on Palestinian whining and europeans
The Palestinians are expert complainers. They have been tought by 60 years of UN rule over them to complain and whine. They have been fed at the breast of the refugee industry. It is no suprise. If Jews had been kept in refugee camps in Europe after the war(as they initially were, some until 1949, see the book 'Postwar') the Jews would have turned into the same phenomenon as the Palestinians, a people endlessely unable to get back on their feet, endlessly complaining and not accepted. If the same standards that have been applied to the Palestinians(for instance re-defining the definition of 'refugee' to make it extend forever past the third generation, a rule that does not apply to ANY other group) were applied to Congolese or Rwandans or Sikhs or Chinese or others(say south vietnamese Hmong) and they were issued refugee cards they too would be Palestinians. But take a good historical look at the situations in Vietnam in 1976 and in India/Pakistan in 1948. In India and Pakistan some 10 million people changed hands, Muslims going to pakistan, Sikhs and Hindus completely ethnically cleansed and going to India. In Pakistan to this day there is an entire seperate caste that is made up of these Indian Muslims who number some 20% or more of the country. They didnt disappear completely. But they dont want to go back. They settled among their brethren(and Pakistan is quite diverse being made up of Baluchis, Pathans and other peoples all of whome are Muslim). The same is true in India. In the Punjab and Haryana and Delhi their are still today millions of descendants of these refugees. Especially the Sikhs do not forget that their nation, half of it, was torn from its ancestral countries. But there were no books written about them, no history of them, no documentation of their lands and names, and thus they were never encouraged to return. They were instead encoruaged by the Gandhian government to forget thier suffering and move forward.
In Southeast asia, the many refugee movements associated with the end of the Vietnam war, which included millions of people, including Hmong, CHinese, Vietnamese and others, mostly solved itself.
We might examine the situation of the Jews who were forced to flee the Muslim lands, some 500,000 between 1945 and 1967. These Jews from Yemen, Iraq, Egypt, Libya, Algeria and Syria, Lebanon and Turkey, they fled, many were forced to leave and their property taken. We have no long books dedicated to reclaiming their lands, their houses, their properties. They do not carry refugee cards.
SO why only with the Palestinians? It is not true what people are taught, that the Palestinians were all rejected by the Arabs. The majority of the Palestinians refugees went to the West Bank, Gaza and Jordan. Only a smaller number went to Syria and Lebanon and Egypt. In the West Bank and Jordan they were given Jordanian citizenship, which was only taken away from them in 1994. They became Jordanians. Check the hsitory, there are still people in the West Bank who keep a picture of King Hussien at home and carry their Jordanian I.D. In 1967 when they fell under Israeli rule they remained Jordanian citizens. The Palestinians who live in Jordan today, and those have citizenship, number some 70% of the country.
Mostly in Lebanon they suffered the most because the unique ethnic balance between Druze, Sunni, MAronite and Shia. The influx of some 100,000 or less Palestinians could not be allowed to tip the balance in favor of the Sunnis. Thus only the MAronite and shia refugees were given citizenship, but almost all Palestinians are Sunni. So it was in Lebanon that the refugee camp system truly harmed them and it was there that they rose in rebellion to form a mini-state in 1975 and caused the Lebanese civil war in 1976.
But the ones in 'Egypt' those refugees resided in Gaza or in Rafah(which is divided by the border). They were not given citizenship by anyone and probably are the worst off, but they were given back to Israel after 1967 anf thus the unos falls on Israel to have granted them independence, which Israel did in a semi way in 2005 with Disengagement. of course we see how thats turned out.
But what of the 300,000 Palestinians refugees from Kuawit? Finkelstien might not tell you about them. After 1948 many Palestinians didnt sit in camps, the immigrated, more than 100,000 to 200,000 came to the United States, people like Edward Said's father, and mostly Christian refugees. Men like Arafat moved first to Cairo and then to Kuwait. Kuwait brought in almost half a million Palestinians to do their work, their housecleaning and things that the rich sheikhs couldnt be brought to do. Palestinians were well educated(at that time) and they were good workers. In 1991 when Saddam invaded Kuwait the Palestinians supported Saddam hussien and plundered the Kuwaitis who had hired them. After all Saddam was a supporter of the Palestinians and he himself had paid for the terror group Abu Nidal and was a friend of Arafat. So when Kuwait was liberated by the United States in 1991, the Kuwaitis expelled every single Palestinian. They were forced to come back mostly to Jordan and the west bank. Kuwait replaced them with Indonesians and Pakistanis. But dont worry there will be no 'refugee' status for those people, many of whome lived in Kuwait for 40 years or more, which for as many as 100,000 of the Palestinians 'refugees' from 1948 was the same period they had lived in Palestine. If you check Walid Khalidi's "all that remains" you will find just how many of the Palestinian 'villages' were in fact recent creations, whose populations fluctuated greatly during the period.
As for Fisk you are wrong there. Read his book. He states quite clearly he thinks it is unfair that the Jews get to have the 'Holocaust' and not the Armenians. Ask Fisk if we can use the word 'Nakba' to describe what happaned in to the Native Americans or the Sikhs. Lets see if he likes any light taken away from his pet Palestinians and Lebanese. Holocaust is a word for Jews. It is. It is word for the Holocaust. Not for the 'holocausts'. And Fisk likes to use the word 'Holocaust' for all sorts of things, just like the word 'Nazi' because he does not see the uniqueness of the Holocaust, he thinks it is not so important and he thinks that because he is not interested in the Jews. But the Armenians are no closer to getting their event called even a genocide. It is illegal in Turkey to even mention the word 'genocide' and the word 'armenian' in the same sentence. It is illegal to mention in Turkey that before 1915 Armenians and Assyrians and Greeks made up 25% of the population in their country and they now make up .01%. Ask a Turk where they went. The national media is forced to call it the "mass killings of Armenians" out of a fear of 'offending' the Turks. Imagine if we weren't allowed to call it the holocaust because of a fear of 'offending' the Germans. So playing with words isnt helping the Armenians. It was indeed the Armenian Genocide that was the first genocide of the 20th century. But we arn't any closer to getting that recognized, despite a french law making it illegal to deny it.
And Israel Shahak, I dont know if he is a holocaust survivor, but he is an anti-semite.
How do we know this?
Well we go to Amazon.com and we search for his book "Jewish History, Jewish Religion: The Weight of Three Thousand Years (Pluto Middle Eastern Studies) (Paperback) by Israel Shahak " And then we look at who bought that book: They bought these books:
Judaism's Strange Gods by Michael A. Hoffman 51 Documents: Zionist Collaboration With the Nazis by Lenni Brenner The Israeli Holocaust Against the Palestinians by Michael A Hoffman The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering, New Edition by Norman G. Finkelstein Jewish Fundamentalism In Israel: New Introduction by Norton Mezvinsky (Pluto Middle Eastern Studies) by Israel Shahak
And they can purchase it for a deal with this book: "Buy this book with Judaism's Strange Gods by Michael A. Hoffman today!" Which is an anti-semitic text.
And look who is involved also:"The Culture of Critique: An Evolutionary Analysis of Jewish Involvement in Twentieth-Century Intellectual and Political Movements Paperback by Kevin B. MacDonald " a known anti-semiteauthor of:Understanding Jewish Influence Paperback by Kevin MacDonald Separation and Its Discontents Toward an Evolutionary Theory of Anti-Semitism Paperback by Kevin MacDonald
and of course:Defensive Racism Hardcover by Edgar J. Steele a racist text
and look who elsle is involved:The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering, New Edition Paperback by Norman G. Finkelstein
andThe Secret World Government or the Hidden Hand: The Unrevealed in History Paperback by Count Cherep-Spiridovich
andThe Politics of Anti-Semitism Paperback by Alexander Cockburn
andSix-Pointed Star: Its Origin and Usage Paperback by O. J. Graham
andThe Great War for Civilisation: The Conquest of the Middle East Hardcover by Robert Fisk
andThe Unseen Hand Paperback by A. Ralph Epperson
and another click away we get these 'wonderful' texts:
One Sheaf, One Vine: Racially Conscious White Americans Talk About Race by Robert S. Griffin A Race Against Time: Racial Heresies for the 21st Century by Jared Taylor The Culture of Critique: An Evolutionary Analysis of Jewish Involvement in Twentieth-Century Intellectual and Political Movements by Kevin B. MacDonald Race Differences in Intelligence: An Evolutionary Analysis by Richard Lynn Race, Evolution, and Behavior: A Life History Perspective (3rd Edition) by J. Philippe Rushton
Be careful who your bedfellows are. And Israel Shahak has many bedfellows and many of them are the intellectual descendants of the race theorists like Alfred Rosenberg(not a Jew by the way) who engineered the theory behind the Holocaust. After all a great number of high up Nazis were academics. People like Adolf Eichman also read books on Talmud and spoke Hebrew. And that while they were busy deporitng 400,000 Jews from Hungary in 1944. Yes they 'studied the Jews'. They set up museums of Judaism and called them 'museums to a vanished race'.
Those who today own and worship Mien Kampf, they are aided in their hatred by Finkelstien and Shahak, by Kimmerling and Pappe, and by Chomsky. It is the Jews, tragically, who aid anti-semitism though their endless bockering and self hate. The ultra-orthodox Neturie Karta marched with Hizbullah in the recent lebanon war, because they hate Israel. So the tragic links with anti-semitism and Jew-hatred stretches from the most extreme religious Jews to the most secualr Jews who reject their Judaism and reject the notion of the Jews as a people. They reject the uniqueness of the Holocaust and meanwhile the Orthodox blame the Holocaust on the Jews "because the Jews became assimilated and rejected Torah". Thanks to the religion we have reasons to reject the Holocaust for religious reasons and thanks tot he Secular we have reasons to reject the Holocaust because it was used by the 'bad' Zionists and because the 'Zionists collaborated with Hitler' and because it was sued for financial gain and because the Jews 'were not the majority of those killed in the Holocaust'.
After all who goes to the rallies supporting the Palestinians? Lesbians, feminists, communists, nazis, islamists, Secular leftist Jews, Orthodox Jews, socialists, Arabs, Muslims. Yes, strange bedfellows?
I prefer to stay away from them all. After all if one can find a place where the COmmunist, the Nazi and the Islamist agree on something, I am sure it is wrong. Because we can remmember the crimes of Nazism, Communism and Islamism.
And why do the Palestinians complain that the U.S and U.K created the partition? because they think both the UK and the U.S are controlled by Jews, many beleive in fact that the UK is 20% Jewish and the U.S 50% Jewish. They see this as 'imperialism'. But it is all a scam. The Ottomans settled the Jews and the Circassians in Palestine in order to blunt Arab rebelliousness. They thought it would revive the land, which was lying fallow and malaria stricken. It was the British who gave independence to these Arab countries and helped create them all. Egyptians and Jordanians and Iraqis were never truly colonized. Turkey neither. THe idea of colonization is mostly a myth in the middle east. Persia and Saudi arabia were never colonized. Afghanistan was never colonized. So when muslims whine about colonialism they are mostly lying. Most of them never really lived under colonialism. The only great colonialism in the muslim world was in Algeria where some 1 million French settlers arrived. REAL colonialism took place in Southern Africa, India, Southeast Asia and the Americas. Dont let the Arabs fool you, they were never colonized to the degree they pretend they were. And those borders they pretend are all fake are mostly historical. Sinai has always been a border of Egypt. Arab Iraq and Persian Iran were always seperated as they are today. There was always a division between Turkey and Arab Syria. The borders of Jordan and Saudi always existed if only because these countries were made of nomads. The borders of Palestine are also relatively historical even if it belonged to Syria. In addition the Lebanon was always a seperate idea and a seperate entity.
If the Europeans today reject the idea of partition ask them what they are doing in Kosovo. Are they not partitioning Yugoslavia. How was Kosovo created? It was 50% Serb in 1950. Why is it today 100% Albanian. And it was also 4% Gypsy in 1950, today it is 0% Gypsy. Where did they go? And before World War Two, before the Nazis allied themselves with the Albanians(and the Palestinian Mufit recruited them even to fight alongside Hitler) the Serbs were something like 70% of Kosovo. So what did the international community do in 1998? We invaded Kosovo and decided, as was done with Palestine, that it should be independent. We also colonized Bosnia at the same time, and dont kid yourself it is colonization because white europeans today run Kosovo, Bosnia and even East Timor.
And dont ask the international community about the Turkish colonization of Cyrpus where they have imported some 100,000 immigrant Turk settlers to the eastern side of the island. But dont worry there arn't any books about the Greek refugees, and dont ask about the Turkish settlers, there are no books on them and no refugee camps for the Greeks. But read the history of Cyprus, it is not so different than Palestine. And of course perhaps you can also investigate what happaned in Ngorno-Karabagh in Armenia, a place colonized by the Russians, split off from Armenia, populated with Azeris and now in open rebellion.
Palestine wasnt the first time europeans drew lines on a map. Unlike other empires such as the Ottomans or the Romans, the Europeans used empire to try and solve conflicts, in many cases they made them worse, but the Turkish view was to simply destroy and enslave communities, so the european case seems more humane. But then those same europeans work to axacerbate the problems in the middle east and that is the tragedy. Had they left the middle east, the way they did India or SOutheast asia, the problems would have been resolved.
Oh well,


1 Comments:
Actually, it is the jews who fuel the flames of antisemtitism through their Hubris and their unmitigated sense of entitlement!
Not to mention the fact that the rest of the world is SICK TO DEATH of your incessant holocaust whining as a way to mooch sympathy and gather funds for Israel.
12:49 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home