Just words??? Just Rhetoric?
When Iran had a symposium titled "A World without Zionism" and called for the destruction of Israel and the death of Israel, three opinions followed from the west. 1) Iran's threats are disgusting, must be taken seriously in light of her nuclear weapons program and the comments should be condemned. 2) The rhetoric was said just to provoke a response so Iran can be a victim and sever its connections with the world and develop its bomb. 3) Iran is merely expressings its diversity and mutli-cultural ideas, it is a peaceful nation and its racist to condemn such comments, they are just rehtoric, just ideas, Iran is a country of diversity and tolerance we must 'understand' her.
The first position was taken by most right wingers and Israel supporters. The second position was taken by the intellectual right and the centrist politicians. The third position was taken by the left and the liberal academics.
We are always told that these types of statements are merely 'rhetoric'. The inclusion of the protolocols of the elders of Zion in Hamas consittution, the calling for the arabs to 'drive Israel into the sea' in 1948, every call for the death of Israel, etc...
However we must recall that in the 1930s the left and the appeasement right also told us that Hitler was just full of rhetoric. How many experts at whitehall and other government houses told the world that Hitler was just using 'rhetoric' to get power and that it didnt reflect his 'true feelings' or that the Nazis used 'rhetoric' as part of their German 'cutlure' or that it was part of aesthetics, or that it was merely for show and that they would change course once in power. Yes we heard these things in the 1930s, up until the end of WWII. When Hitler decalred publically that a world war would mean the 'extermination of the Jews' once again the intellectuals and academics refused to condemn such comments.
In Rwanda when the Hutu Power radio for months in 1993 and 1994 began calling for the extermination of the 'cockroaches' the UN and the world and the liberals and NGOs and aid organizations said it was merely 'rhetoric'. In Cambodia when Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge radio called for the resettling of all the city people, we were told it was rhetoric. When the Taliban and those in Khartoum Sudan also created 'true Islamic Law' and imposed Sharia, it was said to be 'rhetoric'. Perhaps in every case where we are told it is merely 'rhetoric' it is in fact the opposite. Hate groups are not just fat old men with too much time on their hands, they may in fact be losers but if they ever have power history has shown they do follow through with their plans as sure as Stalin and Hitler did. Those like Nasser, who the left will point to as the example of 'see it was rhetoric, he didnt throw Israel into the sea' it is only because he could not. Just as the Neo-Nazis in America cant accomplish their goals without power, Nasser couldnt accomplish his without a good army. However Anthony Eden was right to refer to Nasser as 'Hitler on the Nile' and his instincts in 1956 were correct. Eden suffered the price, but if only the British government had made a similar 'colonial blunder' in 1933 by invading Germany, yes indeed it might have seemed like they ahd confronted a threat that never existed, but perhaps it is better to be safe, just as with Saddam, perhaps he wasnt the 'new Saladin' but perhaps we dont want to find out.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home