Thoughts on the Pope and the role of the western media
My thoughts on the Pope’s Regensburg address and the reaction to it:
On September 12th, 2006 the Pope Benedict XVI(formerly Joseph Ratzinger born 1927) returned to his alma mater University in Regensburg, where taught after 1969, and delivered a public address entitled Faith, reason and the university. The Pope was returning to common themes that he had addressed as a Cardinal and as Prefect for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which is one of the central theological organs of the Catholic church. Over the years, since his appointment to this position in 1981, he had been deeply involved in the inter-faith dialogues of Pope John Paul II. He was involved in outreach to other Christian churches, most importantly to the Orthodox but also to Protestants. He was also involved as an architect of the rapprochement of the church to the Jews, which had begun so famously under John XXIII. Most importantly, as someone interested in bridging the gap between philosophy and theology he took steps towards reconciling Catholic dogma to the system of reason and secularism that had grown up in Europe over the years.
When he journeyed to Regensburg in 2006 it was under this guise that he came, and it was on these topics that he wished to speak.
Soon after his speech there appeared a number of articles detailing his speech focusing on the portions in which he spoke about Jihad, spreading religion with violence and Islam. Although the Pope never mentioned Islam it was these themes that got the most attention in the press. Soon it became known that the pope had quoted a “14th century Christian emperor” who had said that Mohammed brought “evil”. This was the content of the quote as transmitted to the world along with another line in which the Pope condemned religious violence. The connection was clear. The Pope had said “Islam=hate=violence” and he had quoted a 14th century Christian who must therefore have been a Crusader because that was the period the emperor lived in. Enough said. The Pope was in league with George Bush, Ariel Sharon and the BJP, Putin, satan, Nazism, and the crusades. He was himself reenacting the inquisition, and after all was not the office he held as “Prefect for the Congregation of the Faithful” an office that had originally been responsible for the Inquisition. Yes, it was quite clear, all those like Noam Chomsky, Bin Laden or Edward Said who had stated over the years that George Bush was the ‘crusader in chief’ and that the west was embarking on a new period of imperialistic orientalism must be correct. The Pope had joined the crusade and this was no small symbolic gesture, since it was after all the Latin church that originally launched the crusades. Strange bedfellows: The Pope, the Protestant evangelical American president, the Hindu nationalists and the Zionists, but bedfellows nonetheless allied together with Danish cartoonists with the sole purpose of offending Islam and retaking the Holy Land, accomplishing what the Mongols could not do in the 13th century.
But was there another side to this. Like the cartoon debate which began after the September 30th, 2005 publication of Mohammed cartoons in a Danish newspaper this offence quickly went out of control. Muslims around the world protested. Two churches in the West Bank were firebombed, and more was sure to come. As had happened after the cartoon controversy Muslims marched with such improbable placards as “Jihad is our way” and “massacre those who call Islam violent.” Indeed the answer to critique was violence, and that was in fact what the critique had been.
But what if there was more. What if in fact what the newspapers reported was not in fact what had happened at all. It was clear with the Danish cartoons that what had been printed was indeed mostly what was protested, except that some cartoons were later faked to inflame the masses and the cartoons that didn’t portray Mohammed were not shown. But what if in this instance the news had reported a lie?
One wouldn’t want to believe that, but what if one read what the Pope said. What if it turned out that he quoted the emperor to refute the quotation or to analyze the basis of reason and theology, so that the quote had little to do with the larger point of the speech. What if it turned out that at Al Jazeera, the Washington Post, Gulf News, ABC and at the Manchester Guardian the news media had all contrived this story.
Indeed the media did contrive this story. It began with the mainstream media. Then it filtered down to the left wing and Islamic media. From there it went to the Islamist websites, the popular Muslim web, the mainstream Muslim media. From there by Friday, in time for the sermon, it went to the mosque where main stream clerics in Kuwait, Turkey, Morocco and Cairo all condemned the Pope. From there to the president of Malaysia and the secular parties in Turkey. From there to the Muslim street, to the Islamists themselves and from there to the man who threw a firebomb at an Anglican church in Nablus. That was the track it took. It was no different in substance and proportion than the Danish cartoons, or the story of American servicemen flushing the Koran down a toiled. In fact the first story on Al Jazeera was simply the AP article.
The Pope was talking about reason. About the ability of Hellenism and Greek philosophy to be applied to the Bible. He was following in the footsteps of Saint Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine(on whom he wrote his doctoral thesis). But reason was lost with the riots and statements by Muslims comparing the Pope, his holiness, to Hitler. Yes, Hitler. But the people rioting on the streets and firebombing churches were acting more like Hitlerite stormtroopers and less like the Gandhian activists they claimed to be. On moderate Imam in France claimed Islam teaches “peace, equality and tolerance.” And that tolerance was indeed exhibited all over the world by the 1.6 billion Muslims we are constantly reminded of by any Muslim who wants to show how important it is that they not be offended. Surely if 1.6 Billion people believe something it must not be critiqued.
Those people who spent the last 200 years fighting the Catholic church, burning its priests during the Spanish civil war and enacting anti-clerical laws in France, Russia, Poland, Italy and Spain were al involved, or at least their intellectual descendants were involved in misquoting the Pope. But what was their motive. What was the motive of ABC news when it declared “Pope offends Muslims worldwide.” But did he offend them? Isn’t it more proper to say, using our Greek inspired reasoning, that it was the western AP newspaper reports that offended Muslims. The Pope didn’t offend them. The Pope wasn’t even quoted correctly. Maybe it would be more proper to say that Professor Theodore Khoury and Byzantine emperor Manuel II Paleologus were the ones who offended the Muslims, since it was their book and quotes respectively popularized by the world media that led to the anger, the ‘rage’.
There are three central themes that must be illuminated here.
1) The media places an important role in how Muslims think, an increasingly important role considering the place of the internet. Not only this but the western media is directly responsible for much of the hatred and misunderstanding in the Muslim world. Those who work for the western media, those who hate the west such as Edward Said(may he rest in peace), Noam Chomsky and others misrepresent the west directly to the Muslim audience. It is as deep seated as those photographers who, during the recent Lebanon war, faked photographs to cause anger and hate. Yes the western press plays an increasingly biased role in causing hatred and resentment worldwide. Had it not been for the sound bites of the media, which desires conflict and hate to report, there would have been less interest in the Pope’s routine lecture.
2) There is a deep seated alliance on the part of left wing western publications and right wing Islamic publications. Both have a reason to hate the Pope and both condemn the crusades and both apparently work together to inflame tensions in the name of peace and dialogue.
3) This incident, like all those before it, is not an example of the intractable ability of the west and Islam to ‘coexist’ but is an important example of how the west and Islam are unable to coexist given the organs and natures of both societies. Islamic countries and the Muslim street desire these hateful and ‘offensive’ statements in order to propagate rage so that petty Imams and local Islamists can gain power by showing themselves to be leaders of the ‘faithful’. Without an issue to inflame the masses they would lose power, just as a union secretly desires low wages so the workers will continue to support it, just as a peace organization secretly desires conflict since without it there is no need to fight for ‘peace’. Coexistence groups need minorities as surely as the islamist needs to take offense.
4) This ‘rage’ among the Muslim street and calls on the Pope to apologize merely illustrate the point that he didn’t even make in the first place, that there is violence in Muslim society. Surely the Pope is expected to apologize for ‘offending’ Muslims. But what is the true meaning of ‘offending’. When the word ‘offending’ is changed so that like its companions ‘justice’ and ‘equality’ and egalitarian’ and ‘peace’ and ‘jihad’ and ‘tolerance’ and ‘terrorism’ it means the exact opposite of what it is then we must wonder. If Islam is indeed peaceful why do Muslims react with anger and intolerance and violence every time they are ‘offended’. Is this rage not something that itself deserves to be critiqued. After all we know that other people have rage. KKK members have rage, Nazis have rage. Lots of people have rage, but just because people have rage and just because they are ‘offended’ doesn’t mean one must apologize or even understand and commiserate with their offended. We can easily recall that the Nazis were ‘offended’ by a Jew using a park bench. A KKK member is ‘offended’ to see interracial dating. But some things that cause offense do not necessarily need to be rectified, instead they should be increased so that people stop being offended. We know that in the 1970s when the first woman’s voice was heard on Saudi radio that people were so offended they tried to blow up the station. In Persia in the 19th century when the Bab(founder of Bahai faith) had a woman devil herself one man was so offended he slit his own throat. Surely the Aztecs were offended when Cortes ordered them to stop Human Sacrifice. Indeed the South was offended when Sherman and Lincoln discontinued the practice of slavery. Lots of fanatics are offended. We know that certain Brahmins were offended when the Indian constitution of 1948 granted untouchables equality. When women’s feet were unbound in china people were offended. When Jesus made friends with a prostitute people were offended. Sometimes offense doesn’t mean apology is the right answer. When Patton ordered the Germans of the Rhine to clean up the concentration camps he came across surely they were offended. Let them be offended.
5) The media lied to us about what the Pope said. Muslims reacted with violence to being called violent. These are the facts. But Arab-American psychiatrist Wafa Sultan commented in an interview was that was aired on Al-Jazeera TV on February 21, 2006 when the Taliban blew up the Bamiyan Buddhas no Buddhists bombed mosques. When Ahmadinijad, the president of Iran, claimed that the Holocaust never happened, no Jews attacked mosques. These are facts. Sometimes violence is violence and sometimes societies are violent. After all we know that the Muslim colonizers of Spain in the 8th century referred to the Franks as ‘warlike and uncivilized’. Perhaps they were just that. When the Pope was called Hitler by a leading Imam in Turkey on September 15th, no Catholic resorted to violence. Perhaps it is time the world examine how exactly it responds to ‘offense’ and ‘rage’ and how exactly it is that the media is so deeply involved in spreading hatred and oppression, murder and genocide.
Below are the actual texts of the Pope’s speech(two of them) and a number of articles surrounding the speech. Compare the speech with the reporting of it. But remember it was not militant conspiratorial Muslim fanatics who spread these lies in the Muslim world, they only got wind of it in the end after it was deeply digested, the lie was spread by the west, by the AP, by the ABC and the Washington Post. It began in the west. Anti-western hatred always began in the west. After all when a lonely Imam in Paris condemned the Pope for not reconciling and embracing ‘the other’ he was not talking in the language of Islam. When he spoke of Islam preaching ‘peace, tolerance and equality’ he wasn’t speaking in the language of Islam, he was speaking in the language of Secularism, that very ideology the Pope was actually critiquing in his Regensburg speech.
Pope's speech at University of Regensburg (full text)
Sep. 14 (CWNews.com) - Editor's note: The following is the prepared text from which Pope Benedict XVI (bio - news) spoke as he addressed an academic audience at the Unviersity of Regensburg on September 12. As he actually delivered it, the speech differed slightly. Because the speech has aroused an unusual amount of debate-- particularly regarding the Pope's references to Islam and to religious violence-- CWN strongly recommends reading the entire text.
Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen,
It is a moving experience for me to stand and give a lecture at this university podium once again. I think back to those years when, after a pleasant period at the Freisinger Hochschule, I began teaching at the University of Bonn. This was in 1959, in the days of the old university made up of ordinary professors. The various chairs had neither assistants nor secretaries, but in recompense there was much direct contact with students and in particular among the professors themselves.
We would meet before and after lessons in the rooms of the teaching staff. There was a lively exchange with historians, philosophers, philologists and, naturally, between the two theological faculties. Once a semester there was a dies academicus, when professors from every faculty appeared before the students of the entire university, making possible a genuine experience of universitas: the reality that despite our specializations which at times make it difficult to communicate with each other, we made up a whole, working in everything on the basis of a single rationality with its various aspects and sharing responsibility for the right use of reason-- this reality became a lived experience.
The university was also very proud of its two theological faculties. It was clear that, by inquiring about the reasonableness of faith, they too carried out a work which is necessarily part of the whole of the universitas scientiarum, even if not everyone could share the faith which theologians seek to correlate with reason as a whole. This profound sense of coherence within the universe of reason was not troubled, even when it was once reported that a colleague had said there was something odd about our university: it had two faculties devoted to something that did not exist: God. That even in the face of such radical skepticism it is still necessary and reasonable to raise the question of God through the use of reason, and to do so in the context of the tradition of the Christian faith: this, within the university as a whole, was accepted without question.
I was reminded of all this recently, when I read the edition by Professor Theodore Khoury (Münster) of part of the dialogue carried on-- perhaps in 1391 in the winter barracks near Ankara-- by the erudite Byzantine emperor Manuel II Paleologus and an educated Persian on the subject of Christianity and Islam, and the truth of both. It was probably the emperor himself who set down this dialogue, during the siege of Constantinople between 1394 and 1402; and this would explain why his arguments are given in greater detail than the responses of the learned Persian.
The dialogue ranges widely over the structures of faith contained in the Bible and in the Qur'an, and deals especially with the image of God and of man, while necessarily returning repeatedly to the relationship of the three Laws: the Old Testament, the New Testament, and the Qur'an. In this lecture I would like to discuss only one point-- itself rather marginal to the dialogue itself-- which, in the context of the issue of faith and reason, I found interesting and which can serve as the starting-point for my reflections on this issue.
In the seventh conversation edited by Professor Khoury, the emperor touches on the theme of the jihad (holy war). The emperor must have known that surah 2, 256 reads: There is no compulsion in religion. It is one of the suras of the early period, when Mohammed was still powerless and under threat.
But naturally the emperor also knew the instructions, developed later and recorded in the Qur’an, concerning holy war. Without descending to details, such as the difference in treatment accorded to those who have the “Book” and the “infidels,” he turns to his interlocutor somewhat brusquely with the central question on the relationship between religion and violence in general, in these words:
Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.
The emperor goes on to explain in detail the reasons why spreading the faith through violence is something unreasonable. Violence is incompatible with the nature of God and the nature of the soul.
God is not pleased by blood, and not acting reasonably is contrary to God's nature. Faith is born of the soul, not the body. Whoever would lead someone to faith needs the ability to speak well and to reason properly, without violence and threats... To convince a reasonable soul, one does not need a strong arm, or weapons of any kind, or any other means of threatening a person with death....
The decisive statement in this argument against violent conversion is this: not to act in accordance with reason is contrary to God's nature. The editor, Theodore Khoury, observes: "For the emperor, as a Byzantine shaped by Greek philosophy, this statement is self-evident. But for Muslim teaching, God is absolutely transcendent. His will is not bound up with any of our categories, even that of rationality." Here Khoury quotes a work of the noted French Islamist R. Arnaldez, who points out that Ibn Hazn went so far as to state that God is not bound even by his own word, and that nothing would oblige him to reveal the truth to us. Were it God's will, we would even have to practice idolatry.
As far as understanding of God and thus the concrete practice of religion is concerned, we find ourselves faced with a dilemma which nowadays challenges us directly. Is the conviction that acting unreasonably contradicts God's nature merely a Greek idea, or is it always and intrinsically true? I believe that here we can see the profound harmony between what is Greek in the best sense of the word and the biblical understanding of faith in God. Modifying the first verse of the Book of Genesis, John began the prologue of his Gospel with the words: In the beginning was the logos. This is the very word used by the emperor: God acts with logos.
Logos means both reason and word-- a reason which is creative and capable of self-communication, precisely as reason. John thus spoke the final word on the biblical concept of God, and in this word all the often toilsome and tortuous threads of biblical faith find their culmination and synthesis. In the beginning was the logos, and the logos is God, says the Evangelist.
The encounter between the Biblical message and Greek thought did not happen by chance. The vision of Saint Paul, who saw the roads to Asia barred and in a dream saw a Macedonian man plead with him: Come over to Macedonia and help us! (cf. Acts 16:6-10)-- this vision can be interpreted as a distillation of the intrinsic necessity of a rapprochement between Biblical faith and Greek inquiry.
In point of fact, this rapprochement had been going on for some time. The mysterious name of God, revealed from the burning bush, a name which separates this God from all other divinities with their many names and declares simply that he is, is already presents a challenge to the notion of myth, to which Socrates's attempt to vanquish and transcend myth stands in close analogy. Within the Old Testament, the process which started at the burning bush came to new maturity at the time of the Exile, when the God of Israel, an Israel now deprived of its land and worship, was proclaimed as the God of heaven and earth and described in a simple formula which echoes the words uttered at the burning bush: I am.
This new understanding of God is accompanied by a kind of enlightenment, which finds stark expression in the mockery of gods who are merely the work of human hands (cf. Ps 115). Thus, despite the bitter conflict with those Hellenistic rulers who sought to accommodate it forcibly to the customs and idolatrous cult of the Greeks, biblical faith, in the Hellenistic period, encountered the best of Greek thought at a deep level, resulting in a mutual enrichment evident especially in the later wisdom literature.
Today we know that the Greek translation of the Old Testament produced at Alexandria-- the Septuagint-- is more than a simple (and in that sense perhaps less than satisfactory) translation of the Hebrew text: it is an independent textual witness and a distinct and important step in the history of revelation, one which brought about this encounter in a way that was decisive for the birth and spread of Christianity. A profound encounter of faith and reason is taking place here, an encounter between genuine enlightenment and religion. From the very heart of Christian faith and, at the same time, the heart of Greek thought now joined to faith, Manuel II was able to say: Not to act “with logos” is contrary to God's nature.
In all honesty, one must observe that in the late Middle Ages we find trends in theology which would sunder this synthesis between the Greek spirit and the Christian spirit. In contrast with the so-called intellectualism of Augustine and Thomas, there arose with Duns Scotus a voluntarism which ultimately led to the claim that we can only know God's voluntas ordinata. Beyond this is the realm of God's freedom, in virtue of which he could have done the opposite of everything he has actually done. This gives rise to positions which clearly approach those of Ibn Hazn and might even lead to the image of a capricious God, who is not even bound to truth and goodness. God's transcendence and otherness are so exalted that our reason, our sense of the true and good, are no longer an authentic mirror of God, whose deepest possibilities remain eternally unattainable and hidden behind his actual decisions.
As opposed to this, the faith of the Church has always insisted that between God and us, between his eternal Creator Spirit and our created reason there exists a real analogy, in which unlikeness remains infinitely greater than likeness, yet not to the point of abolishing analogy and its language (cf. Lateran IV). God does not become more divine when we push him away from us in a sheer, impenetrable voluntarism; rather, the truly divine God is the God who has revealed himself as logos and, as logos, has acted and continues to act lovingly on our behalf. Certainly, love transcends knowledge and is thereby capable of perceiving more than thought alone (cf. Eph 3:19); nonetheless it continues to be love of the God who is logos. Consequently, Christian worship is worship in harmony with the eternal Word and with our reason (cf. Rom 12:1).
This inner rapprochement between Biblical faith and Greek philosophical inquiry was an event of decisive importance not only from the standpoint of the history of religions, but also from that of world history-– it is an event which concerns us even today. Given this convergence, it is not surprising that Christianity, despite its origins and some significant developments in the East, finally took on its historically decisive character in Europe. We can also express this the other way around: this convergence, with the subsequent addition of the Roman heritage, created Europe and remains the foundation of what can rightly be called Europe.
The thesis that the critically purified Greek heritage forms an integral part of Christian faith has been countered by the call for a dehellenization of Christianity-– a call which has more and more dominated theological discussions since the beginning of the modern age. Viewed more closely, three stages can be observed in the program of dehellenization: although interconnected, they are clearly distinct from one another in their motivations and objectives.
Dehellenization first emerges in connection with the fundamental postulates of the Reformation in the 16th century. Looking at the tradition of scholastic theology, the Reformers thought they were confronted with a faith system totally conditioned by philosophy, that is to say an articulation of the faith based on an alien system of thought. As a result, faith no longer appeared as a living historical Word but as one element of an overarching philosophical system. The principle of sola scriptura, on the other hand, sought faith in its pure, primordial form, as originally found in the biblical Word. Metaphysics appeared as a premise derived from another source, from which faith had to be liberated in order to become once more fully itself. When Kant stated that he needed to set thinking aside in order to make room for faith, he carried this program forward with a radicalism that the Reformers could never have foreseen. He thus anchored faith exclusively in practical reason, denying it access to reality as a whole.
The liberal theology of the 19th and 20th centuries ushered in a second stage in the process of dehellenization, with Adolf von Harnack as its outstanding representative. When I was a student, and in the early years of my teaching, this program was highly influential in Catholic theology too. It took as its point of departure Pascal’s distinction between the God of the philosophers and the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
In my inaugural lecture at Bonn in 1959, I tried to address the issue. I will not repeat here what I said on that occasion, but I would like to describe at least briefly what was new about this second stage of dehellenization. Harnack’s central idea was to return simply to the man Jesus and to his simple message, underneath the accretions of theology and indeed of hellenization: this simple message was seen as the culmination of the religious development of humanity. Jesus was said to have put an end to worship in favor of morality. In the end he was presented as the father of a humanitarian moral message. The fundamental goal was to bring Christianity back into harmony with modern reason, liberating it, that is to say, from seemingly philosophical and theological elements, such as faith in Christ’s divinity and the triune God.
In this sense, historical-critical exegesis of the New Testament restored to theology its place within the university: theology, for Harnack, is something essentially historical and therefore strictly scientific. What it is able to say critically about Jesus is, so to speak, an expression of practical reason and consequently it can take its rightful place within the university. Behind this thinking lies the modern self-limitation of reason, classically expressed in Kant’s “Critiques”, but in the meantime further radicalized by the impact of the natural sciences. This modern concept of reason is based, to put it briefly, on a synthesis between Platonism (Cartesianism) and empiricism, a synthesis confirmed by the success of technology. On the one hand it presupposes the mathematical structure of matter, its intrinsic rationality, which makes it possible to understand how matter works and use it efficiently: this basic premise is, so to speak, the Platonic element in the modern understanding of nature. On the other hand, there is nature’s capacity to be exploited for our purposes, and here only the possibility of verification or falsification through experimentation can yield ultimate certainty. The weight between the two poles can, depending on the circumstances, shift from one side to the other. As strongly positivistic a thinker as J. Monod has declared himself a convinced Platonist/Cartesian.
This gives rise to two principles which are crucial for the issue we have raised. First, only the kind of certainty resulting from the interplay of mathematical and empirical elements can be considered scientific. Anything that would claim to be science must be measured against this criterion. Hence the human sciences, such as history, psychology, sociology, and philosophy, attempt to conform themselves to this canon of scientificity. A second point, which is important for our reflections, is that by its very nature this method excludes the question of God, making it appear an unscientific or pre-scientific question. Consequently, we are faced with a reduction of the radius of science and reason, one which needs to be questioned.
We shall return to this problem later. In the meantime, it must be observed that from this standpoint any attempt to maintain theology’s claim to be “scientific” would end up reducing Christianity to a mere fragment of its former self. But we must say more: it is man himself who ends up being reduced, for the specifically human questions about our origin and destiny, the questions raised by religion and ethics, then have no place within the purview of collective reason as defined by “science” and must thus be relegated to the realm of the subjective. The subject then decides, on the basis of his experiences, what he considers tenable in matters of religion, and the subjective “conscience” becomes the sole arbiter of what is ethical. In this way, though, ethics and religion lose their power to create a community and become a completely personal matter.
This is a dangerous state of affairs for humanity, as we see from the disturbing pathologies of religion and reason which necessarily erupt when reason is so reduced that questions of religion and ethics no longer concern it. Attempts to construct an ethic from the rules of evolution or from psychology and sociology, end up being simply inadequate.
Before I draw the conclusions to which all this has been leading, I must briefly refer to the third stage of dehellenization, which is now in progress. In the light of our experience with cultural pluralism, it is often said nowadays that the synthesis with Hellenism achieved in the early Church was a preliminary inculturation which ought not to be binding on other cultures. The latter are said to have the right to return to the simple message of the New Testament prior to that inculturation, in order to inculturate it anew in their own particular milieux. This thesis is not only false; it is coarse and lacking in precision. The New Testament was written in Greek and bears the imprint of the Greek spirit, which had already come to maturity as the Old Testament developed. True, there are elements in the evolution of the early Church which do not have to be integrated into all cultures. Nonetheless, the fundamental decisions made about the relationship between faith and the use of human reason are part of the faith itself; they are developments consonant with the nature of faith itself.
And so I come to my conclusion. This attempt, painted with broad strokes, at a critique of modern reason from within has nothing to do with putting the clock back to the time before the Enlightenment and rejecting the insights of the modern age. The positive aspects of modernity are to be acknowledged unreservedly: we are all grateful for the marvelous possibilities that it has opened up for mankind and for the progress in humanity that has been granted to us. The scientific ethos, moreover, is the will to be obedient to the truth, and, as such, it embodies an attitude which reflects one of the basic tenets of Christianity. The intention here is not one of retrenchment or negative criticism, but of broadening our concept of reason and its application.
While we rejoice in the new possibilities open to humanity, we also see the dangers arising from these possibilities and we must ask ourselves how we can overcome them. We will succeed in doing so only if reason and faith come together in a new way, if we overcome the self-imposed limitation of reason to the empirically verifiable, and if we once more disclose its vast horizons. In this sense theology rightly belongs in the university and within the wide-ranging dialogue of sciences, not merely as a historical discipline and one of the human sciences, but precisely as theology, as inquiry into the rationality of faith.
Only thus do we become capable of that genuine dialogue of cultures and religions so urgently needed today. In the Western world it is widely held that only positivistic reason and the forms of philosophy based on it are universally valid. Yet the world’s profoundly religious cultures see this exclusion of the divine from the universality of reason as an attack on their most profound convictions. A reason which is deaf to the divine and which relegates religion into the realm of subcultures is incapable of entering into the dialogue of cultures. At the same time, as I have attempted to show, modern scientific reason with its intrinsically Platonic element bears within itself a question which points beyond itself and beyond the possibilities of its methodology.
Modern scientific reason quite simply has to accept the rational structure of matter and the correspondence between our spirit and the prevailing rational structures of nature as a given, on which its methodology has to be based. Yet the question why this has to be so is a real question, and one which has to be remanded by the natural sciences to other modes and planes of thought: to philosophy and theology.
For philosophy and, albeit in a different way, for theology, listening to the great experiences and insights of the religious traditions of humanity, and those of the Christian faith in particular, is a source of knowledge, and to ignore it would be an unacceptable restriction of our listening and responding. Here I am reminded of something Socrates said to Phaedo. In their earlier conversations, many false philosophical opinions had been raised, and so Socrates says: “It would be easily understandable if someone became so annoyed at all these false notions that for the rest of his life he despised and mocked all talk about being - but in this way he would be deprived of the truth of existence and would suffer a great loss”.
The West has long been endangered by this aversion to the questions which underlie its rationality, and can only suffer great harm thereby. The courage to engage the whole breadth of reason, and not the denial of its grandeur – this is the program with which a theology grounded in Biblical faith enters into the debates of our time. “Not to act reasonably (with logos) is contrary to the nature of God”, said Manuel II, according to his Christian understanding of God, in response to his Persian interlocutor. It is to this great logos, to this breadth of reason, that we invite our partners in the dialogue of cultures. To rediscover it constantly is the great task of the university.
The Times, September 16th, 2006.
The Pope's Regensburg address:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,13509-2360088,00.html
The Pope’s speech was entitled Faith, reason and the university. This is an edited extract:
"I was reminded of all this recently, when I read the edition by Professor Theodore Khoury (Münster) of part of the dialogue carried on, perhaps in 1391, by the erudite Byzantine emperor Manuel II Paleologus and an educated Persian on the subject of Christianity and Islam, and the truth of both.
The dialogue ranges widely over the structures of faith contained in the Bible and in the Koran. . . In the seventh conversation the emperor touches on the theme of the holy war. The emperor must have known that Sura (Koranic chapter) 2, 256 reads: ‘There is no compulsion in religion.’ According to the experts, this is one of the suras of the early period, when Mohammed was still powerless and under threat. But naturally the emperor also knew the instructions, developed later and recorded in the Koran, concerning holy war .. . . He addresses his interlocutor with a startling brusqueness on the central question about the relationship between religion and violence, saying: ‘Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.’
The emperor, having expressed himself so forcefully, goes on to explain the reasons why spreading the faith through violence is something unreasonable. Violence is incompatible with the nature of God and the nature of the soul. ‘God,’ he says, ‘is not pleased by blood — and not acting reasonably . . . is contrary to God’s nature. Faith is born of the soul, not the body. Whoever would lead someone to faith needs the ability to speak well and to reason properly, without violence and threats . . . To convince a reasonable soul, one does not need a strong arm, or weapons, or any other means of threatening a person with death . . .’ The decisive statement in this argument against violent conversion is this: not to act in accordance with reason is contrary to God’s nature. Theodore Khoury, observes: For the emperor, as a Byzantine shaped by Greek philosophy, this is self-evident.
But for Muslim teaching, God is absolutely transcendent. His will is not bound up with any of our categories, even that of rationality. At this point, as far as understanding of God and thus the practice of religion is concerned, we are faced with an unavoidable dilemma. Is the conviction that acting unreasonably contradicts God’s nature merely a Greek idea, or is it always and intrinsically true? . . . John began the prologue of his Gospel with the words: ‘In the beginning was the Word.’ This is the very word used by the emperor: God acts, with logos. Logos means reason and word — reason which is creative and capable of self-communication, precisely as reason. A profound encounter of faith and reason is taking place here, between genuine enlightenment and religion . . . This inner rapprochement between biblical faith and Greek philosophical inquiry was an event of decisive importance not only from the standpoint of the history of religions, but also from that of world history . . .
Given this convergence, it is not surprising that Christianity, despite its origins and some significant developments in the East, took on its historically decisive character in Europe. In the Western world it is widely held that only positivistic reason and the forms of philosophy based on it are universally valid. Yet the world’s profoundly religious cultures see this exclusion of the divine from the universality of reason as an attack on their most profound convictions. The West has long been endangered by this aversion to the questions which underlie its rationality, and can only suffer great harm thereby. The courage to engage the breadth of reason, and not the denial of its grandeur — this is the programme with which a theology grounded in biblical faith enters into the debates of our time. ‘Not to act reasonably, not to act with logos, is contrary to the nature of God,’ said Manuel II, according to his under-standing of God. It is to this great logos, this breadth of reason, that we invite our partners in the dialogue of cultures."
And this is what a Liberal Says: Note how a liberal says "peace be upon him" because the liberal is now a god fearing Muslim, he doesnt of course refer to the Pope as "his holiness" or use any such superlatives when speaking of Jesus, the new liberal is indeed a religious fascist.
From Aljazera.com:
Pope invited to a public debate
By Ahmed Janabi
Friday 15 September 2006, 13:39 Makka Time, 10:39 GMT
A Sharia professor at Qatar University has invited Pope Benedict XVI to participate in a public debate to challenge his recent comments about Islam.
Muhammad Ayash al-Kubaisi sent a letter on Thursday to the pope asking him to participate in a public debate to discuss the issues he had raised during his six-day visit to Germany.
Pope Benedict XVI caused controversy during a visit to his native Bavaria when he criticised the Islamic concept of jihad [holy war].
The letter which was sent to Aljazeera.net said that such statements would cause cultural and religious clashes between the East and West.
It described the Pope's statements as evidence of ignorance of Islamic teachings, labelling the act a free gift to the current US administration which would use those critical remarks to justify the aggression on Muslim territories such as Afghanistan and Iraq.
Responding to the Pope's statement that Islam was spread by force, al-Kubaisi said: "If the non-Arab Muslims in Iran, Pakistan and Indonesia etc. were forced by Arabs to enter Islam, why are they still sticking to their religion knowing the Arab Muslims lost the power long time ago?"
Spreading Islam
Al-Kubaisi told Aljazeera.net : "Let us look at who spread Islam in the Middles Ages - the Turkish Ottomans through the Ottoman Empire (1481-1922), and the Mughal empire (early 16th to the mid-18th century). So if those were forced to enter Islam, is it possible they bother to spread it? I do not think so."
he explained that the Quran gives a clear signal in Verse 2: 256 where it refers to there being "no force in religion".
The letter described shock at the Pope's statement, saying it pours oil on fire, at a time when everybody expects the pontiff to join the efforts to bridge the gap between East and West.
Widening the gap would serve the interests of no one, the letter said.
Muslim scholars and religious leaders in Kuwait, Turkey and Pakistan have criticised Pope Benedict XVI for his remarks about Islam and urged him to play a positive role in bringing Islam and Christianity closer.
Jihad
During a six-day visit to his native Germany this week, the Pope criticised Islam and its concept of jihad (holy war), citing a 14th-century Christian emperor who said that Prophet Muhammad had brought the world "evil and inhuman" things.
"Violence is incompatible with the nature of God and the nature of the soul," he said on Tuesday in an address at Regensburg University.
Father Federico Lombardi, a Vatican spokesman, later said he did not believe the Pope's words were meant as a harsh criticism of Islam.
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/948BB17B-7515-401C-8566-AFF195334309.htm
Personally, I have no love of the Catholic faith, nor of any of man's corruption of God's message to man. However, having read the speech, I don't understand what the problem is, he spoke against violence for all religions and called for greater dialogue.
Tim Stokes, UK
How many Muslims have reacted to the sectarian violence in Iraq, where Shia and Sunnis kill each other? Why the silence and when someone issues a statement they find displeasing, they get angry?
Stephen Hall, Qatar
The pope, and indeed much of Europe, should be the last people on earth to criticise the Muslim world especially in light of the millions who perished for the sake of "the cross". The world needs a history lesson!
Joe
This shows the ignorance of the pope and I want Muslims to know that not all Christians bow to him nor do we think as he does.
Shirley Peterson, Canada
The pope's thesis is clear: Violence in the name of religion [any religion] is wrong! The pope may have misunderstood the place of the Prophet in Islam [peace be upon him], which is contrary to a Christian view of a prophet, where such reverence is reserved for God alone. But let's engage with this invitation to stamp on men of violence and their evil ways! May Allah grant us peace.
Phil, UK
I think it's time for Muslims across the globe to stop crying wolf any time someone criticises their beliefs.
Ache, UK
How come when a cartoon is drawn or someone makes insulting comments the Ummah rallies and condemns these things; but daily slaughters of Muslims in Palestine, Kashmir, Chechnya, Uzbekistan, Iraq etc go unanswered?
A dead child is more insulting to me than ignorant words. who cares what the pope says?
Andrew Yusuf, USA
The pope makes reference to a 14th-century Christian emperor who said that Prophet Muhammad had brought the world "evil and inhuman" things.
Do the homework. Muhammad did bring "evil and inhuman" things. As did the Catholic Church during those times. So what? That was then, this is now.
Muslim, Christian, Jewish, Buddhist...
Who cares? Everyone needs to calm down. Let their neighbour practise whatever his or her religion is, and just ignore what others say.
My wife is Catholic. I'm Protestant. The family across the street are Muslim. My son is best friends with their son. We respect each other's beliefs.
Matt Hensley, USA
Anger. It is strange though, that we hardly hear any protests from angry Muslims when radical Islamists urge people to use terrorism in order to promote their goals.
Dag, Sweden/Bangladesh
ABC
Pope Offends Muslims Worldwide
By MARTIN SEEMUNGAL
ROME, Italy, Sept. 15, 2006— Pope Benedict delivered a speech at Regensburg University earlier this week, where he once taught theology. His speech focused mainly on Christianity and what he called the tendency to "exclude the question of God" from reason. Islam was a small part of his speech, but its mention created an enormous controversy.
The pope quoted from a book that recounted the words of a 14th century Byzantine Emperor, Manuel II Palaeologus. The book quoted a conversation between the emperor and an "educated Persian." The topic was Christianity and Islam.
There was relatively little reaction right away. But by Thursday it seemed the whole Muslim world had been stirred.
On Thursday evening the Vatican found itself scrambling to issue a statement as it tried to defuse the situation: "It certainly wasn't the intention of the pope to carry out a deep examination of jihad and Muslim thought on it, much less to offend the sensibility of Muslim believers," said the Rev. Federico Lombardi, speaking for the Vatican. He insisted that the pope respects Islam.
But now many in the Muslim world have called for the pope to withdraw the remarks and issue an apology. The Muslim Brotherhood has called on Islamic countries to break relations with the Vatican if the pope does not make an apology. According to The Associated Press, the 57-nation Organization of the Islamic Conference, the world's largest Muslim body, said quotations used by the pope represented a "character assassination of the Prophet Mohammed" and a "smear campaign." Similarly, the Pakistani government passed a resolution condemning the pope's words, saying, according to the AP, "This house demands the pope retract his remarks in the interest of harmony among different religions."
Particularly worrying for the Vatican and the pope is the reaction in predominately Muslim Turkey. The pope is scheduled to visit Turkey at the end of November.
A top cleric in Turkey, Ali Bardakoglu, told NTV that the pope's remarks were "saddening and unfortunate." Bardakoglu said it would be even worse "if the pope was reflecting the spite, hatred and enmity" that Bardakoglu believes some in the Christian world direct toward Islam.
The danger of this spinning out of control is apparent, and real. And concerns have been raised that the pope might have to delay or even cancel the Turkey trip, a trip in part about reconciliation, ironically, between the Catholic Church and Orthodox Christians in Turkey.
The pope said, "The emperor comes to speak about the issue of jihad, holy war." Continuing, the pope said, "I quote, 'Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached."
The pope characterized the emperor's words as "surprisingly brusque." He also recounted how the emperor explained that spreading faith through violence is unreasonable, since violence is incompatible with God. A few sentences later, the pope was back to analyzing Christian theology.
Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi later told reporters that the pope did not intend to give "an interpretation of Islam as violent."
The speech and the quotes were carried in major papers around the world. Some raised the question that, given existing interfaith tensions, the pope's remarks might spark anger.
The pope makes his next public appearance on Sunday. And the pope, as is tradition, is expected to deliver an address, usually a message for Christians around the world. But this Sunday there will no doubt be many Muslims listening, to see if the pope has a message for them.
http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/60F307D9-8A08-48E0-8AD6-C3731B7F66EE.htm
Pope criticised over Islam remarks
Friday 15 September 2006, 9:47 Makka Time, 6:47 GMT
Muslim scholars and religious leaders have criticised Pope Benedict XVI for his remarks about Islam and urged him to play a positive role in bringing Islam and Christianity closer.
Ali Bardakoglu, head of the state-run religious affairs directorate in Turkey, said on Thursday that Pope Benedict XVI was "full of enmity and grudge" against Islam. He opposed the pontiff's planned visit to Turkey in November.
Bardakoglu also demanded that the pope should immediately retract and issue an apology for his remarks about Islam and his criticism of the concept of jihad (holy war).
The pontiff's remarks "reflect the hatred in his heart. It is a statement full of enmity and grudge", Bardakoglu told the NTV news channel on Thursday.
"It is a prejudiced and biased approach."
Islam criticised
During a six-day visit to his native Germany this week, the pope criticised Islam and its concept of jihad, citing a 14th-century Christian emperor who said that Prophet Muhammad had brought the world "evil and inhuman" things.
"Violence is incompatible with the nature of God and the nature of the soul," he said on Tuesday in an address at Regensburg University.
The Vatican press office said in a statement the pope had not intended to carry out an in-depth study of jihad and Muslim thinking about it, "even less to offend the sensitivity of the Muslim faithful".
Federico Lombardi, the Vatican chief spokesman, said: "It is clear that the Holy Father's intention is to cultivate a position of respect and dialogue towards other religions and cultures, and that clearly includes Islam."
He said a careful reading of the Pope's lecture would show that "what really matters to the Holy Father is a clear and radical rejection of religious motives for violence".
Bardakoglu, however, described them as unacceptable.
"[The pope's] approach is a spoilt and cocksure point of view that looks down on the other. At times, we also criticise the Christian world for its wrongs, but we never defame either Christ or the Bible or the holiness of Christianity."
In comments to the Anatolia news agency, Bardakoglu said the pope carried the same mindset as that "of the Crusades" which arose from the Church's view that Islam is the enemy.
Apology call
In Kuwait, two high-ranking Islamist officials also called on Pope Benedict XVI to apologise for his remarks.
Hakim al-Mutairi, secretary-general of the emirate's Umma (Islamic Nation) party, urged the pope to to apologise immediately "to the Muslim world for his calumnies against the Prophet Muhammad and Islam".
Al-Mutairi denounced the pope's "unaccustomed and unprecedented" remarks, and linked the Catholic Church leader's comments to "new Western wars currently under way in the Muslim world in places such as Afghanistan, Iraq and Lebanon".
The pope's statements amounted to "the pursuit of Crusades", he said.
"I call on all Arab and Islamic states to recall their ambassadors from the Vatican and expel those from the Vatican until the pope says he is sorry for the wrong done to the Prophet and to Islam, which preaches peace, tolerance, justice and equality," al-Mutairi said.
Sayid Baqir al-Muhri, head of the assembly of Shia ulemas (Shia theologians) in Kuwait, labelled the pope's comments "unrealistic and unjustified", and also called on him to apologise.
"His unjustified attack on Islam and the Prophet Muhammad clearly contradicts his call for dialogue between civilisations," al-Muhri said. "It opens the way to animosity between religions.
"We demand that the pope make a public apology" to help bring an end to animosity.
'Positive role'
The pope was also criticised by Muslim scholars and religious leaders in Pakistan who urged him to play a positive role in bringing Islam and Christianity closer.
Khurshid Ahmed, head of the Institute of Policy Studies in Islamabad, said: "It is very unfortunate that a religious leader of his stature is issuing statements which can fan religious disharmony.
"The Pope's attitude is very different from his predecessor. Instead of bringing Islam and Christianity closer, he is straining relations between the two religions," Ahmed said.
"In the present political atmosphere such views can be exploited by those who are trying to malign Muslims and Islam.
"We expect the Pope to play a positive role in promoting relations between religions and civilisations.
"The Pope's views about the role of Sharia [Islamic law] and jihad are at variance with Muslim beliefs."
Hafiz Hussain Ahmed, a leader of the Jammiat Ulema-e-Islam party and an MP, urged the Pope not to take inspiration from George Bush, the US president.
He said: "The Pope is a respected personality not only for Christians but for Muslims also. He should not lower his stature by giving Bush-like statements."
Shahid Shamsi, spokesman for the Jamaat-i-Islami party, said:"The Pope's statement was an attempt to jeopardise a remarkable unity displayed by Christians and Muslims against recent Israeli aggression in Lebanon."


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home