Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Thursday, August 03, 2006

How Israelis think: The ignorance, the arrogance

Israel was created by Zionism to 'normalize the Jews' and 'make them like every other nation'. This has been nly partly sucessful. Whereas other movements have suceeded to create new nation-states for the Croats and Slovaks and Ukrainians the nation building work in Israel has been hampered by at least three problems: The presence of a large Arab minority, unending war and terror, mass immigration and a forth issue: massive international press coverage, world obsession and european nd arab opposition as well as being the target of popular hatred among the extreme right, the extreme left and the Arab and Muslim states.

However Israel was created and hs survived and an Israeli culture has been created. This culture is not a monolith but a mosaic of jewish culture(outside the arab culture that also exists). It contains the Ashkenazi secular, the sephardim, the haredim, the ethiopians and the russians among others. Each of these adds flavor and slowly assimilat and blend, thus we see for instance that German was widely spoken in the 1930s by the Yekkes but today Russian is a third language for almost a million people. This is an immigrant society affected, like america, by waves of immigration.

There exists in Israel a secualr western mentality among a small bourougise elite of ashkenazim, caled populrly the WASPs of Israel. These people feel more secure in the language and custums of Europe than of Israel. They travel abroad frequently, most avoid army service, all go to college and many will leave the country, they have few if any children, many work in 'human rights' organizations at least once and when violence or terror rises most end up in New York or Canada as a refuge.

One person in particular is a woman in her 20s, on Sept. 11, having escaped te intifada in Israel, she was in New York. She has travelled in South East Asia as well, for her the temple complex at Angor was not interesting because she "loves nature and I am really only happy in natural things, I notice natural bauty so those materalistic things dont really ipact me" when asked if she thought the Laos capital Vientiene was 'colonial' in its architectual appearence she says "colubia, I've never been there" then when corrected adds "I dont notive buildings, I only notice nature and beauty..."

In response to why she is going to a bar on Tesha b'Av, a religious holidy in which almost everything else is closed she says "who cares about something that happaned 3000 years ago" not realizing Tesha b'Ave is in memory of the temple destrution of the first and secnd temples(2000 years ago) and the expulsion of 1492 and partially the Holocaust. But what is a secualr person to know, much less to respect others.

She speaks of being robbed in Abu Tor "I was walking alone from a bar in the middle of the night and a boy, an arab boy, stole my purse, it was so frightening, so awful, I tried to chase him but I fell(she was wearing high heels and a short skirt like most western women who value themselves only for their looks) I strained my ankle and I just sat and cried and when I noticed no one was going to help me(in western culture no one helps women) I got up and walked back to the bar since my keys were in the purse, the stolen purse, I couldnt help but to think how worse it could be be, I cant get over it, I could have been raped, I shudder to think of it, its so awful that such a thing can happen, all the time in Asia and elsewhere and I live in Harlem and never did that happen to me."

But the true interest in the secular rich Israeli is how, despite their pretended worldiness, they lack a basic unerstading of many things, this is an excerpt from a real conversation:


Secular(s): The U.S supports Israel because of sept. 11
man(m): But you know there is a long tradition of U.S support for Israel
s: no, i'm sure its because of sept. 11, I was there, it changed everything now Bush and America like Israel and understand Israel.
m: But you just dont know your history then, in the old days most countries in Europe and America supported Israel, al that has happaned is that europe has stopped its support, Americas hasnt changed dramatically.

S: well you know I worked for a human rights organization, but in this war I am with Israel, as opposed to Hizbullah(only in Israel is there ever a queston of whether a person would support their country in time of war)…but even if I am with Israel it does not mean Israel is correct or right, there is no justice I the middle east. There is no right or wrong.


S: Anti-semitism is an accusation too easily made, I don’t believe it exists the way people always throw that word around. Disliking Israel isn’t anti-semitism.
M: Don’t you wonder why it is that the coverage of Israel is so disproportionate, that on he covers of 8 major world newspapers Israel takes the headline and yes it isn’t only in Lebanon that 400 civilians have died in 3 weeks, in other places like Sudan, Iraq, a hundred killed a day, and in the Congo and in a far off lace perhaps never heard of, Sri Lanka. But do you wonder why all the world’s attention is on Israel. Disproportionate hatred of Israel is anti-semitism, so why is it that Israel is always the headline?
S: It is because of the U.S Jewish influence.
M: I’m sorry, I don’t understand, if that’s the excuse for why the U.S supports Israel or the coverage in the U.S, why isn’t Sudan covered?
S: Sudan doesn’t matter, those people don’t matter.
M: oh so there is an excuse for everything, for why in each case the lives of Arabs killed by Jews takes precedence?
S: Its not an excuse, that’s how it is,
M: lets go back to this claim you made about U.S jewish influence, do you realy believe that classic nazi-anti-semitic argument.
S: but it is true. The U.S Jews are very powerful, and they have great influence in the media.
M: you are aware that this is a classic nazi argument, that the jews control the media, the banks, the world.
S: how dare you call me a nazi, and an anti-semite, I am a Jew and an Israeli, my ancestors were hunted down by the Nazis for those exact reasons.
M: And you repeat them, you as a Jew repeat them, which is more startling, but not suprising, after all many big anti-semites are Jews(Chomsky, Kimmerling, Finkelstein). But basically you are ignorant, you don’t know anything about Amrica, you’ve only lived there a short time, I grew up there, so your ignorance betrays you, let me ask you who owns CNN.
S: I don’t know that and that’s irrelevant.
M: It is Ted Turner, not a Jew(actually an anti-semite, apparently, like Mel Gibson and shakira). Now who owns Fox News, or News Corp.
S: That doesn’t matter, everyone knows about the large number of Jews employed at those places and all the Jewish influences and the Jewish influence in Hollywood.
M: You’ve got to be kidding, you believe these things, did you get it from a neo-nazi website(maybe jewatch.com). Rupert Murdoch, who is not a Jew owns News Corp(and the Saudis have a big investment there, Murdoch is pro-Israel because he is right wing, many of the Jews in Media are actually anti-Israel by an twist of irony. And none of this explains the disproportionate coverage, and it doesn’t begin to explain why European news hates Israel and the U.S news is only lukewarm).
A Third person interjects here: Perhaps the reason for the coverage is economic, Israel and it has so many investments and the Europeans and Americans have investments here.
M: Have either of you ever bothered to wonder is perhaps it has a little something to do with the fact that Christianity and Islam hold Jerusalem and the Holy Land sacred?
S: well that’s also a reason.
M: but a secondary one to the Jewish influence that runs the media apparently. Not even wondering why that Jewish influence doesn’t make the media pro-Israel. Do you know the percentage of Hollywood owned by Jews, the percentage of Jews employed in the media, there are only 5 million Jews in the U.S and 13 million worldwide(the PM of Malaysia said the Jews control the world by proxy). Do you know that even?
S: its doesn’t matter if I can name names or the numbers, everyone knows about the influence and that’s not anti-semitic, it’s a good thing, its good for Israel, the Jewish influence makes America support Israel and America is the only country in the world that supports Israel, so its great that jews have so much influence to make America do that(the argument behind the Walt and Mersehmeier paper on the Jewish lobby exactly).
M: do you realize what you’ve said, you could be a spokesman for any nazi organization or for any islamist, that’s how terrible, ignorant and offensive thse comments are.
S: well I don’t think you have a right to call me a nazi, my ancestors perished at there hands and I support Israel, I am just telling the truth, and its not anti-Israel or anti-Jewish, I am a Jew, its about the facts and about how these things make the media and America pro-Israel.
M: well in my mind that’s what the Nazis said, so thank you, have a good evening, I’ve had enough propaganda and anti-semitism for one night.


What is interesting here? It is the level of ignorance and stupidity of an Israeli and not just any Israeli, because the instincts of the normal fellafal vendor in Israel are perfectly good, it is this Israeli, the most educated(she has a law degree and works for the Israeli justice department) and yet she, who has traveled so much, believes these things, under the guise of thinking they are accurate and that it is normal for a jew to be proud that Jews control the United States, and not realizing the boomerang of this argument and the other side to it. Saying Jews control the U.S Media, Hollywood and the government is anti-semitic, but even if its true it has a bizarre boomerage because it means that the only reason any country would support Israel against Islamism is because of a hidden jewish influence, not ever because a country might realize Israel is right, the ‘third party’ mentioned here also mentioned the existence of the Arab oil lobby, a potent factor. But it has also been in history that nations sovereignty has been protected not just because of influence of that nation’s people, for instance the English declaration of war in 1939 on Germany due t the invasion of Poland was not because of undue Polish influence in the British media, but rather because of realism and the U.S intervention in Vietnam(1962), Panama(1989), Somalia(1992) and Haiti(1993, 2000) had nothing to do with large numbers of those people influencing the U.S but rather other alterior, sometimes more or less pure, motives. In the case of the intervention in Yugoslavia(1998) it had more to do with some Albanian influence(see ‘how a Brooklyn roofer..’, but the original intervention in Bosnia(1994) was not because of this but for humanitarian reasons or perhaps due to Clinton’s sex affair.

So this Israeli accepts the Walt and Mershemeir thesis. But she thinks it is good for Israel. Well it isn’t good, if people think he Jews control the U.S that isn’t god, is anti-semitic, it leads to hate. If that is the reason Israelis think their country should be or is supported then they are foolish. America doesn’t think it should be supported just because of American influence, the reason for the intervention in Sudan should not just be because of African influence, it should be because of what is right and wrong, those two words the moral relativist modern secular Israeli refuses to use.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home