Douthat, Harvard, Summers and Relativism
What happaned at Harvard? We all know a few of the stories soruounding Mr. Summers, the former Secretary of the Treasury. Summers dared to say that women dont do well in Science. He also dared to order harvard students to go abroad and he beat down the harvard faculty for trying to divest from Israel, calling them anti-semites, in response they passed a no-confidence vote. Short of rounding up all academics and imprisoning them, Mr. Summers is on the right track. However recently he has been the scoruge of a few books and some blogs and articles. A review:
Aesthetic Relativism at Harvard
Posted on March 10, 2005 by Jeff Baldwin http://www.thegreatbooks.com In category:
Recommended Reads
Education
Ready for some less-than-shocking news? Harvard University does not provide a particularly rigorous education.
What you’ve suspected for a long time has been confirmed, and not by someone preaching sour grapes because they couldn’t get into an ivy league school. The Atlantic Monthly recently featured an article entitled “The Truth About Harvard” written by alumnus Ross Douthat. Douthat cheerfully describes “the overall ease and lack of seriousness in Harvard’s undergraduate academic culture.”
He begins by relating an older story about grade inflation (90% of the class of 2001 had a grade-point average of B- or higher). One of Harvard’s more conservative professors—I have no idea what Harvard considers “conservative”—caused quite a stir in 2001 when he announced that each student who enrolled in his course would receive two grades: one measuring the actual quality of his work, and then an “ironic” grade that was turned in to the administration. Only the student would know whether or not he deserved the grade that showed up on his report card!
After making his point, this professor backed down on his policy—but the horse was out of the barn. Though it presumably takes academic excellence to get accepted by Harvard, academic excellence is not necessarily expected once you’re in.
How has such an august institution fallen so far? The answer, Douthat hints, has to do with relativism.
To use the phrase “great books” is to suggest that there is a standard by which all books may be measured. Christians do not feel particularly nervous when they hear this—they are accustomed to measuring moral actions against the unchanging standard of the character of God. Christians believe in absolutes, recognizing that moral relativism will always be untenable because God reveals part of His moral law to all men through their consciences (Romans 2:14-15). Everyone knows that murder is wrong, and will be wrong 500 years from now. No amount of relativist rhetoric can change that.
But campuses that have embraced moral relativism have necessarily embraced aesthetic relativism as well. If God is not the Source and Standard of truth or goodness, then neither is He the Source and Standard of beauty. When judging the beauty or the skillfulness of a particular work, we are left only with changeable humans holding up different yardsticks. “Beauty,” as the cliché goes, “is in the eye of the beholder.”
The Christian should respond by pointing out that “beholder” ought to be capitalized. There is only one Beholder Who matters: God. Throw out God, and you can no longer know whether or not a roadkill possum is more beautiful than Mount Harvard (the highest mountain in Colorado, as if you didn’t know).
This is precisely Harvard University’s problem today. “As in a great library ravaged by a hurricane,” writes Douthat, “the essential elements of a liberal arts education lie scattered everywhere at Harvard, waiting to be picked up. But little guidance is given on how to proceed with that task.” To suggest what books are worthy of your contemplation implies certain knowledge about the standard for excellence in literature—something the Harvard professor abandoned a long time ago.
Thus, Douthat says, Harvard rejected the idea of a “Great Books” program and instead in 1978 created the Core Curriculum, which was designed to help undergraduates receive a liberal arts education. Unfortunately, the Core is largely viewed as a failure; it was described in the student newspaper as a “stifling and stagnant attempt” at education.
The reason for this failure, and the failure of Harvard’s undergraduate programs in general, is the simple fact that Harvard forgot that an excellent education is a discriminating education. A history class could, in theory, spend a semester examining the history of the Pet Rock—but if there is a fixed standard (if you can discriminate), then you know that there are more important events in history. Likewise, a literature professor might choose to teach an entire course about Archie and Jughead, but the discriminating professor should admit that some books are better written and more profound.
Absent a belief in a fixed standard grounded in the character of God, Harvard provides Core classes that would be better described as “fringe.” To wit: “Tel Aviv: Urban Culture in Another Zion,” or “Women Writers in Imperial China: How to Escape from the Feminine Voice,” or “The Cuban Revolution: 1956-71: A Self Debate.”
Some of those titles may sound interesting to you. But none of them deal with the Great Conversation—the most eloquent, most profound dialogue pitting great mind against great mind. The Great Conversation is the soul of a liberal arts education.
Those last two sentences would make the Harvard professor bristle. How do you know what is most profound? How can you measure eloquence or excellence?
In a relativist world, those questions are unanswerable. But if Christianity is true, then the Christian knows—like a brother—the Fount of all wisdom and all knowledge, Jesus Christ (Colossians 2:2-3). Christians may always pursue excellence in academics. The world is quickly talking itself out of the possibility of excellence.
From Jerusalem Post:
Summers's hailstormBy DAN MARKEL
Harvard Rules: The Struggle for the Soul of the World's Most Powerful UniversityBy Richard BradleyHarperCollins$25.95
Privilege: Harvard and the Education of the Ruling ClassBy Ross Gregory DouthatHyperion$24.95
A few weeks ago, I returned to Harvard for my 10th college reunion with a few things on my mind, mostly having to do with what Larry Summers, Harvard's current president, had been up to lately. To take just one example: when I recently started a book club in DC that focuses on nonfiction with a Jewish flavor, I discovered that book-clubbing was an oddly gendered activity. Indeed, at the first meeting of the club, it was all women, save me. Notwithstanding large community announcements, it was the same thing at the second meeting.
Can one fairly say that women simply like to talk about books more than men? Or that women prefer to adopt more pre-commitment strategies to finish books? Or that women are more social than men? These were some of the topics of discussion at the first meeting, and all the women there indicated their agreement and puzzlement that book clubs skew towards those gifted with double X chromosomes.
I wondered about my book club experience: sure, it was not solid empirical evidence. But does that mean the (widely observed) phenomenon is not worth discussing? It was in this context that the recent Larry Summers debacle at Harvard caught my eye. On the Harvard campus, at least in some quarters, it appears that such discussion is verboten. Indeed, in the aftermath of Summers's terrible spring, a time in which Harvard's arts and sciences faculty voted no confidence in Summers's presidency, a more pressing question has arisen: has Harvard become hostile to genuine curiosity and excellence? Or does the fact of Summers's continued presidency, notwithstanding the ego blow he suffered, augur an institutional commitment to such values?
To avoid a hasty answer, I turned to two recent books about Harvard to gain some perspective on the Summers controversy. Ross Douthat's Privilege: Harvard and the Education of the Ruling Class and Richard Bradley's Harvard Rules both chronicle the "Age of Summers," the former from a student's perspective, the latter from a journalist's perspective.
I confess I have some vested interest in the matter - I am a devoted alumnus and former employee. So, with the nostalgic prism of hindsight, I took an active interest in Summers's presidency, which began just after I left.
Although useful for general background, Bradley's Harvard Rules proves a disappointment to anyone with a passing familiarity with Harvard. Although Bradley conducted some interviews with various "victims" of Summers's reign, the book is mostly a repetitive pastiche of reportage from other sources - Summers himself granted no interviews to Bradley, even though he is typically mindful of shaping press coverage.
The book is also gossipy beyond even this reviewer's prurient tolerance. How many instances of Larry Summers's boorish pizza-stuffing habits do we need to hear about? Or that he mispronounced some faculty's names and seemed fidgety or tired on occasion? Bradley and the detractors he cites fail to appreciate the demands of being a president of a major university, let alone Harvard. In light of that burden and spotlight, it's hardly surprising that Rudenstine, Summers's predecessor, felt compelled to take a three-month reprieve from the job to recover from the stress and anxiety.
Bradley's book has other flaws too: for instance, it inanely sees perfidy when there is none. Discussing the prelude to Summers's stint in DC as Treasury secretary, Bradley conjures images of a secret deal struck in 1996 between Summers and Bob Rubin, his predecessor. Under the terms of this nefarious "secret arrangement," Rubin would urge then-president Clinton to name Summers as his successor if Summers agreed to stay on as deputy for two more years.Clinton agreed to this scenario, which Bradley describes as "unknown to anyone except the three men and a handful of their closest staff members." Bradley concludes the matter thus: "When Summers and Rubin dealt with foreign governments, they pushed for transparency. But when it came to their own fortunes, different standards applied." Good gracious. Will the Republic survive?
This is not to say that Summers has always been a mensch while at Harvard or beforehand. Bradley's evidence bears out that Summers can be sharp-tongued, awkward and gruff. What's more, Bradley describes a more serious problem than simply the appearance of loutishness: namely, a predisposition to skew the processes of inquiries so that their results tend to confirm views held at the outset.
As it happens, Summers tends to have robust and intriguing ideas about how to change Harvard for the better. But if Bradley's account is correct - and it is hard to vouchsafe - the point stands that Summers has not done a measurably strong job in ensuring that a variety of viewpoints are ventilated and listened to carefully. And, as Summers has found out, that can be devastating to the ongoing stability of an office like Harvard's presidency.
BRADLEY'S SNARKY book is neither balanced nor all that incisive. Given the young age of its author, Douthat's book, Privilege: Harvard and the Education of the Ruling Class, is surprisingly far more rewarding - especially as a contemporary rumination on what William James called, a century ago, the "Bitch-Goddess" of Success. Douthat suffered quite a beating a few months ago at the hands of various bloggers, after an excerpt of his book in the Atlantic Monthly amateurishly characterized the workings of various academic philosophy departments. But while warranted, the whupping was unfortunate, as it distracted attention from the two larger and more urgent points Douthat was making and that come across more clearly in the book.
First, Douthat explained how Harvard was failing to demand enough from its undergraduates, especially in the humanities and social sciences. Although Harvard has for the last 50 years or so admitted many intellectual powerhouses, Douthat rightly laments that the dominant culture at Harvard encourages students to choose extracurricular over curricular activities. Whoever has the Palm Pilot with the most appointments wins the game. Summers is valiantly trying to shift this emphasis, in part by trying to curb grade inflation and by raising expectations and standards for both students and professors.
Whereas Bradley views this agenda with suspicion, Douthat sees the moral costs of the unearned A- that is dispensed by teachers on a relatively slapdash paper. The breach of honesty that grade inflation represents was made apparent when Harvey Mansfield, one of Douthat's political philosophy professors (and mine), announced that instead of penalizing students who took his class by giving them the grades they deserved, he would give them two grades: the first would be an "ironic" grade, which would be sent to the registrar, the second would be given to the student alone, and would reflect what the student really "deserved" in the eyes of the teacher.
The second thesis that Douthat weaves into his deftly crafted coming-of-age narrative is a measured critique of the prevailing Harvard fascination with diversity. Douthat argues that while there is tremendous diversity of complexion, there is not much diversity of class (or ideology) at Harvard. What's more, Douthat illustrates how even if one comes from truly unusual circumstances, the Harvard experience tends to produce homogenized results, with so many of Harvard's graduates ending up spending at least some time at the same professional schools, law firms, big cities, and reading the same blogs, magazines, books and newspapers.The operating assumptions of these two authors, or at least of their publishers, is that you don't have to have gone to Harvard to care about what's happening there in recent years. That's because, like it or not, Harvard's influence on American education, and the reproduction of its social elites, remains substantial, if also overestimated. If, and only if, you have some need to monitor the activities of the institution, then skip Bradley's book and enjoy Douthat's meditations.
The writer, a graduate of Harvard University, is an attorney in Washington, D.C. His writing can be found at www.danmarkel.com.
The ahrvard crimson:
Published on Wednesday, February 16, 2005Doubting DouthatA hollow critique of our hallowed hallsBy THE CRIMSON STAFF
Back in the fall of 2001, Tufts Dean Charles Inouye told the Tufts Daily News that grade inflation at Harvard was “just another symptom of their culture of arrogance—image over substance.” And he went further. “Everybody in the business knows just how little Harvard students work,” he asserted. “They’re essentially a lazy bunch. A lot of them aren’t even that smart.”
At the time, Inouye’s remarks aroused the ire of a vast contingent of Harvardians, and students took up their own defense through a barrage of letters to the Daily and the Dean’s Office. One outraged Crimson columnist even employed the power of the press. In “The Harvard Syndrome,” published November 5, 2001, he argued that “the acknowledged fact that some Harvard students are lazy” and “the presence on campus of a few meatheads, legacies, and dim bulbs with bizarre talents” are used by the ignorant to draw unfair—and even blatantly false—generalizations about the University and its students.
Clearly, Ross G. Douthat ’02 (the aforementioned Crimson pundit) has changed his mind.
In a recent piece in The Atlantic Monthly, “The Truth About Harvard,” Douthat reveals that in retrospect, he feels “cheated” by his undergraduate experience at Harvard, and proceeds to bash practically every aspect of academic life—the classes offered, what is expected of the students, the way grades are given—on his way to concluding that Harvard is, as its critics have long suspected, easy. Harvard students are “creatively lazy,” committing their considerable intellect to achieving the highest grades with the least amount of effort.
This verdict is based on an entertaining mixture of personal anecdotes and general observations, and while many of the latter can claim validity, the former have no real place in an informed discussion.
Douthat falls victim to his own college-era critique, generalizing the experience of a Harvard student from his own career, which was largely dependent on his personal choices. Perhaps the most vivid recollection in the article is the discussion of a “pathetically easy” paper, for which he apparently “didn’t need to do any reading, absorb any history, or learn anything at all.” One can only wonder why an individual with such a high commitment to academic rigor would have enrolled in such a course in the first place.
In proving—via his own example—that “gut” classes and delinquent students exist at even this great university, Douthat does no more than acknowledge that Harvard students are more normal than the traditional “egghead” stereotype might allow. And despite the fact that an exposé of this sort seems to pop up every few months, the article’s success proves that this sort of revelation is clearly still considered newsworthy.
Where Douthat’s critique proves more valuable is in his discussion of the problems with Harvard’s current academic structure: there are major flaws in the current Core Curriculum, the academic advising system, and even the apathy of some professors and teaching fellows. But these descriptions succumb to an inherent bias. Douthat blasts the humanities for inflating grades—he argues that it’s a reaction to their “retreat into irrelevance”—and neglecting to prepare those students who are not headed for professorships of their own. Perhaps the history and literature department failed to prepare him adequately for his editorial position at the Atlantic, but his emphasis on liberal arts and the importance of giving students a strong background in history, a “Great Books” experience, and so on, clashes with his implication that the sciences are the only real fields of study remaining.
In addition, Douthat is unabashedly Eurocentric. It is a tragedy, he claims, that an undergraduate might leave Harvard’s walls “unable to distinguish Justinian the Great from Julian the Apostate.” Instead, they’re more likely to be familiar with propaganda in Nazi Germany, the role of the samurai in Japanese culture, or the Castro regime in Cuba. Of all the things to criticize, why complain that Harvard is too successful in attempting to expand the cultural and intellectual horizons of its students?
Perhaps there has been a move in the American university system away from fact-based learning—and perhaps Douthat is right that this trend is not a positive one. He may even make an argument for increased control over grades or more direction for confused undergraduates faced with a massive course catalog and no idea where to start. But these flaws are pervasive, not unique to Harvard, and tossing in the Harvard name to attract attention is cheap journalism.
Douthat never points to a better model. He never suggests that Harvard is being held to an existing standard and has been found wanting. Instead, he chooses to follow in the steps of so many before him and demand that Harvard, and its slothful students, isnot living up to some ever-elusive ideal. Based on his past performance, we rather expected better.
Atlantic Monthly:
The Atlantic Monthly March 2005
The Truth About HarvardIt may be hard to get into Harvard, but it's easy to get out without learning much of enduring value at all. A recent graduate's report
by Ross Douthat
.....
t the beginning of every term Harvard students enjoy a one-week "shopping period," during which they can sample as many courses as they like and thus—or so the theory goes—concoct the most appropriate schedule for their semesters. There is a boisterous quality to this stretch, a sense of intellectual possibility, as people pop in and out of lecture halls, grabbing syllabi and listening for twenty minutes or so before darting away to other classes.
The enthusiasm evaporates quickly once the shopping period ends. Empty seats in the various halls and auditoriums multiply as the semester rattles along, until rooms that were full for the opening lecture resemble the stadium of a losing baseball team during a meaningless late-August game. There are pockets of diehards in the front rows, avidly taking notes, and scattered observers elsewhere—students who overcame the urge to hit the snooze button and hauled themselves to class, only to realize that they've missed so many lectures and fallen so far behind that taking notes is a futile exercise. Better to wait for the semester's end, when they can take exhaustive notes at the review sessions that are always helpfully provided—or simply go to the course's Web site, where the professor has uploaded his lecture notes, understanding all too well the character and study habits of his seldom-glimpsed students.
Published on Thursday, February 17, 2005Core Courses Proven Idiotic, Irrelevant for 9,572nd TimeBy SARA E. POLSKYCrimson Staff Writer
You can whisper about your prof behind his back, bash her anonymously on a blog, but you have to admit it takes balls to attach your name to an article slamming him in a national publication. Ross Douthat ’02 calls out specific Harvard professors in “The Truth About Harvard,” an article in the March Atlantic Monthly that zeroes in on Harvard’s Core courses as inconsequential, calling them “maddeningly specific and often defiantly obscure.”
Despite the mud being thrown on their names, the profs of these Core courses have not risen up in arms. Most declined to comment, while others vaguely remembered having heard about the article but not having read it.
When provided with copies of the piece, though, professors of courses like Foreign Cultures 78: “Understanding Islam and Contemporary Muslim Societies” made plenty of pointed observations about the author.
Douthat may state that “Understanding Islam” is “parochial” for examining “Muslim-animistic syncretism in Africa” but not the Koran or “the rise of radical Islam.” But Professor of the Practice of Indo-Muslim Languages and Cultures Ali S. Asani finds Douthat’s mind just a tad narrow.
“The author, I think, has a particularly stereotypical view of Islam, that studying Islam is just about reading texts,” Asani says.
And the history department may be on a “retreat into irrelevance,” but at least it knows how to fact-check. Folger Fund Professor of History Andrew Gordon, chair of the History Department, notes that Douthat forgot one important detail when complaining that there were no history classes on the American Revolution during his undergraduate years: there was one.
But other professors that teach the classes Douthat cites concede that he’s at least right about the lack of breadth in Core classes.
“If the author is referring to some of the themes represented [in the Core] as being more specific than general,” says Professor of Psychology Richard J. McNally, whose Social Analysis Core “Psychological Trauma” is described as the “obscure” alternative to Ec 10, “then I think he may very well have a point.” Translation: touché.
Monday, March 07, 2005
Ross Douthat, the Core Curriculum, and other tidbits from The Atlantic
Well, I finally got around to reading Douthat's Atlantic piece about Harvard. And, like the character in Green Eggs and Ham -- I have a two-year-old, what do you expect? -- having finally bothered to taste it, I find I agree with much of what he wrote, especially about the Core, which truly sucked ass as a means of getting a general education. The whole thing should be replaced with a Great Books curriculum coupled with real science and math courses. But this should come as no revelation; people have been complaining about the Core forever, so when Mr. Douthat claims to be revealing "The Truth About Harvard" I do think he's a bit, um, full of himself. And I saw he has a whole book out now about it, which I think is ridiculous and obscene. I am sick and tired of Harvard graduates undermining my self-esteem by getting book contracts at younger and younger ages. There oughta be a law, I swear. But Douthat also trots out the old "the humanities are irrelevant and have an inferiority complex" canard:
Attempting to explain the left-wing biases of his Harvard colleagues, the libertarian philosopher Robert Nozick once hypothesized that most professors oppose capitalism because they consider themselves far smarter than boorish businessmen, and therefore resent the economic system that rewards practical intelligence over their own gifts. I'm inclined to think that such resentment -- at least in money-drunk America -- increasingly coexists with a deep inferiority complex regarding modern capitalism, and a need, however unconscious, to justify academic life in the face of the fantastic accumulation of wealth that takes place outside the ivory tower.It does not seem to have occurred to Douthat that professors may oppose, not capitalism per se, but the idolatry of the believers in the absolute truth of the free market. Money-drunk America may consider it heresy that a democratic society might successfully implement something other than untrammeled capitalism and yet be a wonderful place to live; but such places exist -- not without their troubles, of course, but they are different troubles than those we have here, and some of us might prefer those troubles to our own. It is a question of values. Do people whose intelligence and efforts are directed to something other than business or science secretly believe they are smarter than businessmen? Some of them do, I'm sure, just as many businessmen believe, and not especially secretly, that humanities professors are parasitic elitist snobs who waste their lives thinking about useless crap that doesn't make any sense. But perhaps, just perhaps, many academics do what they do because they believe that, especially in a society where the accumulation of wealth seems to have trumped all other concerns, it's important for some people to think about other things. Is it possible that some people might genuinely not believe that the fantastic accumulation of wealth is really that valuable in life? Douthat might reply that such statements are sour grapes: academics don't make much money, so of course they insist that money is not that important. Douthat cheerfully deploys a favorite tool of humanities professors when he psychoanalyzes them and pronounces their behavior to be the product of a "need, however unconscious, to justify academic life." (What behavior, exactly, is never quite clear. Grade inflation? Postmodernism? The teaching of courses on obscure subjects? Hatred of capitalism?) Those of us who choose paths in life that are not primarily concerned with the accumulation of wealth are not immune to envy and resentment and feelings of inferiority and all the other nasty emotions Douthat says are 'really' behind whatever behavior he's complaining about in humanities professors. That we feel such emotions, however, does not mean that our behavior is dictated by them. Humans, happily, are able to make choices that are quite at odds with their urges, emotions, desires, and instincts. All the research that's been done on the accumulation of wealth, for example, shows that above a certain level of comfort, wealth has no particular effect on human happiness. Even though at times I think, "oh, if we just had more money, I could get that plasma TV, and then I'd truly be happy," and I truly feel it, I know, intellectually, that it's not true. Even though at times I wonder if I'm "not doing anything important with my life," or "not contributing enough", or "not successful enough," those values are not the ones guiding my life. So I let these thoughts and feelings pass, as they do, and I get on with the things that I think are actually important in life. Of course colleges should provide a liberal education to future bankers, diplomats, doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc. And I agree with Douthat that they are failing to do so. But in a country as anti-intellectual as ours, where academia is constantly attacked, it may be difficult for the children of capitalist privilege, on their brief sojourn in a world where capital is not king, to even get a liberal education. Perhaps students like Douthat, groomed since childhood for success in the world, simply are unable to hear what their professors have to say. Is this the fault of their professors?
http://www.kafka.com/politics/2005/03/ross-douthat-core-curriculum-and-other.php as
Basically what we are talking about here is two things, one is moral relativism and the other is the fact that liberals are racists that in their quest for racial perfection, which is to say diversity, they really dont end up with diversity but an elite society of people who happen to look different, as if diversity was making sure one had an equal number of ugly people and good looking people are a get together, rather then just different interesting people regardless of looks.
Well he has hit the subject on the head, but what is convinces us of more then before is that we must prepare, that the time si coming, that we must begin sharpening our weapons, for he time is coming, the time of judgement, the rime when we shall finally cast off the irons, the prison of this thing called liberalism and islamism and we will finally be able to wage a true just holy war of civilization against liberalism-islamism-nazism.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home