Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Thursday, November 17, 2005

on economics and the wealth gap in the US

My reply to the Krugman article:

Lets point out the fallacies in this Krugman piece.
Fallacy #1: We really dont know if its more liekly that todays children, or my generation(born 1980) will inherit their fathers class, since my generation, and certainly my childrens have not lived their lives. My grandfather arrived in this country penniless from Russia, but the wealth he had as an old man didnt really roll in until he was in his late 30s. In 20 years or more we will be able to certify with a strong yes or no if what they are claiming is true, namely that fewer people are moving out of their birth class, however givin what Krugman says, that the giant middle class developed during the 1940s and that the Baby boom propelled it, then wouldnt that suggest the giant middle class is staying where it is, large and in the middle, if Krugmans logic is to be followed i.e Premise 1: people today are more likely to inherit dads class, and premise 2: the middle class america we know came about between 1930 and 1960, then actually we will be inheriting a caste society with a big middle class, precisely what Krugman is claiming will not happen.
Fallacy #2: Krugman argues that the poor are not pulling themselves out of poverty like they used to, but this is probably only certain sections of the poor, namely the white trash and the blacks. Hispanic, Asian, Middle Eastern, African and Indian immigrants all fitt he standard profile of my grandfathers generation, within one generation they have usually opened their own businesses and or gone to college. The Blacks and the poor whites suffer from apathy of being long term poor americans, they havent cvhanged their social status in 150 years, I dont think they will ever change it, remmember the engine for social mobility is not the government, the engine is the individual, and his drive, which is why the big immigrant floods triggered the social mobility.
Fallacy #3 Krugman rattles off a number of the government policies of the 1960s and claims they worked to "to keep income gaps relatively small." Let us examine how honest this is. Take a look at the big landed gentry of America, such as the Kennedy's their inherited income and trsut accounts havents gotten too small and they werent smaller in the 1960s. The rich have always been rich and the poor have always been poor. Krugman says "The economy was hardly egalitarian, but a generation ago the gross inequalities of the 1920s seemed very distant." but if the 1920s were sooo bad then why is it the 1920s was when my Grandfather and other immigrants began to make money??? Explain the lie.
Fallacy #4 Statistics:Krugman writes: "between 1973 and 2000 the average real income of the bottom 90 percent of American taxpayers actually fell by 7 percent. Meanwhile, the income of the top 1 percent rose by 148 percent, the income of the top 0.1 percent rose by 343 percent and the income of the top 0.01 percent rose 599 percent."
This is the classic statistic fallacy, it looks all cut and dry, but when one peaks behind the curtain the truth is revealed. First of all we are missing the statistic for the 9 percent, that 9 percent that is apparently between the "bottom 90 percent" and the "top 1 percent" and that 9 percent is crucial, for it is within that 9 percent that we find the upper middle class, that one part of society that is single handedly responsible for Americas position in the world economy.
Secondly we are also missing the key statistic of inflaction, and CPI. Also Krugman is comparing 'real income' which he doesnt define, to 'income' when he is dealing with his top 1 percent and bottom 90 percent. Apparently the bottom 90 percent make 'real' income but the top 1 percent make 'fake' income? The key word 'real' is left out of the second figure because, had it been dropped from the first figure, we would have seen a high rise in the incomes of the bottom 90 percent. Everyone knows the poor dont make a lot of money, but everyone also knows that the poor make more today than they did in 1973. What Krugman is fudging here is the concept of the living wage, or the idea of income compared to inflation, if we compare say the 10,000 a year the poor made in 1973 and the 20,000 he makes today, and then we compare it to inflation it may be true is making less 'real' income, or that his purchasing power is less, most of us can confirm this because in the 1970s and more so in the 1950s one man could support his whole family, now it takes a man and his wife. This is true because women were added to the workplace and in order to make up for the surplus labor pay was cut. supply and demand, in fact a downside of the liberal program to get women in to the workplace and make them equal, equality has its downsides. But elasticity tells us that will change.
Krugman and his argument may have its merits but it also has classic fallacies within it, that only the trained eye can spot. We will know in 20 years if the middle class is truly shrinking. The liberal always points to europe as the 'perfect world' that we should model ourselves after, the liberal claims denmark is better than america, but lets look at europe today, first look at how they manage their poor, keeping them in ghettos of immigrants, and let us take a curvey of any society in europe and you will find the same family names today make up the rich as did 100 years ago, there is virtually no social mobility in europe and socialism is used as a stop gap measure by the rich landed families to keep themselves privlidged by keeping the poor on the dole and happy. However in America if you take the 500 richest americans you find 19% dont even have college educations and only 12% are inherited wealth, thats better than any country in the world in terms of social mobility.




The Death of Horatio Alger>Paul Krugman>>The other day I found myself reading a leftist rag that made outrageous claims about America. It said that we are becoming a society in which the poor tend to stay poor, no matter how hard they work; in which sons are much more likely to inherit the socioeconomic status of their father than they were a generation ago.>>The name of the leftist rag? Business Week, which published an article titled "Waking Up From the American Dream." The article summarizes recent research showing that social mobility in the United States (which was never as high as legend had it) has declined considerably over the past few decades. If you put that research together with other research that shows a drastic increase in income and wealth inequality, you reach an uncomfortable conclusion: America looks more and more like a class-ridden society.>>And guess what? Our political leaders are doing everything they can to fortify class inequality, while denouncing anyone who complains--or even points out what is happening--as a practitioner of "class warfare.">>Let's talk first about the facts on income distribution. Thirty years ago we were a relatively middle-class nation. It had not always been thus: Gilded Age America was a highly unequal society, and it stayed that way through the 1920s. During the 1930s and '40s, however, America experienced what the economic historians Claudia Goldin and Robert Margo have dubbed the Great Compression: a drastic narrowing of income gaps, probably as a result of New Deal policies. And the new economic order persisted for more than a generation: Strong unions; taxes on inherited wealth, corporate profits and high incomes; close public scrutiny of corporate management--all helped to keep income gaps relatively small. The economy was hardly egalitarian, but a generation ago the gross inequalities of the 1920s seemed very distant.>Now they're back. According to estimates by the economists Thomas Piketty and Emmanuel Saez--confirmed by data from the Congressional Budget Office--between 1973 and 2000 the average real income of the bottom 90 percent of American taxpayers actually fell by 7 percent. Meanwhile, the income of the top 1 percent rose by 148 percent, the income of the top 0.1 percent rose by 343 percent and the income of the top 0.01 percent rose 599 percent. (Those numbers exclude capital gains, so they're not an artifact of the stock-market bubble.) The distribution of income in the United States has gone right back to Gilded Age levels of inequality.>>Never mind, say the apologists, who churn out papers with titles like that of a 2001 Heritage Foundation piece, "Income Mobility and the Fallacy of Class-Warfare Arguments." America, they say, isn't a caste society--people with high incomes this year may have low incomes next year and vice versa, and the route to wealth is open to all. That's where those commies at Business Week come in: As they point out (and as economists and sociologists have been pointing out for some time), America actually is more of a caste society than we like to think. And the caste lines have lately become a lot more rigid.>>The myth of income mobility has always exceeded the reality: As a general rule, once they've reached their 30s, people don't move up and down the income ladder very much. Conservatives often cite studies like a 1992 report by Glenn Hubbard, a Treasury official under the elder Bush who later became chief economic adviser to the younger Bush, that purport to show large numbers of Americans moving from low-wage to high-wage jobs during their working lives. But what these studies measure, as the economist Kevin Murphy put it, is mainly "the guy who works in the college bookstore and has a real job by his early 30s." Serious studies that exclude this sort of pseudo-mobility show that inequality in average incomes over long periods isn't much smaller than inequality in annual incomes.>>It is true, however, that America was once a place of substantial intergenerational mobility: Sons often did much better than their fathers. A classic 1978 survey found that among adult men whose fathers were in the bottom 25 percent of the population as ranked by social and economic status, 23 percent had made it into the top 25 percent. In other words, during the first thirty years or so after World War II, the American dream of upward mobility was a real experience for many people.>>Now for the shocker: The Business Week piece cites a new survey of today's adult men, which finds that this number has dropped to only 10 percent. That is, over the past generation upward mobility has fallen drastically. Very few children of the lower class are making their way to even moderate affluence. This goes along with other studies indicating that rags-to-riches stories have become vanishingly rare, and that the correlation between fathers' and sons' incomes has risen in recent decades. In modern America, it seems, you're quite likely to stay in the social and economic class into which you were born.>>Business Week attributes this to the "Wal-Martization" of the economy, the proliferation of dead-end, low-wage jobs and the disappearance of jobs that provide entry to the middle class. That's surely part of the explanation. But public policy plays a role--and will, if present trends continue, play an even bigger role in the future.>>Put it this way: Suppose that you actually liked a caste society, and you were seeking ways to use your control of the government to further entrench the advantages of the haves against the have-nots. What would you do?>>One thing you would definitely do is get rid of the estate tax, so that large fortunes can be passed on to the next generation. More broadly, you would seek to reduce tax rates both on corporate profits and on unearned income such as dividends and capital gains, so that those with large accumulated or inherited wealth could more easily accumulate even more. You'd also try to create tax shelters mainly useful for the rich. And more broadly still, you'd try to reduce tax rates on people with high incomes, shifting the burden to the payroll tax and other revenue sources that bear most heavily on people with lower incomes.>>Meanwhile, on the spending side, you'd cut back on healthcare for the poor, on the quality of public education and on state aid for higher education. This would make it more difficult for people with low incomes to climb out of their difficulties and acquire the education essential to upward mobility in the modern economy.>And just to close off as many routes to upward mobility as possible, you'd do everything possible to break the power of unions, and you'd privatize government functions so that well-paid civil servants could be replaced with poorly paid private employees.>It all sounds sort of familiar, doesn't it?>>Where is this taking us? Thomas Piketty, whose work with Saez has transformed our understanding of income distribution, warns that current policies will eventually create "a class of rentiers in the U.S., whereby a small group of wealthy but untalented children controls vast segments of the US economy and penniless, talented children simply can't compete." If he's right--and I fear that he is--we will end up suffering not only from injustice, but from a vast waste of human potential.>>Goodbye, Horatio Alger. And goodbye, American Dream.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home