Why 'Collapse' is wrong about the world
In the book Collapse Jared Diamond argues that mis-use of the environmnt leads to the end of communities or 'collapse'. He cites Easter Island, Pitcairn Island, the Vikings, the Anastazi, the Maya, Haiti and Rwanda. In the case of Rwanda he appears to argue the comeptition over resources and overcrowding led to genocide. He also mentions Montana and the clear cutting and mining as examples of the same phenomenon. However he is wrong. In his earlier work Guns Germs and Steal he argued that environmental factors and key inventions lead to success. It ios true that mismanaging the environment can lead to less resources and thus a land cannot support the population. Evidence of this can be seen in the Middle East where rampant cutting of forests led much of the region to become desert, especially in Lebanon, the Negev and Iraq one can see the disastrous consequences of more then 1000 years of environmental destruction that began when Bedouin bands came from Arabia and drove the farmers from their lands in the 7th century. The Ottomans later cut down many forests for their ship building programs. Like Scotland the land became treeless and subject to erosion. Did this lead to collapse, not exactly, it led to decline and urbanization.
The minority of countries in the world have been led to total destruction on the level of Easter Island. However Montana is not going the way of Maya. Guns Germs and Steal didnt take into account other cultural or religious reasons for success, and Collapse is mostly a contrived study that tries to link every conflict to the environment, like Marxism linking every conflict to economics, this theory is to simple.
Seth J. Frantzman


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home