This conversation is the premise of this discussion:
Human 1: I wont go to Mae Sharim(the ultra-Orthodox neighborhood in Jerusalem)
Human 2: Why?
Human 1: They are hostile and I don’t want to have things imposed upon me. I don’t want to have to wear 'modest' clothing.
Human 2: But you will go to the Arab towns and you would go to Iran and wear the proscribed dress there?
Human 1: That is different.
Human 2: Why is it any different, its the exact same, it is a community asking people to dress a certain way, to respect certain norms, at least in Mae Sharim its not law, in Iran its law.
Human 1: Well I expect more of the Jews.
Human 2: Isn’t that anti-Semitism?
Why is it that a European or an American will gladly come to Israel but never venture forth into the Haredi neighborhoods, but they would go to the 'exotic' Bedouin and wear special clothes, they will go to Hebron and wear 'modest' dress and they will do the same in India or in Iran or all over the world. Why the special case for the Jews?
The reason is twofold. First the European is familiar with Jews, Jews and Europeans lived next to one another for 2000 years. The European feels that the Jews are 'his' that they are in a sense European and 'white'. We must of course recall that sixty years ago the same European tried to exterminate the same Jews because they were a 'different race...a cancer upon our nation...a foreign body..." However the modern liberal leftist European who has his moral relativism(let us remember the same Human 1 also claimed that there is no such thing as smart and dumb, that some literate educated people are dumb and some illiterate uneducated people are smart and that we must never judge), the same European says that the Jew must hold to a higher standard. If one translates what is really being said it is this 'Jews are like us, those people in Iran are barbarians, we expect them to be savage, however the Jews should not stoop to their level and be religious fanatics, the Jews helped invent modernity, the Jews are liberal and love equal rights, if a Jew acts like a barbarian it is worse than for the barbarian to act as such because the barbarian is born a barbarian and therefore has no choice, by doing the same the Jew uses choice and therefore Jews are worse if they practice any sort of religious exclusion'. That is the translation of this very simple statement "I expect more of the Jews".
The second part to this is the European denial of his own history and the history of the Jews. The European pretends to accept that Jews have been the drivers of modernity, in fact perfectly suited to do so because they could, in the ideal sociological manner, stand outside the state and sees its imperfections, discrimination helped them become critiquers. However behind the Jews such as Mendollsohn and Einstein and Memmi and Marx, the vast majority of Jews in Europe(until 1942 when the Europeans decided to kill them all) were deeply religious, like Mae Sharim. In fact it was the religious fanaticism and the very non-European ways of the Mae Sharim type Jews that preserved Judaism and probably will continue to do so. The Jews who became radically secularized assimilated, as was their goal in breaking down national boundaries. The Jews who were the drivers of communism, Trotsky, Zinoviev, 'Red' Rosa Luxembourg, Bela Kun, Kamanev, all were driven with a desire to free themselves from being Jews, as Lazar Kagonovich could testify, and to become fully Russian, but instead of becoming Russian they rather made all Russia communist in order to blur the lines between peoples and end racism, a noble goal that failed miserably.
The European denies history. The European denies that the Jews religiously have much more in common with the Iranians than with themselves. Perhaps the Jews have more in common with old style Christianity or with orthodox Christianity. However let us recall that the Human 1 in the dialogue is in fact a Croatian, and it was the Croatians that killed a higher percentage of Croatian Jews than any Jews in all of Europe during the Holocaust and in Croatia the entire Holocaust was carried out by local Croats. In fact the Croats exceeded the Nazis in their brutality and zealousness. It is ironic for the Croat to then come to Israel and say that she will not visit parts of Israel because of the Jews extremism, in fact her own people murdered the Jews and were themselves extremist and for her to say 'I expect more of the Jews' it is the ultimate irony, we all expected more of the Croats, but when given a few minutes without international law the Croats went on a butchery rampage, just as they did in the 1990s in the Balkan wars, however we are supposed to visit Croatia. Let us compare. In Croatia everyone looks normal and acts normal but behind the normalcy is Nazism and hatred and racism trying to get out, lurking in every home. Every man knows the location of his axe and gun so that he may 'go to work' one day on the minorities. However in Mae Sharim a woman will never be raped, a person will never be robbed, women are not sexually harassed, but the European woman will not go.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home