Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Wednesday, August 23, 2006

Why Racial profiling doesnt work

Racial profiling might work if one were confronting criminal activity based solely among a racial group, but in recent calls in the last years to have racial profiling for terrorists at the airports the ideas are mis-guided. it is true that in the 5 years 80% of all terrorists have been of Arab descent, have had Muslim names and so on. But that doesnt mean racial profiling will catch them. What exactly would the discription be? "swarthy man, or brown skinned, or light skinned with dark hair". That would be enough to not let anymore southern Italians board planes, and of course Jews. One of two things is going on here. Either people beleive religious profiling is acceptable and those who disagree are calling it racial profiling or people are really beelive that Arabs or Muslims are a 'race' which they are not. After all a number of those caught with close ties to terrorists have been Asian, African and White converts to islam. We might recall that one of those arrested in the recent plot to bring the liquids aboard the place was a British man Umar Islam who converted(his original name wasn't umar Islam but those who convert to islam get new names because it would apparnelty be an insult to Muslims if they kept their heathen names). Also a woman who blew herself up in Iraq was from Belgium and she converted.

Religious profiling is a decent idea. However it is very problematic and risks alientating many people, many innocent people obviously. But perhaps the best kind of profiling is that which is logical. Almost all terrrorists in the last 5 years, with the exception of the Chechans and Tamils(both localized terrorist phenomenon) have used men between the ages of 17 and 30. Thats not such a big group of people. Say you took out all the men on every flight in that group and gave them all yellow cards. Then of those men you took out the known muslims and gave them red cards. You would then end up with two sets of young males, one a risk and the other a higher risk. That would pretty much do it. Subject them to better checks and more screening. Have their bags double checked. Of course it doesnt mean you have no vigilance for the other people, because terrorists arn't dumb, but you can have less. Wasting time checking the grandmothers and the little babies is indeed a waste of time. Checking wheelchairs and strollers is not.

But America and the world is lost in a pacifist dream, lost in the land of tolerance and diversity unwilling to ever offend anyone. SO there will be no profiling, there will never be intelligent security(after all security personell are paid as much as those at starbucks) and so people will wait longer. Those whining about racial profiling are idiots.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home