Thoughts on lies about the caucuses
You dont seem to understand the meaning of the word 'morally'. In fact it has been argued that the murder of one palestinian by the IDF is 'morally' equivilent to the Holocaust. When intellectuals discuss morals they do not discuss numbers. It is interesting that you have used the word in the same context in order to justify that the Holocaust is 'not as bad' as other things. TO be sure the genocide in cambodia killed a higher percentage of the nation than the Holocaust, as did the slaughter of the Tutsis. Recall that I think 800,000 Tutsis were killed, leaving some 100,000 or something. Much higher percentage. If you knew anything about the history of the expulsions of the Circassians from the Caucuses you would realize you have made two major mistakes in your numbers game. First, you claim that 10.5 million were expelled and murdered. That is a larger number of people than the TOTAL number who live in the caucuses today. How is it possible that in 1860, the period you actually speak of, that there were MORE people living there than today? ANd of course the people that live there today also lived there then, the Georgians and Armenians have lived in the Caucuses since long before the Turks. The Turks began immigrating from central asia only in the 8th century. You will know they followed a route already carved out by the Avars, Bulgars and Huns. The Turks are the latest manifestation of central asian migrants to Europe. They did indeed settle in the caucuses, but when you speak of 5 million 'turks and ottomans' you dont seem to know of what you speak. What is an 'ottoman'. Ottoman is not a name of a nation, or a race, or a people, it is like the word 'american' it is an identity based solely on citizenship of the Ottoman empire. The Russians never evicted 'ottomans' rather they evicted those loyal to the Turks and those loyal to the ottomans, usually muslim mountain tribes who resisted the Russian advance.
You obviously do not know of what a Circassian is. The largest expulsions of any people from the Crimea or caucuses were the circassians. more than 200,000 Circassians were forced to relocate to Turkey. Circassians are not Turks though, they resemble Cossacks. They were forced BY THE TURKS AND OTTOMANS to sell themselves into slavery in order to get passage on Turkish ships in order to leave the caucuses, for every 30 transported one was sold into slavery. Circassian slaves drifted south and circassians settled in Jordan, Palestine and even the Arabian peninsula as well as Turkey.
You have read an interesting piece of propoganda, but you have not read anything else, and you dont even seem to try to reconcile your facts with logic. 10.5 million could not have been killed and deported. It is not a 'holocaust' because we are not talking about systematic killing. The russianization of the Caucuses took place over almost 100 years. Sorry, but you just are not an expert on the region. You dont know the tiniest thing apparently about the multitude of ethnic groups that make up the caucuses, whether they are Chechen, Abkhaz, Georgian, Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Ingush, Armenian, Azeri etc...


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home