Have Germans Changed?
They say we must not judge. But let us try to judge an experience:
Imagine a classroom full of students at an international school. The Professor is talking about the Israeli education system and he explains that there are four aspects to this. The first part is for Secualr students, the second for the national religious(including seperate education for the sexes), the third is for the Orthodox religious and the forth for minorities. The Orthodox are educated with the sexes seperated. They learn primarily religious material. It is not a 'modern' curriculum full of tolerance and social science and math and science. The education prepares the girls for marriage and the boys for yeshiva. The German begins to question this "How is it possible?" "How can they function in the modern world this way?" "They dont know anything!". "They are illiterate...cant function in the modern world". Then another european says "Why dont NGO'S help them to get out and see the modern world". Now we must stop for a second and explain the Orthodox life. Indeed the Orthodox Haredi wear black clothes and dress like the 17th century. THey have beards and they seperate men and women in most activities. They do marry early and have lots of children and the men do not go to the army and are rarely employed. However it is not like the Amish, it does not reject modernity. They ride airplanes, buses, they are involved in business, they butcher meat, they sell things, they have sex(but they seperate for a week a month), they also drive cars. They drink alcohol and dance. They use computers and email. Cloistered in their areas they look different, as any community looks different, as diffferent as we would look if we constituted 10% of their country. Two issues are raised by this questioning. The first is that it has anti-semitic overtones. Why? Because the same european would never ask in such as harsh, condescending, direct, flabergasted, suprised, condemning manner about Muslims or Sikhs, or anyone else. Imagine the German in Cairo learning about Islam and she learns that in the Islamic school men and women are seperated and in orthodox islam the women covers her face with a full viel and Abbaya, and the man wears a long dress and turban or Khaffiya or skullcap. Would the same european condmn this with her voice and ask such direct insulting questions? No. Instead the european would in fact be offended and defend such people and say "we must be tolerant and not judge and be understanding, it is there culture." The european does it against Jews because the european feels familiar with jews.
Secondly, we must see into this line of questioning where it leads. The undertones of these statements are this "These are not people, they are animals, illiterate beasts, how can they exist, should they exist...". This is the direct line of reasoning from Mien Kampf and the line of reasoning that the Germans directed at the OstJuden, the Jews who immgrated en masse in the 1920s from Russia and Ukraine to avoid pogroms. They came with poverty and black hats and very different ways and a cloistered lifestyle. They preferred their children only speak yiddish. And the Germans hated them for it, questioned there right to exist. Indeed some Germans have not changed. They haven't changed. However it doesnt matter so much. Soon Germany will be a majority Muslim. They have their petty hatreds for Orthodox Jews, but in the end they will all submit to Islamic rule. They will indeed be raising their children in much the same way the Haredi do and then one wonders if they will ask the same questions. On Pesach we ask four questions. The German asked four questions.
In 1942 they asked four questions at Wannassee. Nothing has changed.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home