thoughts on Carter and liberalism
Well its worse than that because I think that Israel is trying to give back most of the land to the Palestinians and has tried at a number of times to do it. From 1948-1967 Israel didnt occupy any Palestinians, of course it still suffered terrorism. But that period is usually conveniently written out of history books so that Israeli history begins in 1948 and then jumps to 1967, it makes it easier to blame all the problems on the 'occupation'. And in 1994 Israel agreed to give back almost all the west bank and Gaza and administratively gave back 90% of it. But terrorism, magically, didnt stop. Then in 2000 Barak begged Arafat to take 98% of the land and of course then all of a sudden Arafat wanted East Jerusalem, the old city and of course the return of 5 million Palestinian 'refugees' to Israel. Well that wasn't going to happen, so there had to be 5 more years of terrorism. And then Israel pulled out of Gaza, but people like Jimmy Carter said that the disengagement from Gaza doesnt end the Occupation because "Israel maintains control over the maritime rights of Gaza and over the airspace and borders and thus continues her occupation" which is a nice way of changing internaitonal law, except in the case of San Morena, Andorra, Bhutan, Swaziland, Nepal and Lesotho, all of which are controlled by the countries that souround them(i.e Italy, Spain, India and South Africa) but we apparently dont refer to them as occupied territory, and we dont apparently refer to Tibet as occupied territory either, although according to that same venerable internaitonal law, that everyone holds to be sacred, it is.
Mr. Carter is a shameful individual and it is suprising that he was president and pretended to be an 'honest broker' and then has the GALL to accuse other presidents of not being 'honest in their brokering of peace between the Palestinians and ISrael(i.e Clinton and Bush and Nixon and Reagan) when he himself has sunk so low in his obvious bias. But Mr. Carter wants us all to beleive he was not biased. Yeah, ok Mr. Carter, when you are acting as a spokesman for the smae idiocy that the palestinians shout as propoganda, but you give it the legitimacy of the stamp of a former president of the United States. How pathetic.
And the worst of it is this one. Those allies of Mr. Carter, like Noam Chomsky, Norman Finkelstien and the Walt and Mersheimer report at Harvard, that claims that the 'bad' Jewish-Zionist-Israeli-banking lobby controls U.S foreign policy in the middle east have some explaining to do now that a former president has apparently come under the influence of the Israel-hate crowd. So apparently the Zionist conspiracy that controls the country, according to those harvard brahmans Walt and Merhsemeir who authored their sad report a year ago, didnt control Carter. Or did it? Is that why Carter wasnt able to do in 1979 what he claims the U.S should do now, which is force Israel to do all sorts of things, like give away the old city, give away every inch of the territories and the golan heights and the so-called Shaba farms(three acres of land over which the Hizbullah claims it is fighting Israel, but used as an excuse to claim ISrael 'occupies' Lebanon). Perhaps Carter's hand was held by the Jew lobby in 1979, prevented from forcing Israel to do as he pleased.
We had a case today in ISraeli court that may suprise you(although sadly not me). An Arab woman assisted her son in murdering two of her own daughters and trying to murder a third. The crime? One daughter had gotten pregnant by her own uncle(read raped perhaps?) and the other daughters knew of the illicit affair. Thus they all dishonored their family. So the woman was found guilty of holding the girls arms while her son made them drink acid and strangled them(apparently two of them willingly drank the acid/posion). The mothers attorney argued that "the woman should not be punished so harshly(she got dozens of years in prison or something) because as an arab woman her culture demanded she cleanse the family honor..it would be racist to punish her." The sentencing judge denied the claim of racism citing that he gave her a "harsher sentence because we must send a message to the arab community that these violations of human rights will not be tolerated.(i.e the soft bigotry of low expectations is not acceptable)." But one wonders on both accounts what has taken place here. On the one hand you have apparently a leftist attorney who truly beleives that one must take into account 'culture' when imposing penalties for crimes. I suppose this might be true when it is a victimless crime like a Rastafarian smoking pot or a Navajo using Poete. But the state guarantees, in ISrael as the U.S, the right to life of each person. Culture ends when murder begins. NOw why doesnt the left see that? To be fair the sentencing judge was also a leftist from a different strain of leftism, that old view that people indeed must be brought kicking and screaming into the modern world. But what disturbes me is the process of logic that takes a leftist from caring about culture, which seems pretty positive on its face, to claiming that we must care so much about culture that 'sacrificing the lives of a few arabs is important for us to show respect for their culture(not a direct quote)'. What is the attorney really saying? 1) it is racist to prosecute an arab for murder because their culture forces them to murder their own children. 2) Arabs lives dont matter, because culture is more important. So what does this mean? Does it mean in the American south that in 1865 a 'culture' argument could have been used by leftists to say that "slavery is the culture of the white plantation owner, and therefore it would be unfair to deprive him of his slaves". Does it mean that when the KKK strung up uppity blacks for eating in white establishments that the argument "the black man offended the culture of the white man and his sensitivities, thus the KKK should not be prosecuted." After all perhaps a similar argument could have been used in the 1950s for wife beating. "since it is the culture of many men to beat their wives, especially after a good drink, we should not prosecute such behavior." I like this culture argument, but what I dont understand is how its possible that in an open minded society anyone can beleive such a thing for a single instant. Two people were murdered and the logic says "well it is their culture to murder." But what about the two dead girls? The state guaranteed them life, and guaranteed it would prosecute to the full extent of the law anyone who robbed them of it, the constitution doesnt say "all Jews will have rights to liberty and life, and all arabs, owing to their culture, will have seperate rights, thus the life of an arab women is worth approximatly 1% the life of the Jew." The same leftists that complain that Israel doesnt grant enough rights to arabs vis-a-vis their share in government or media, are the same ones who apparenlty also beleive that when an arab women is murdered, that she deserved it based on her 'culture'. They inadvertently accept the precepts of arab chauvinist society and extreme religion and say "yes a women who dares have an illicit relationship deserves death and so do any women who are privy to such information, in order to safe-guard the honor of the family." And if we accept such pretexts, we are no better than Saudi Arabia, and we are not giving equal rights to everyone.
Fear the day such extreme-leftist views are able to penetrate the mainstream because they will reverse 200 years of fighting for human rights, because they beleive all rights are relative, and that given that therefore a person in fact enjoys no rights.
The brilliant article that is evidence of it appears here:E. J'lem woman gets 15 years jail for role in daughters' murders By Nir Hasson, Haaretz Correspondent Jerusalem District Court on Tuesday sentenced an East Jerusalem woman to 15 years in prison for assisting in the "honor killing" of two of her daughters, and in the attempted murder of a third. Sara Shakirat's son, 29-year-old Maher Shakirat, committed the two killings and was also carried out the attempted murder. As part of a plea bargain, Shakirat admitted her role in the crimes, in return for escaping an 18-year prison sentence.
Amani Shakirat, 20, and her pregnant 28-year-old sister Rudeina were found dead at their home in the village of Jabel Mukaber in May 2005. Police couldn't say whether the women had swallowed acid, or had been strangled. Their sister Leila, 24, was found in serious condition. Relatives said that she had swallowed acid in a suicide attempt. The incident began when the parents suspected that Rudeina had damaged the family's honor by being unfaithful with her husband's uncle. Rudeina, who was in the ninth month of her pregnancy when she was killed, did not know who the father was. Maher Shakirat asked his parents' permission to kill all three sisters, on the grounds that the pther two were party to Rudeina's secret affair. On May 2, the father sent most of the family members out of the house, and Maher asked Rudeina and Amani to drink the acid that he had bought, so that he would not have to kill them himself. The two women drank the acid, but did not die, after which Maher strangled them both with a cord. At this time, Sara Shakirat was in the house, and backed up her son. She even called the third daughter, Leila, and invited her to the house so that Maher could kill her too. When Leila arrived, Maher tried to strangle her and threw acid over her, but she survived and even acted as a witness for her mother during sentencing. Sara Shakirat's attorney, Leah Tzemel, asked the court to reduce her sentence as she had acted in accordance with Arab tradition, which states that she is responsible for her daughters' moral behavior. But judges Moshe Ravid, Orit Efal-Gabay and Aharon Farkash, rejected this request, saying rather that punishment in such cases should be more severe, "in order to thwart and eradicate such shocking acts that harm defenseless women on the grounds of desecration of family honor."
Seth Frantzman


1 Comments:
interesting, you never realize how bad and idiotic some presidents cna really be.
www.lost.eu/51ec
5:06 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home