Doubting Huntington: an Onus to idiocy
Yesterdays International Herald Tribune contained an article about why the 'Clash of Civilizations' doesnt exist. It is not a unique comment. Almost everyone wants to chime in with their very own view. In India in 2005, in a swank restuarant in Bombay, a young caucasian women from Tucson, Arizona claimed "I dont beleive in the Clash of Civilizations". Note the message this turns on: Beleif. Was Samuel Huntington a preacher, was he a prophet, was he talking about god? His idea, his book, his thesis was not religion, it doesnt require beleif. This is the problem, the central problem with educated western(for lack of a better word, despite the fact we dont think the 'west' exists) liberals is that they ascribe 'beleif' to things that are not about faith. Once the western secualr society killed religion they began to ascribe the feelings they had for religion, those their ancestors had, towards other things so that all sorts of things became subjects of 'beleif'. The most obvious example is 'communism' but it transcends that even down to business approaches like Six Sigma or stock analysis called 'statistical analysis'. People 'beleive' in these things, or they dont. Thus, when Mr. Huntington wrote his book people, especially liberals, began to say they didnt beleive in him.
Why?
The reason they ascribe such importance to his work and refuse to 'beleive' it is because they think that 'beleiving' in Huntington means accepting his hypothesis and therefore it means as members of the 'western' civilization they must be in combat with all the other civilizations and since liberalism and moral relativism and internationalism transcend the 'west' they cant ascribe to it, because to do so would force them to be patriots. But this view is simply a totally misguided view predicated on the fact that they ascribe such importance to 'beleif'.
If one doesnt 'beleive' in Huntington, but merely accepts that, yes obviously, the new paradigm of the world is more based on the conflict between religion and culture rather than the marxian view of the conflict between class i.e Communism and Capitalism, one can be totally secure in realizing that Huntington is obviosuly correct.
How do we know he is on to something?
All we must do is add up all the conlifcts, in fact tallying up stories in the same International Herald Tribune would be enough.
Let us give a sample:
Israel
Iraq
Egypt(the copts)
Libya, Syria(the cartoon riots)
Iran(holocaust denial)
Thailand
Nigeria
Sudan
Chad
Phillipines
Chechnya
Kosovo
Bosnia
Lebanon(recent bombings of christian neighboorhoods)
Palestine(hamas)
China's Xinjiang province
India(terrorism)
Kashmir
Bangladesh(anti-hindu riots)
Armenia vs. Azerbaijan
Singapore vs. malaysia
East Timor vs. Indonesia
So if we were 'beleivers' in Marxism we could ascribe all these conflicts to class, but if we were honest we could obviously see that each conflict is based on deep religious, historical and cultural divides. The liberal doesnt want to 'beleive'. He thinks beleiving in the thesis makes him a 'racist' or a 'western nationalist' or something. He speaks against the 'inevitability' of the conflict and claims that the conflict is in fact created by the intolerance of the west(i.e the cartoons) and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But then let him explain the terrorism in Kashmir, in China, in Thailand, in Nigeria and in the Sudan. He will ascribe to each 'local' reasons, but ask him to explain how exactly Saudi money got to Bosnia and Chechnya and Indonesia. Let him explain the similar intolerant methods used against minorities by Malaysia, Indonesia, Pakistan and Egypt. Let him explain. He will argue, squirm and then he will call you a 'racist'. Then you know that you have proved, to some small extent, the Huntington thesis.
Huntington, like Benny Morris, is not accused, like Hitchens, of being an undercover right wing racist extremist, so goes the epitat of everyone who was ever correct. The liberal works hard to deny the thesis, when he speaks of rioting in other countries he tries to hide the religious identity of the participants, or he uses higher language or tribal names to confuse the reader. He might speak of a bomb in a 'maronite' neighboorhood, or he might speak of Ibbo and Fulani tribal fighting in Nigeria or he might speak of Arabs assaulting Africans in Sudan or he might speak of assaults on 'copts' in Egypt. He will try to not ascribe any religious reasons to things. But the more he tries, the more he acknowledges Huntington.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home