Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Wednesday, December 14, 2005

How 'world' statistics use faulty arithmatic

Take two recent publisized 'facts':
1) According to the Committee to Protect Journalists China, Cuba, Eritrea, Ethiopia are the top jailers of Journalists, editors and photographers. However America is said to be 6th.

How the Lie works: This fact tries to show that America is one of the worst suppressor of journalist freedoms. Apparently the U.S has jailed five journalists in Iraq or Guantanamo bay. What is really being toyed with here are certain definitions. First of all, some of those imprisoned by the USA may in fact not be journalists, but people posing as journalists. Even if they are all bonofide journalists it is not accurate to imply that the U.S is suppressing freedom of expression or the press. Of 180 countries in the world, how many even allow a free press? Perhaps 40 or so. Many nations have nominal free presses, such as Egypt, with some opposition allowed in state sanctions opposition newspapers, however in these nations the journalists know what they cant write in their home countries. Some countries simply have no dissenting voices because they are are visciously nationalistic, for instance azerbaijan. However we know in Turkey people are arrested just for daring to say that there might have been an Armenian genocide. That certainly doesnt imply much freedom. Why is North Korea not appearing on the top five? Is it because North Korea is so free? Why isn't Saudi Arabia there? Or Jordan? Or Syria? Or Chad, or Sudan? It is not because they are free, it is because they dont even have a press and if they do it consists of three cousins of the leader of the country who toe the party line. The U.S.S.R didnt have to imprison journalists either, they were employed by the state. America is free and america happens to have jailed five journalists, like America jailed Judith Miller, precisely because America is free, with so many journalists sometimes they run amok and break American law. Many nations dont have even the vissitudes of that form of law, since they dont have journalists, or at least none who dare speak up.

2) The UN claims that according to its 2005 UN development program measuring national income inequality the U.S is 74th and Israel is 49th. What does this mean. What this is saying, apparently is that America and Israel are terribly unequal societies where a small number of rich people make all the money.

How the lie works: If we think a little deeper about this it is saying that there are 73 countries that are more 'equal' than America. Let us try to figure out where those countries might be. We are told that Denmark is number 1 and Namibia is the worst, out of the 124 countries that were measured. We can imagine that perhaps most European countries are 'more equal' which means they have few people making a lot of money, but lots of people middling through. Europe contains 20 or so countries that might fit this model, inclusing tiny nations like Luxembourg and Andorra and San Remo and the Vatican. Then we might have a few countries in Asia that come close to this model, for instance, Japan. And then we have the Anglo-countries, such as New Zealand, Australia and Canada that also might fit. That might be a total of 35 countries, not 73. What is being said here is that lots of South American, African and Middle Eastern nations have less of a rich-poor gap than America.

This is however a huge lie. Let us examine the poor in America. They have homes, they have cars and TVs. They make 20,000 a year or more. Yes the richest of the rich make some massive sum of money. However lets look at a place like Egypt or India or even Rumania. The poor in these places ride horses, they live in grass huts or makeshift tin shacks, they are mere peasents, and perhaps earn the equivalent of a thousand dollars a year or in India a few hundred. Meanwhile the rich people in these countries, yes they make less than the American in most cases, but they are a hundred times more wealthy in comparison to the poor. It is simply inaccurate arithmatic. Mexico is not 'more equal' than America. Check out the difference in poverty and the actual life of the poor in both countries and in one you will find true grinding poverty, in the other you will not and in one you will find the rich and the rich in the other country will live the same way. Mexico also has billionaries. Now even the fact of Namibia being the 'worst' is a lie. Surely other African countries have much poorer people than Namibia, which has very few people. What happaned in Namibia is that once again the poor are not so poor, but the rich are much richer than in neighbooring Congo, where the poor make a dollar a year but the rich simply are not the jet set of Namibia. Now let us also recon that in some nations the rich dont appear to have even an income. Surely in the Soviet Union the income of Stalin was nill. In Saudi and in Brunei the Shaykhs and Sultans make nothing, because they are the state. This doesnt mean they are 'poor' or that no wealth gap exists. It means that in communist Russia or a place like Saudi the rich simply have no income because they are the state, the states income is what the rich make, and the poor have nothing. Just because theoretically in the U.S.S.R everyone made the same wage doesnt make it true in fact. In fact the communist party supplemented the wage of the members and government people through dachas and free trips and all sorts of goodies including special stores. Everyone was 'equal' and the nation might rank NUMBER ONE but in fact it should be 124 becuase the actual difference between the communist laborer in the Gulag(who makes nothing) and the Politburo member is much greater than in America.

Next time you read statistics dare to open your mind and give it some thought as to how they are calculated, who compiles them and what they are being used for.

For instance, Teddy Kennedy has only his Senate 'income' that amounts to 150,000 a year making him 'middle class' however we all know that he is wealthy. Income doesnt masure the true gap between rich and poor despite what the UN report implies.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home