began making contacts with the Jewish leadership.
He slowly worked to overcome the hesitant distrust towards himself. A meeting was arranged with one of the more prominent Jews in Haifa, David HaCohen. The two men discussed Zionism and at the end Wingate asked to be given a chance to prove himself to the Jewish community. Wingate told HaCohen that "I count it my privilege to help you fight your battle. To that purpose I want to devote my life." (Sykes, p.112) Another man Wingate met with was Emanuel Wilenski. Wilenski was the chief intelligence officer of the Haganah. Wingate told him the Jewish Agency's policy of self-restraint was wrong and that passive defensive measures were impractical now. Wilenski was surprised to hear Wingate declare that the Jews were practically in a war and that it was his ambition to lead a Jewish army in the battles ahead. Wilenski came away afterwards feeling Wingate was the most remarkable man he had ever met. Afterward Wingate soon made friends with the top Jewish leaders. The secretary of the Jewish Agency (future prime minister of Israel) Moshe Sharrett was one with whom he formed a strong friendship with. He met David Ben-Gurion (Zionist leader and future prime minister) and became close to Chaim Weizmann, the Zionist movement's leader (future Israeli president).
Military Ideas
While impressed with the devotion and willingness to sacrifice in the Haganah members, Wingate was exasperated by the defensive nature of the Jewish forces. He realized that the Jewish forces could not halt the violence with their defensive tactics of fortified settlements alone, nor could the British with their static defenses and conventional patrols. Wingate thought there was a better way to bring an end to violence against both the British presence and Jewish community, and stabilize the colony. In 1938 clashes between marauding Arabs & British forces were being instigated at the guerillas behalf, they had the initiative. Many local villagers, herders and office informants were acting as the eyes and ears of the guerillas. Arab guerillas would strike and then slip away often with the aid of some of the locals. They moved about freely at night, able to operate near and in villages which they would assault for supplies and terrorize for control. Raiders and arms were now also infiltrating across the border from neighboring Lebanon & Syria despite British efforts to stop the flow. British mobile columns and patrols were consistent & routine in their movements & their actions, and aerial bombing ineffective. Commented one Jewish official on a big sweep by British forces, "They marched over hills and valleys, and in the end emerged with some rusty Turkish pistols and a few empty rounds of ammunition...The Arab gangsters just hid their arms and mingled with the population of the villages. Not only did the huge British army find absolutely nothing, it discredited and ridiculed itself in the eyes of the whole population." (Royle, p.118) One British colonial official put it, "Our intelligence was haphazard and patchy, and consequently much of our military effort against the rebels was clumsy & misdirected." (Foot, p.52)
photo captionGeneral Wavell, commander in Palestine. He was to have a significant role in all three military campaigns Wingate fought in.Photo courtesy of the Imperial War Museum, London
Wingate envisioned carefully selected, small and mobile units of volunteers to fight aggressively and unconventionally. A report prepared at a future date (date June 5th, 1938 and titled: "Secret Appreciation of Possibilities of Night Movements by Armed Forces of the Crown - With Object of Putting an end to Terrorism in Northern Palestine") spelled out formally the need for a unique military force. "There is only one way to deal with the situation, to persuade the gangs that, in their predatory raids, there is every chance of their running into a government gang which is determined to destroy them." (Wingate in Haganah Museum doc.80-69-26) They were to carry the war to the enemy, taking away his initiative and keeping him off-balance. "And to produce in their minds the belief government forces will move at night and can and will surprise them either in villages or across country." (Wingate in Haganah Museum doc.80-69-26) The force would be a mixed British-Jewish one under his command, operating primarily at night with the allies of the night: deception, surprise and shock. The Jewish population he saw was an untapped source of intelligence, security and manpower. Instead of being stationed at British police or military bases he saw the force based at Jewish communities. The Jewish police and the Haganah had good contacts among both the Jewish and Arab populations, providing consistent and reliable intelligence. They were familiar with the land. And by being based at Jewish settlements the force would remain secure in planning and movements, and to avoid having their movements easily monitored. He felt that they could make excellent soldiers, better than the average British one, with their motivation and resources. The regular British forces had the formal military training, the equipment and official support. The name of the new unit was to be the Special Night Squads or SNS.
Earning Trust
Captain Wingate set about getting his ideas implemented against official disapproval of arming Jews. His openly pro-Jewish beliefs, disdain for military hierarchy, disheveled professional appearance contributed, with the belief that Jews were not a martial race, to factors working against him. Several papers were written and distributed within British Jerusalem headquarters of the potential effectiveness of a mixed British-Jewish force matched with unconventional tactics. The commander of the field brigade Wingate was formally attached to, Brigadier Evetts, was busy during all hours trying to push out mobile columns and block the Syrian border with static forces and the construction of a wire fence. Evetts showed an interest in his ideas and encouraged him. In the spring of 1938 General Archibald Wavell was the commander of British military forces in Palestine. In order to circumnavigate the staff at headquarters that was opposed to his ideas, he sought a way to directly meet Wavell. Investigating the route & timing of his journey while the general was visiting military bases, Wingate made sure he was there to step in front of his car one day. Not bothered by the ingenuity of Wingate's approach as the later climbed in, Wavell listened as Captain Wingate articulated his ideas. His initial reaction was that Wingate was "an odd creature." (Connell, p.196) Wavell was not sympathetic to Zionism, but he did recognize the intelligence of the plan to overcome a sense of defensiveness and break the guerillas. Wavell gave his approval.
Wingate next turned to the Jewish leadership to overcome their hesitancy. Both Wilenski and HaCohen found it difficult to convince others that this British soldier was different and could be an ally. Many of the Yishuv leadership were openly skeptical toward them. Mutual distrust between the Jewish and British sides was strong. British anti-Semitism was common and often openly expressed, and British officers were serving with Arab military units. While Wingate had the support of Weizmann and Wilenski, he had to fight to get active cooperation. Some Jewish leaders were opposed to changing the policy of restraint, suspicious of this British officer who was asking for the best men of the Haganah to take aggressive action. One day Wingate went to the head of the Jewish Agency in Jerusalem and shouted at him "Why do you flirt with your enemies and ignore your friends?" (Sykes, p.144) Eventually suspicions cooled & Yitzhak Sadeh, the Haganah leader, came to trust in Wingate's sincerity. He ordered the Haganah to cooperate with Wingate.
photo captionYitzhak Sadeh, military chief of the Haganah in the 1930s and 1940s (and former Russian military officer). He stated of Wingate with his active mind always thinking, "If he had not gone in for a military career, he would undoubtedly have been equally successful in any other field."(Haganah museum doc.80.137.3)Photo courtesy of theIsraeli Ministry ofDefense, Museum Unit
photo captionJewish Supernumerary Police arriving at the site where they would begin to help build the settlement of Hanita.photo courtesy of theIsrael GovernmentPress Office
Wingate's work would expand upon and greatly improve the work being done by Sadeh. Under Sadeh's direction, the Haganah was beginning to re-organize to improve its military effectiveness. A few Haganah men were slowly being taught to patrol in small units and in more remote areas. Haganah daytime patrols moved along dirt paths and at night set up small ambushes and launching pre-emptive strikes. A small training program was being created to help teach basic military field craft and tactics. But Sadeh was facing resistance from his superiors about changing the strategy of passive military defense. The policy of restraint meant the Haganah ceding the initiative and mobility to the Arab guerillas. Said one future Israeli Army chief-of-staff, "The fact was that, up to Wingate's time, those leading the Haganah were neither scientists in warfare nor artists in warfare, but simply amateurs who had to do what they did for lack of alternative." (General Yigal Yadin in Haganah Museum doc.143-12) Wingate's arrival and subsequent success would help to turn the fortunes for the Haganah. Sadeh put it as "For some time we did the same things as Wingate, but on a smaller scale and with less skill. We followed parallel paths, until he came to us, and in him we found our leader." (Allon, p.10)
In March of 1938 the Jewish Agency decided to build a fortified settlement at Hanita in the north next to the Lebanese border. It was picked because it would help fortify the Jewish presence in the Galilee. From here Jewish forces hope to help seal a border crossing being used by the Arab raiders infiltrating from Lebanon. Hundreds feverishly worked on the "stockade and watchtower" project on the rocky ground. During the first night they were attacked with rifle fire. Such attacks went on for several days, with the Arabs striking and then retreating at will. The Jewish force was unable to successfully entrap them before they reached the border. A successful action led by two young leaders Yigal Allon & Moshe Dayan did strike at the marauders hard eventually. Into this situation in April Wingate arrived with a letter from the Haganah headquarters asking to be shown around.
Wingate brought an energy and direction into the Jewish force. His arrival at Hanita produced created a tremendous impression from the first. Bringing with him a pair of rifles and a dictionary, his trip through dangerous northern territory was the first to come alone during the night. One of the soldiers listening and watching Wingate intensely at Hanita was Dayan. "When he spoke, he looked you straight in the eye as someone who seeks to imbue you with his own faith and strength," remembered Dayan. (Dayan, p.45) Assigned to watch him closely, Zvi Brenner remembered how "I slept in a tent with him so as to watch his steps...In those days no-one was allowed to leave the settlement without the express permission of the commander, but Wingate used to disappear and return after a couple of hours. We had meanwhile searched [for] him in vain while he had thoroughly explored the vicinity." (Haganah Museum doc.11-16)
photo captionA stockade and watchtower settlement similar to the one at Hanita. Hundreds would prepare the groundwork for a settlement in secret. Then working non-stop, in 24 hours the bases of a settlement would be constructed. The first priority were the fortifications (barracks, watchtower, wooden walls) prepared for defense against the expected Arab attacks.photo courtesy of theIsrael GovernmentPress Office
With the authority given to him by the British and Haganah authorities, Wingate was finally able to get the Haganah forces to undertake the aggressive action Sadeh had been trying to push through unsuccessfully. He met with the Haganah commanders and spoke to them about the need for forward mobile, defense. "Instead of defending the colony from inside, we should go out and meet the enemy in the open, near his villages. This was something entirely new for us, and we had still no experience in that kind of warfare, " said Zvi Brenner. (Haganah Museum doc.11-16) One night gathering the force together, he spoke to them of the success of his efforts and tactics in the Sudan. He spoke initially in Hebrew, but was forced to switch to English as his audience could not understand his accent. They did understand the biblical quotations he had interlaced in his speech. He said they would go out that night and set an ambush he planned on a map near an Arab village to catch the attackers as they were moving, to strike first. The Haganah were thinking defense of the settlement meant being near the settlement, not at an ambush near the exit from an Arab village, a new concept. Under Wingate's instructions the force, which included Sadeh, marched along hill ridges, not the paths. He insisted upon walking ahead of the force to scout. Nearing the targeted village, he split the force into two groups a hundred yards apart so as to get any armed raiders in a crossfire. Though no hostile Arabs appeared that night, the idea was important. The British captain began to lead patrols and ambushes in the area.
Into the spring of 1938 the guerilla war and terrorism campaign continued, especially in the north. The rebels were without a central command structure for coordination and strategic decisions, due to political and personal rivalries, and arms were often of poor quality. But the could enjoy information and supplies from across the spectrum of Arab population from villagers to policemen, and cross-border smuggling ensured a supply of weapons. While numbering no more than 1500 active guerilla fighters backed by thousands more part-time combatants, they were seriously disrupting civil administration, communications and control. (Cohen & Kolinsky, p.182) Military action and terrorist bombings were continuing to put civilians at risk as much as soldiers, with colonial officials targeted for assassination. For several months in a row now, each month saw hundreds of terrorist acts, dozens of murders and attempted assassinations. (Cohen & Kolinsky, p.154-5) The Yishuv was beginning to suffer heavy casualties from guerilla raids and terrorist acts, for the next several months averaging some 50 deaths per month. (Teveth, p.97) Now saboteurs were striking at the British Iraqi Petroleum Company's oil pipeline. Running through the northern Galilee region where it met the port of Haifa, the attacks were concentrated in the eastern region and against communications nearby. No reinforcements were on the immediate way with the threat of war approaching in Europe. With these factors in mind, in May the new British commander in Palestine, General Haining, reluctantly gave the order to continue the forming of the SNS to put a stop to this and other acts of terror.
Sanjay Gandhi
Some other musings:
How the liberal argues: the liberal uses fake statistics and fallacious argument against others. he cites statistics and challenges you by saying "have you been poor" as if to say if you have not experinced then you cannot speak. Then the liberal calls 'racist' and gets offended.
Carriers of the torch: the dialectic of conservative thought: The conservative is not revolutionary, he is a minority. The liberal fakes being aminority to construct the feeling fo persecution and the liberal infects the masses, the conservative relies on the fact that the masses are by their nature conservative but does not seek to revolutionize them. The cosnervative seeks ot carry the torch, to save the nation. The liberal seeks to create moral relativism, and relativism is the recipe for the end, the dark age, the nation that first becomes relative is hte one that dies fisrt for it accepts its weakness and inherent badness and the other then wins becuase the other is nationalistic, liberalism offers no solution to nationalsim, and it cannot compete, the liberal in every great socety, when the society is challenged by diversity and when the society becomes global, then the relaitvist ideas comes out and then they infect society, for they tell us that all are equal and then they tell us to accept and then the ntion that does not accept wins. the conservative has no answer to this, but all throughout history the great conwservatives fought relentless war, such as Ayn Rand or Winston Churchill, or Cato the elder against the liberal. Teh era of romance is over today. Can it be redeemed. The liebral convinces us that we must not become savage and barbaric and sink to lower ourselves to the depths of the other, but we must lower ourselves and become them in order to defeat them, but we do not actually become them becuase our essense remains. Our superiority remains. The conservative carries the torch, he cannot reconcile his want to lead the masses and the fact hat he dreads revolution. He treads cataclysm and genocide and persecution, he dreads utopian ideals. Realism is his way, but he does no know whether to be isolationist or global, he fears globalism, he fears ht einternationalc omunity for in it are the seeds of destruction.
Al Sieber said "If I had been apache I would be geronimo" but he fought the apaches. This is the conservative way.
The trifecta: Arendt and Heidegger, Nazism and Liberalism together at last.
The affair of these two can only finally show evidence of the tru connection between liberal thought and Nazi thought. The fact that Hanna beleived evil was merely 'banal' in a snense normal and in a sense therefore we are all nazis and therefore there is no good or evil or right or wrong. Had they had a child we could conclusivelly show that that child, their offspring, would be the true combination of the liberal and the nazi, thus the proof.
Hannah Arendt (October 14, 1906 – December 4, 1975) had an affair with Martin Heidegger (1889-1976)
A biography follows my thoughts:
http://66.249.93.104/search?q=cache:5UpKOljMxSMJ:en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannah_Arendt+Hannah+Arendt&hl=en
Hannah Arendt (October 14, 1906 – December 4, 1975) was a German political theorist. She had often been described as a philosopher, although she always refused that label on the grounds that philosophy is concerned with "man in the singular." She described herself instead as a political theorist because her work centers on the fact that "men, not Man, live on the earth and inhabit the world."
Born of secular Jewish parents in the then independent city Linden now Hanover and raised in Königsberg (the hometown of her admired precursor Immanuel Kant) and Berlin, Arendt studied philosophy with Martin Heidegger at the University of Marburg. She had a long, sporadic romantic relationship with Heidegger, something that has been criticised due to his Nazi sympathies. During one of their breakups, Arendt moved to Heidelberg to write a dissertation on the concept of love in the thought of Saint Augustine, under the direction of the existentialist philosopher-psychologist Karl Jaspers.
The dissertation was published in 1929, but Arendt was prevented from habilitating (and thus from teaching in German universities) in 1933 because she was a Jew, and thereupon fled Germany for Paris, where she met and befriended the literary critic and Marxist mystic Walter Benjamin. While in France, Arendt worked to support and aid Jewish refugees. However, with the German military occupation of parts of France following the French declaration of war during World War II, and the deportation of Jews to concentration camps, Hannah Arendt had to flee from France. In 1940, she married the German poet and philosopher Heinrich Blücher. In 1941, Hannah Arendt emigrated with her husband and her mother to the United States with the assistance of the American journalist Varian Fry. She then became active in the German-Jewish community in New York and wrote for the weekly Aufbau.
After World War II she resumed relations with Heidegger, and testified on his behalf in a German denazification hearing. In 1950, she became a naturalized citizen of the United States, and in 1959 became the first female appointed a full professorship at Princeton.
Hannah Arendt late in life
Arendt's work deals with the nature of power, and the subjects of politics, authority, and totalitarianism. Much of her work focuses on affirming a conception of freedom which is synonymous with collective political action. Arguing against the liberal assumption that "freedom begins where politics ends," Arendt theorizes freedom as public and associative, drawing on examples from the Greek polis, American townships, the Paris Commune, and the civil rights movements of the 1960's (among others) to illustrate this conception of freedom. In her reporting of the Eichmann trial for The New Yorker, which evolved into the book Eichmann in Jerusalem, she raised the question whether evil is radical or simply a function of banality -- the tendency of ordinary people to obey orders and conform to mass opinion without critically thinking about the results of their action or inaction.
She also wrote The Origins of Totalitarianism, which traced the roots of communism and fascism and their link to anti-semitism. This book was controversial because it compared two subjects that some believed were irreconcilable.
On her death in 1975, Hannah Arendt was buried at Bard College in Annandale-on-Hudson, New York, where her husband taught for many years.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Heidegger
Martin Heidegger (September 26, 1889 – May 26, 1976) was a German philosopher. He studied at the University of Freiburg under Edmund Husserl, the founder of phenomenology, and became a professor there in 1928. He influenced many other major philosophers, and his own students at various times included Hans-Georg Gadamer, Hans Jonas, Emmanuel Levinas, Hannah Arendt, Leo Strauss, Xavier Zubiri and Karl Löwith. Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Jean-Paul Sartre, Jacques Derrida, Michel Foucault, Jean-Luc Nancy, and Philippe Lacoue-Labarthe also studied his work more or less closely. Beyond his relation to phenomenology, Heidegger is regarded as a major or indispensable influence on existentialism, deconstruction, hermeneutics and postmodernism. He attempted to reorient Western philosophy away from metaphysical and epistemological and toward ontological questions, that is, questions concerning the meaning of being, or what it means to be.
Contents[hide]
1 Early life and education
2 Philosophy
2.1 Being and Time
2.2 Later works
2.3 Influences and difficulties of French reception
2.4 Criticism
3 Heidegger and Nazi Germany
3.1 Der Spiegel interview
3.2 Obligations and unsplendid silence: Celan at "Todtnauberg"
3.3 Conclusion
4 Further reading
5 Selected Bibliography
6 Cinema
7 Quotes
8 External links
Early life and education
Heidegger was born to a rural family in Meßkirch, Germany, and raised to be a clergyman. He was influenced as a teenager by Aristotle mediated through Christian theology. The concept of being, in this traditional sense, dating back to Plato, was his first exposure to an idea he would plant at the core of his most famous work Being and Time (1927). His family was not wealthy enough to send him to university and he required a scholarship, which itself required he study for the religious order. Mathematics was also his early major. During his time as a student he left theology for philosophy as he gradually found other academic funding. He wrote his doctorate thesis on a text then thought to be by Duns Scotus, a 14th century ethical and religious thinker, but later attributed to Thomas of Erfurt.
Heidegger was originally a phenomenologist. To oversimplify, phenomenologists approach philosophy by attempting to perceive experience unmediated by prior knowledge and abstract theoretical assumptions. Husserl was its founder and major exponent. In fact, Heidegger studied under Husserl and it was this that persuaded him to become a phenomenologist. Heidegger became interested in the question of being (or what it means to be). His famous work Being and Time is characterized as phenomenological ontology. The idea of being dates back to Parmenides and has traditionally served as one of the key thoughts of Western philosophy. The question of being was revived by Heidegger after being eclipsed by the metaphysical tradition from Plato to Descartes, and more recently in the Enlightenment. He tried to ground being in time, and thus discover its real essence or meaning, that is, its intelligibility for us.
Thus Heidegger began where being began — in ancient Greek thought, resurrecting a lost, under-appreciated issue in contemporary philosophy. Heidegger's great opening was to take Plato seriously again, and at the same time undermine the entire Platonic world by challenging the core of Platonism — treating being not as timeless and transcendent, but as immanent in time and history. This is partially why Platonists such as George Grant regard Heidegger as a great thinker, even if they disagree with his analysis of Being and conception of Platonic thought. Although Heidegger was a supremely creative and original thinker, he also borrowed heavily from Friedrich Nietzsche and Søren Kierkegaard, the latter of whom goes mostly unacknowledged by Heidegger. Heidegger can be compared to Aristotle, who took Plato's dialogues and systematically presented them as treatises and concepts. Similarly, Heidegger extracted Nietzsche's unpublished fragments and interpreted them as the culminating expression of Western metaphysics. Heidegger's published lectures during 1936 on Nietzsche’s Will to Power as Art are less scholarly commentaries than original philosophical works in their own right. Heidegger's concepts of angst and Da-sein draw on Kierkegaard's notions of anxiety, the importance of subjective relation to the truth, existence in the face of death, the temporality of existence, and the importance of passionate affirmation of one's individual being-in-the-world.
Martin Heidegger is regarded as one of the most significant philosophers of the 20th century. His prominence is rivaled only by Bertrand Russell and Ludwig Wittgenstein, and his ideas have seeped into an incredibly large number of research areas. It is because of Heidegger's discussion of ontology that he is often cited as one of the founders of existentialism and his ideas inspired some great philosophical works, such as by the philosopher Sartre who adopts many of his ideas from Heidegger (although Heidegger insists that Sartre misunderstood his works). His philosophical work was taken up throughout Germany, France, and Japan and has gained, since the 1970s at least, a strong following in North America as well; it was scorned as rubbish, however, by contemporaries such as the Vienna Circle, Theodor Adorno, and British philosophers such as Bertrand Russell and Alfred Ayer.
Heidegger's refusal to adopt current concepts such as the fact-value distinction, his criticism of modern science and technology, and his refusal to offer an "ethical" component to his theory, claiming such a suggestion was a fundamental misunderstanding of his thought, often puzzled and confused philosophers. Attacking him seemed like the only thing to do, especially since his private behavior was morally and politically ambiguous.
[edit]
Philosophy
[edit]
Being and Time
Heidegger's most important work is the dense and challenging Being and Time (German Sein und Zeit, 1927). Although the book as published represents only a third of the total project outlined in its introduction, it marked a turning point in continental philosophy. It has been massively influential and remains one of the most discussed works of 20th century philosophy; many subsequent philosophical views and approaches, such as existentialism and deconstruction, have been strongly influenced by Being and Time.
In this work, Heidegger takes up the question of the meaning of being: what does it mean to say that an entity is? This is the fundamental question of ontology, defined by Aristotle as the study of being qua (Latin, tr. roughly as 'as', or 'in the capacity of') being. In his approach to this question, Heidegger departs from the tradition of Aristotle and of Kant, both of whom, despite the vast difference between their respective philosophical positions, approach the question of the meaning of being from the perspective of the logic of propositional statements. Implicit in this traditional approach is the thesis that theoretical knowledge represents the most fundamental relation between the human individual and the beings in his surrounding world (including himself).
Explicitly rejecting this thesis, Heidegger instead adopts a version of the phenomenological method, purged of what he regards as the residue of Aristotelian/Kantian cognitivism still present in Husserl's formulation of this method. Like Husserl, Heidegger takes as his starting point the phenomenon of intentionality. Human behavior is intentional insofar as it is directed at some object or end (all building is building of something, all talking is talking about something, etc). Intentionality was an activity termed by Heidegger as "Sorge" (care) and reflected a positive aspect of Angst. Sorge, or caring, as the fundamental concept of the intentional being, presupposed an ontological significance that distinguishes ontological being from mere ontic being (thinghood). Theoretical knowledge represents only one kind of intentional behavior, and Heidegger asserts that it is founded on more fundamental modes of behavior, modes of practical engagement with the surrounding world, rather than being their ultimate foundation. He divides the understanding between the existentiell understanding, which understands existence through existence itself, and existential understanding, which is the theoretical analysis of what constitutes existence. An entity is what it is (i.e., it has being) insofar as it "shows up" within a context of practical engagement (Heidegger calls such a context a 'world'), not because it has certain inherent properties ascertainable by disinterested contemplation. A hammer is a hammer not because it has certain hammer-like properties, but because it is used for hammering.
This also necessitated a rejection of the Cartesian, disembodied 'I': that is, an 'I' as a purely thinking object. Instead, Heidegger insisted that any analysis of human behaviour should begin with the fact that we are in the world (not viewing it in an 'abstract' fashion): therefore the fundamental fact about human existence is our 'being-in-the-world'. Human beings, Heidegger insisted, were embodied beings who acted in the world. He also said that the world was a characteristic of Being in the World, "Da-Sein.". He therefore rejected the 'subject-object' distinction assumed by most philosophers since Descartes. Things are meaningful to us in terms of their use in certain contexts, which are defined by social norms. However, all of these norms are radically contingent. Their contingency is revealed in the fundamental phenomenon of Angst, in which all norms fall away and beings show up as nothing in particular, in their essential meaninglessness. (Contrary to some existentialist interpretations of Heidegger, this does not mean that all existence is absurd; rather, it means that existence always has the potential for absurdity.) The experience of Angst reveals the essential finitude of human being.
The fact that beings can show up, either as meaningful in a context or as meaningless in the experience of Angst, depends on a prior phenomenon: that beings can show up at all. Heidegger calls the showing up of beings "truth", which he defines as unconcealment rather than correctness. This "truth of beings", their self-revelation, involves a more fundamental kind of truth, the "disclosure of being in which the being of beings is unconcealed." It is this unconcealment of being that defines human existence for Heidegger: the human being is that being for whom being is an issue, that is, for whom being shows up as such (Heidegger's word for such an entity, which could conceivably have non-human instantiations, is Da-sein). This is why Heidegger begins his inquiry into the meaning of being with an inquiry into the essence of human being; the ontology of Da-sein is fundamental ontology. The unconcealment of being is an essentially temporal and historical phenomenon (hence the "time" in Being and Time); what we call past, present, and future correspond originarily to aspects of this unconcealment and not to three mutually exclusive regions of the homogeneous time that clocks measure (although clock-time is derivative from the originary time of unconcealment, as Heidegger attempts to show in the book's difficult final chapters).
The total understanding of being results from an explication of the implicit knowledge of being that inheres in all human behavior. Philosophy thus becomes a form of interpretation; this is why Heidegger's technique in Being and Time is often referred to as hermeneutical phenomenology. Being and Time, being incomplete, contains Heidegger's statement of this project and his interpretation of human existence and its temporal horizon, but does not contain the working out of the meaning of being as such on the basis of this interpretation. This ambitious task is taken up in a different way in his later works (see below).
As part of his ontological project, Heidegger undertakes a reinterpretation of previous Western philosophy. He wants to explain why and how theoretical knowledge came to seem like the most fundamental relation to being. This explanation takes the form of a destructuring (Destruktion) of the philosophical tradition, an interpretive strategy that reveals the fundamental experience of being at the base of previous philosophies. In Being and Time he briefly destructures the philosophy of Descartes; in later works he uses this approach to interpret the philosophies of Aristotle, Kant, Hegel, and Plato, among others. This technique exerted a profound influence on Derrida's deconstructive approach, although there are very important differences between the two methods.
Being and Time is the towering achievement of Heidegger's early career, but there are other important works from this period, including Die Grundprobleme der Phänomenologie (The Basic Problems of Phenomenology, 1927), Kant und das Problem der Metaphysik (Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics, 1929), and "Was ist Metaphysik?" ("What Is Metaphysics?", 1929).
[edit]
Later works
Although Heidegger claimed that all of his writings concerned a single question, the question of being, in the years after the publication of Being and Time the focus of his work gradually changed. This change is often referred to as Heidegger's Kehre (turn). In his later works, Heidegger turns from "doing" to "dwelling." He focuses less on the way in which the structures of being are revealed in everyday behavior and in the experience of Angst, and more on the way in which behavior itself depends on a prior "openness to being." The essence of being human is the maintenance of this openness. (The difference between Heidegger's early and late works is more a difference of emphasis than a radical break like that between the early and late works of Wittgenstein, but it is important enough to justify a division of the Heideggerian corpus into "early" (roughly, pre-1930) and "late" writings.)
Heidegger opposes this openness to the "will to power" of the modern human subject, who subordinates beings to his own ends rather than letting them "be what they are." Heidegger interprets the history of western philosophy as a brief period of authentic openness to being in the time of the pre-Socratics, especially Parmenides, Heraclitus, and Anaximander, followed by a long period increasingly dominated by nihilistic subjectivity, initiated by Plato and culminating in Nietzsche.
In the later writings, two recurring themes are poetry and technology. Heidegger sees poetry as a preeminent way in which beings are revealed "in their being." The play of poetic language (which is, for Heidegger, the essence of language itself) reveals the play of presence and absence that is being itself. Heidegger focuses especially on the poetry of Hölderlin.
Against the revealing power of poetry, Heidegger sets the force of technology. The essence of technology is the conversion of the whole universe of beings into an undifferentiated "standing reserve" (Bestand) of energy available for any use to which humans choose to put it. The standing reserve represents the most extreme nihilism, since the being of beings is totally subordinated to the will of the human subject. Heidegger does not unequivocally condemn technology; he believes that its increasing dominance might make it possible for humanity to return to its authentic task of the stewardship of being. Nevertheless, many of Heidegger's later works are characterized by an unmistakable agrarian nostalgia.
Heidegger's important later works include Vom Wesen der Wahrheit ("On the Essence of Truth," 1930), Der Ursprung des Kunstwerkes ("The Origin of the Work of Art," 1935), Bauen Wohnen Denken ("Building Dwelling Thinking," 1951), and Die Frage nach der Technik ("The Question Concerning Technology," 1953) and Was heisst Denken? ("What Is Called Thinking?" 1954).
[edit]
Influences and difficulties of French reception
Heidegger, like Husserl, is an explicitly acknowledged influence on existentialism, despite his explicit disavowal and objection, in texts such as the "Letter on Humanism," of the importation of key elements of his work into existentialist contexts. While Heidegger was banned from university teaching for a period shortly after the war on account of his activities as Rector of Freiburg, he developed a number of contacts in France who continued to teach his work and brought their students to visit him in Todtnauberg (see, for example, Jean-François Lyotard's brief account in "Heidegger and 'the jews': A Conference in Vienna and Freiburg," which discusses a Franco-German conference held in Freiburg in 1947, a first step in bringing together French and German students after the War). Heidegger subsequently made efforts to keep abreast of developments in French philosophy by way of recommendations from Jean Beaufret, who was an early French translator, and Lucien Braun.
Deconstruction as it is generally understood (i.e., as French and Anglo-American phenomena profoundly rooted in Heidegger's work, with limited general exposure in a German context until the 1980s) came to Heidegger's attention in 1967 by way of Lucien Braun's recommendation of Jacques Derrida's work (Hans-Georg Gadamer was present at an initial discussion and indicated to Heidegger that Derrida's work came to his attention by way of an assistant). Heidegger expressed interest in meeting Derrida personally after the latter sent him some of his work. (There was discussion of a meeting in 1972, but this did not happen.) Heidegger's interest in Derrida is said by Braun to have been considerable (as is evident in two letters, of 29 September 1967 and 16 May 1972, from Heidegger to Braun). Braun also brought to Heidegger's attention the work of Michel Foucault. Foucault's relation to Heidegger is a matter of considerable difficulty; Foucault acknowledged Heidegger as the philosopher whom he read but never wrote about. (For more on this see Penser à Strasbourg, Jacques Derrida, et al, which includes reproductions of both letters and an account by Braun, "À mi-chemin entre Heidegger et Derrida").
One feature that garnered initial interest in a French context (which propagated rather quickly to scholars of French literature and philosophy working in American universities) was Derrida's efforts to displace the understanding of Heidegger's work prevalent in France from the period of the ban against Heidegger teaching in German universities, which amounts in part to rejecting almost wholesale the influence of Jean-Paul Sartre and existentialist terms. In Derrida's view, deconstruction is a tradition inherited via Heidegger (the French term "déconstruction" is a translation of Heidegger's "Destruktion" - literally "destruction"), whereas Sartre's interpretation of Dasein and other key Heideggerian terms is overly psychologistic and (ironically) anthropocentric, consisting of a radical misconception of the limited number of Heidegger's texts commonly studied in France up to that point (namely Being and Time, What is Metaphysics?, and Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics). Derrida, on the other hand, is at times presented as an ultra-orthodox "French Heidegger," to such an extent that he, his colleagues, and his former students are made to go proxy for Heidegger's worst (political) mistakes, despite ample evidence that the reception of Heidegger's work by later practitioners of deconstruction is anything but doctrinaire "Heideggerianism". The work of Philippe Lacoue-Labarthe may be taken as exemplary in this regard and was often commended as such by Derrida, who further contrasted Lacoue-Labarthe's extended work on Heidegger with Foucault's silence.
Having earlier mentioned the contributions of Derrida, Lacoue-Labarthe, and Lyotard to scholarship on Heidegger and National Socialism, it is worth noting that Heidegger's relation to the Holocaust and Nazism was the subject of great and occasionally fractious debate across various "deconstructions". These included the extent to which specific practitioners of deconstruction could entirely do without Heideggerian deconstruction (as Lyotard in particular may have wished) or were - rather - obliged to further (and in the cases of many mis- and uninformed criticisms, recall) already extensive criticisms of Heidegger which considerably predated (in the case of Derrida, by decades) the broad recognition of Heidegger's activities as a National Socialist. The latter were precipitated by press attention to the Victor Farias book "Heidegger et le nazisme" (Farias was an ex-student of Heidegger) and extensive treatments of the Holocaust and its implications. These included for example, the proceedings of the first conference dedicated to Derrida's work, published as "Les Fins de l'Homme" (the essay from which that title was taken), Derrida's "Feu la cendre/cio' che resta del fuoco", or the studies on Celan by Lacoue-Labarthe and Derrida which shortly preceded the detailed studies of Heidegger's politics published in and after 1987.
[edit]
Criticism
Heidegger's importance to the world of continental philosophy (which he largely created, there being no distinction between analytical and continental philosophy prior to him) is probably unsurpassed. His reception amongst philosophers of the analytic school, however, is quite another story. Saving a somewhat favorable review by Gilbert Ryle in the journal Mind of Being and Time at the time of its publication, Heidegger's contemporaries from the analytic tradition (which was still young, but already quite sharply delineated from other branches of philosophy) generally regarded both the content, insofar as they believed there to be any at all, and the style by which he delivered it, as evidence of the worst possible way of doing philosophy.
The analytic tradition values clarity of expression, whereas Heidegger thought that "making itself intelligible was suicide for philosophy." Apart from the charge of obscurantism, analytic philosophers generally considered the actual content that could be gleaned from Heidegger's work to be either trivially false, non-verifiable or uninteresting. This view has largely survived, and Heidegger is still spoken of with derision in most quarters of analytical philosophy, and his influence is considered to have been disastrous for philosophy, in that a clear line can be traced from it to most varieties of postmodern philosophical thinking.
[edit]
Heidegger and Nazi Germany
Heidegger joined the Nazi Party on May 1, 1933, before being appointed the rector of the university in Freiburg. He resigned from the rectorship in April 1934. During this time Heidegger's former teacher Husserl, who was Jewish, was denied the use of the university library at Freiburg because of the racial cleansing laws issued by the Nazi Party. Heidegger also removed the dedication to Husserl from Being and Time when it was reissued in 1941. Heidegger later claimed that this was due to pressure from his publisher, Max Niemeyer. Additionally, when Heidegger's Introduction to Metaphysics (lectures originally given in 1935) was published in 1953, he declined to remove a reference to the "inner truth and greatness of this movement [die innere Wahrheit und Größe dieser Bewegnung]," i.e. National Socialism. Instead of deleting or altering the text, he merely added the parenthetical gloss, "(namely, the confrontation of planetary technology and modern humanity) (nämlich [die] Begegnung der planetarisch bestimmten Technik und des neuzeitlichen Menschen)." Many readers, notably Jürgen Habermas, came to interpret this ambiguous remark as evidence of his continued commitment to National Socialism.
Critics further cite Heidegger's affair with Hannah Arendt, when she was a doctoral student of his at the University of Marburg. This affair mostly went along in the 20s, some time before Heidegger's involvement in Nazism, but it did not end when she "fled" from him and moved to Heidelberg to continue with Karl Jaspers, and she later spoke on his behalf at his denazification hearings. Jaspers spoke against him at these same hearings, suggesting he would have a detrimental influence on young German students because of his powerful teaching presence. Arendt, who was Jewish, resumed their friendship, if extremely cautiously, after the war, despite or even because of the widespread contempt that Heidegger was held in for his political sympathies, and despite his being forbidden from teaching for a number of years.
[edit]
Der Spiegel interview
Some years later, hoping to quiet controversy, Heidegger gave an interview to Der Spiegel magazine, in which he promised to discuss the issue provided it was published posthumously. It should also be mentioned that the published version was not a real interview, but the protocol had been largely "corrected" on Heidegger's demand. In this interview, Heidegger's defense of his Nazi involvement runs in two tracks: first, he argues that there would have been no alternative; he says he had tried to save the university (and science in general) from being politicized and had to make compromises with the Nazi administration. Second, he saw an "awakening" ("Aufbruch"), something which might help to find a "new national and social approach". From 1934 on, he says, he would have been more critical towards the government. Heidegger is evasive on some questions in this interview. For example, when he talks about a "national and social approach" in national socialism he links this to Friedrich Naumann. But Naumann's "national-sozialer Verein" was not at all national socialist, but liberal. This confusion seems to be deliberately created by Heidegger. Also, he changes between his two arguments quickly, disregarding their contradictions. And his statements often tend to take the form "others were much more Nazis than me" and "the Nazis did bad things to me, too", both of which are true, but miss the point. Also, the Der Spiegel interviewers did not bring to question Heidegger's quote from 1949 where he compares engineered food production to the Holocaust ("essentially the same"); in fact, they were not in possession of much of the evidence for Heidegger's sympathies towards Nazism which is known today. To further evaluate this issue, read "Only a God Can Save Us," Der Spiegel interview with Heidegger (1966) and Jürgen Habermas, "Work and Weltanschauung: The Heidegger Controversy from a German Perspective." translated by John McCumber, Critical Inquiry 15 (Winter 1989): pp. 431-456.
[edit]
Obligations and unsplendid silence: Celan at "Todtnauberg"
Shortly after giving the Spiegel interview and following Celan's lecture at Freiburg, Heidegger hosted Paul Celan at his chalet at Todtnauberg. The two walked in the woods. Celan impressed Heidegger with his knowledge of botany (also evident in his poetry), and Heidegger is thought to have spoken about elements of his press interview. Celan signed Heidegger's guest book.
In his Poetry as Experience, Lacoue-Labarthe advanced the argument that, although Celan's poetry was deeply informed by Heidegger's philosophy, Celan was long aware of Heidegger's association with the Nazi party and therefore fundamentally circumspect toward the man and transformative in his reception of his work. Celan was nonetheless willing to meet Heidegger (although he may not have been willing to be photographed with him or to contribute to Festschriften honoring Heidegger's work). Heidegger was a professed admirer of Celan's writing, although he did not attend to it as Hölderlin or Trakl (neither did he attend to Celan as a Jewish poet working within that German tradition). "Todtnauberg", however, seems to hold out the unrealized possibility of a profound rapprochement between their work, albeit on the condition that Heidegger break a silence that virtually blanketed his work to the end (Lacoue-Labarthe has commented on the insufficiency of Heidegger's one known remark about the gas chambers, made in 1949). In this respect Heidegger's work was perhaps redeemable for Celan, even if that redemption or what need was had for it was never transacted between the two men. Lest one implicitly take this as Celan simply demanding an apology of Heidegger (such a scenario seems simplistic, the more so given that neither was given to simplism), there are reasonable grounds to argue that it was (and still is) at least as important to specify how the Nazi period is das Unheil (disaster, calamity) (which is to say: specificity as to a great deal more than counting the dead). What compelled Heidegger to write about poetry, technology, and truth ought to have compelled him to write about the German disaster, all the more so because, on the basis of his thought, Heidegger attributed an "inner greatness" to the movement that brought about that disaster.
Lacoue-Labarthe and Jacques Derrida have both commented extensively on Heidegger's corpus, and both have identified an idiomatically Heideggerian National Socialism that persisted until the end. It is perhaps of greater importance that Lacoue-Labarthe and Derrida, following Celan to a degree, believed Heidegger capable of profound criticism of Nazism and the horrors it brought forth. They hold that Heidegger's greatest failure not to be his involvement in the National Socialist movement but his "silence on the extermination" (Lacoue-Labarthe) and refusal to elaborate a thorough deconstruction of Nazism beyond laying out certain of his considerable objections to party orthodoxies and (particularly in the case of Lacoue-Labarthe) their passage through Nietzsche, Hölderlin, and Richard Wagner, taken to be susceptible to Nazi appropriation. It would be reasonable to say that both Lacoue-Labarthe and Derrida regarded Heidegger as capable of engaging Nazism in this other fashion and have undertaken such work on the basis of this (one ought to note in due course the questions raised by Derrida in "Desistance" in calling attention to Lacoue-Labarthe's parenthetical comment: "(in any case, Heidegger never avoids anything)").
[edit]
Conclusion
Heidegger's involvements with the Nazis and the lack of a clear apology for them complicated many of his friendships, and continues to complicate the reception of his work. It is disputable whether Heidegger was antisemitic or if he was taken in by the charismatic projections of Nazi propaganda, but he had clear sympathies for certain elements of Nazism. Whether this is in any way a result of his philosophy is still contested. It has also been noted that many parts of "Sein und Zeit" can be read as anti-democratic, anti-modernist and anti-liberal, e.g. the condemnations against the "lordship of the they" (Herrschaft des Man), the "chatter" (Gerede) and the Dasein's Verfallenheit (roughly, being-fallen-to) the world.
The possibility that Heidegger's affiliation with the Nazi party was the result of his philosophy would lead many to discredit Heidegger as a philosopher solely on this basis, as Jean-François Lyotard remarked, the formula becomes "if a Nazi, then not a great thinker" or, conversely, "if a great thinker, then not a Nazi")


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home