Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

More problems with Edward Said

Thanks for the quick reply. That is a very interesting idea. Tom Segev's 'One Palestine Complete' and of course books on Wingate and Burton have touched on this topic. It has a parallel in the British rule in India and elsewhere, where British soldiers individually supported various people's. For instance as I understand it many British officers were more partial to Malays over Chinese and Hindus in Malaysia, seeing the Malaysians as a 'martial race' and in India the same prejudice led the British to appreciate Muslims and Sikhs over Hindus, who were frequently seen as dishonest.

The fascinating thing I found in my research about Palestine in the Mandate was the fact that, unlike in Iraq and Egypt, the British had no real connection to the local Christian Arab community but preferred the educated Muslim elite and the Bedouins, not the Fellahin(peasants). But in Iraq the British preferred trained many Assyrians for service and in Egypt they hired mostly Copts, so many that they brought them to Palestine to build and run the railroad and serve in the household.

I wonder if those who objected to the Arabs fall into two classes, firstly those who liked the Jews, partly as Christian-Zionists, like Oliphant, Mienertzhagen and Wingate. Secondly those who simply didn't trust the Arabs or didn't identity with them. The British did not however find the Druze to be 'martial' in the way that the Israelis eventually did. It is a truly multi-faceted subject with many parallels elsewhere. One only must think of the French connection to the Maronites.

I wonder also how much the anti-Semitic(or rather in this case anti-Jewish) question falls into those, there is no record with Lawrence, but I have read quite sobering anti-Jewish comments from other officers who served in Palestine and were supportive of the Arabs.

I have to ask you personally your view of Said's thesis. I have read his book and am familiar with his theory but I find it troubling. If those who were Orientalists are considered racists or imperialists then it makes me wonder this: If the orientalist, such as Lawrence, is seen as belittling the 'natives' by trying to commiserate with them, being sympathetic and at the same time pretending to be one is seen as a negative in western academic history. Then is the logical conclusion that those who simply were not at all interested in local cultural history, those who simply completely rejected any interest in other parts of the world and other cultures, are they positive. And if so, doesn’t that lead to the logical decline of any discipline in history that studies the 'other'. Forcing us to rely only on how the 'other' portrays himself.

And if that’s the case, then why should the 'other' be allowed to write a history of us? It seems like an extraordinarily simplistic and to my mind wrong-headed view of things. The 'other', for instance in the case of the Palestinians is not a monolith. He has a dozen cultures within him. If it were left up to the Sunni Arab elite, which is who Said would lead us to believe know the 'true' history of the Arabs, we would ignore the Copts, the Maronites, the Kurds, the Shia, the Ismaili, the Wahhabi, the Persian, the Turkish, the Berber, the Fellah, the Alewites, the Circassian, the Druze, the Armenian, the Chaldean and the Assyrian, not to mention the Nubian, Jewish and many other views of what is the 'correct' Arab-Muslim-Middle Eastern view of their world. Which is why I object to so much of Arab scholarship on the Middle East, it is as Arabo-Muslim centric as our history is accused of being Eurocentric, ignoring everything that begins before 632 and anyone who is not Arab speaking or ethnically Arab.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home