Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Thursday, March 09, 2006

Are Arabs ‘excluded’ from Israeli civil society?

A recent comment by a professor at Hebrew University alleged that Arabs in Israel are routinely discriminated against, not just by the government or in hiring, but by the media, they are sidelined and since the mass media represents society therefore it is a model of how civil society as a whole excludes the Arabs. If we ignore Haaretz, which devotes at least 25% of its articles to Israeli-Arabs or Palestinians, then we can begin by looking at general Israeli mass media. According to the professor one example of this sidelining is that Israeli media is in Hebrew(gasp!) and it has Russian subtitles sometimes, but never Arab subtitles, despite the Arabs supposed equality before the law. The professor points out that in a recent pledge drive to help sick children the children were all Jewish(gasp!).

Now let us recall that in 1982 when asked when South African blacks would have the vote and true democracy Pik Botha, the foreign minister responded “when the rest of Africa has democracy”.

Pik Botha points to a very fair fact, despite the fact that we would like to discourage comparisons between Israel and Apartheid South Africa. Europeans claim that Israel discriminates against its Arabs based on these ludicrous statements, such that Israeli media is mostly in Hebrew(gasp!) and doesn’t have Arab subtitles. But let us examine the host countries of the Europeans and American liberals who claim this, indeed they have been able to infect Israeli academics with self hate, but let us examine their hate and double standards. France has a large Muslim minority, is its mass media subtitled in Arabic, does it have large Arab editions of its dailies such as Le Monde? No. England? No. Germany has millions of Turks, is the TV subtitles in Turkish? No. America has millions of Mexicans, is its media subtitled in Spanish? No. Not on one account can we find an example of a country that caters to its minority who may speak a different language. They have a double standard for Israel. That’s not a complete surprise. However the situation could be easily remedied. In America there are now two Spanish channels that are available via cable. Why? Because of this little thing called capitalism. Some Hispanics and investors realized the massive profits that could be made with Spanish language TV. Therefore Telemundo and Univision are wildly successful. Yes, this is how the world works. Just because Israel has Arabic as an ‘official language’ and just because Arabs are accorded citizenship and full and equal rights doesn’t mean the media has to cater to them. If someone wanted to make some money perhaps a mass circulation newspaper could be published in the Arab sector, after all the Arab sector doesn’t pay property taxes in most of its villages so there is plenty of lose change among the Israeli-Arabs. In their quest, their unending quest, for self hatred, Israeli academics routinely make outlandish wrongheaded statements without first thinking them through. They want higher standards to apply to Israel than any other country in the world. We wonder if they had lived in Germany in the 1930s whether they would have demanded the mass media publish in Yiddish?

Race in Israel: Another lie

Racism in theory requires that race exist. If there is no racial difference between two people can they be racist towards one another? Now the European and the Arabs claim that Israel is a ‘racist apartheid country’ where ‘racism is indoctrinated from birth and shows itself in all institutions’. Let us do an experiment. Let us take 30 Europeans, we will select them proportionately from their countries. Then we will take 10 Americans and 10 Muslims. We will put them in a room and in front of them will be paraded Israeli citizens. The Israeli citizens will be proportionate to the population. Thus out of 10 Israeli citizens, 3 will be Arabs(one of these will be a Christian) and there will be 2 Russians, 1 Ethiopian, 2 Ashkenazim, and 2 Sephardim(One will be either Yemenite or Moroccan). Yes we will line up these ten Israeli citizens and the Europeans and all the others who claim that Israel is so racist will be asked to divide the group into Arabs and Jews. The modern European rhetoric about Jews claims that Jews are ‘white’ and that white Jews are racist, like the Nazis, against the Semitic Arabs who are portrayed as ‘dark’. In this rhetoric the ‘superman’ Jew is shown to suppress the ‘oppressed Arab’.
But let us put it to the test. The European of course wont be able to judge. Perhaps to make it slightly easier we will allow one of the Jews to wear a Kippah or black fedora to symbolize the Haredi percentage of the population. And since one of the Arabs will be a woman maybe she can wear a headscarf(despite the fact that only a small minority of Israeli-Arab women wear them). That might make it easier.

Now the European will make the claim “but in Israel the Jews know the difference”. Yes this was also the Nazi excuse, the Jews were portrayed as ‘racist’ in Germany and therefore the Nazis were merely combating Jewish ‘racism’ with a preemptive strike. Now the European is saying that Israelis all know the difference with the Arabs, or so the claim goes the Israeli Jews discriminate based on names, any job applications with the name Ahmed or Mohaamed or George, are immediately discarded. For that matter Israelis at the interior ministry certainly discriminate against non-Jews, who are usually European.

How do we reconcile the ‘new racial rhetoric(NRR)’ of the Europeans whereby Jews are said to be ‘white’ and there are said to be ‘no difference between the Jews and the Europeans’ because the Europeans use this argument in order to combat the Nazi argument that Jews were racially different(and to them therefore inferior). Now let us try to understand this quite complicated problem. In 1940 Jews were ‘different’ they were selected based not only on religious affiliation or name, since many were assimilated, even born Christian, they were also selected based on their ‘racial’ appearance. The Nazis had a very highly developed racial selection system, designed apparently or in part by IBM.

Now in 1940 Jews were ‘different’. There was no one in Eastern Europe who could not ‘pick out the Jews’ when the Nazis arrived and asked the local collaborators to do so.

Now let us learn about the rhetoric of today. Today the modern European or even some Canadian and American students claim that “Jews are no different racially or ethnically than Europeans, Judaism is merely a religion, the racist lies of the Nazis are wrong, Jews look just like Europeans, the photos of ‘degenerative’ Jews used by the Nazis were lies’. Ok, that’s interesting. However lets separate propaganda from reality. Surely the anti-Semitic cartoons of ugly, dirty, dark, swarthy hunchbacked Jews is a complete fabrication. But, sadly, it is based on a certain reality. Stereotypes are based on fact. Jews certainly looked different, even if in many cases the differences were small and among assimilated Jews who were born of mixed parents surely those differences were mitigated. However many Jewish features, dark hair, dark eyes, curly hair, these features, so prominent in Israeli society and the reason everyone remarks about the ‘beautiful Mediterranean look of Israelis’ is one example of how Jews were completely different then their pale skinned, shiny haired, blue or green eyed neighbors. The fact is that there are ethnic differences between the whites in Europe as well. There are major differences between Russians, English, Germans, French and Italians. Not always are these differences apparent, but there is no doubt an Italian from Palermo will, on average, appear massively different than a Russian. This is the reason many Israelis can easily point out the Russians in any given IDF unit or among a group of women. The Russians are different.

Thus we see that there are major ethnic differences even within Israeli society. If one will go to the community of Kiryat Belz they will find a cloistered Haredi community that has many ethnic similarities, by the same fact the Moroccan kibbutz’s near Kiryat Gat are different, as are the Russian areas of Tel Aviv. These are facts. Add to this the fact that the Arabs are also ethnically different. However the modern rhetoric of the European is not at play here. Recall that the same self hating Israeli academics claim that Ashkenazim were ‘racist’ against the Sephardim who arrived in the 1950s. So if the Ashkenazi are ‘racist’ against Amir Peretz, and then all Israelis are said to be ‘racist’ against the Arabs(who themselves have major ethnic differences among them, from the Circassians to the Bedouins), what do we really have.

We have a lie. The Europeans have lied and the lie has even infected Israeli society, among those who should know better.

When an Ethiopian doesn’t hire an Arab what is the ‘racism’ taking place. Is it the black man discriminating against the white Arabs. After all on Hitler’s race scale the Arabs are considered ‘whiter’ than the Jews.

Remember that the European doesn’t classify the genocide in the Sudan as racism despite the fact that it is Arab Janjaweed ‘raiders’ who are murdering and raping and enslaving Africans. Yes, it is whites slaughtering Blacks. What is the difference between the situation in Sudan and the situation in South Africa. There is no difference, in both cases it is racism. However the European, employing is New racial rhetoric(NRR) which is not do different than the convoluted Nazi view, classifies certain things according to ‘race’ and others according to ‘ethnicity’ and others according to religion all based on lies. Race is a lie. The European created racism, the European created the Holocaust, now the European divides us all and encourages hatred of Jews by claiming Jews are ‘racist’. Hopefully, and pray this will be soon, the Europeans will disappear from the world, they have wreaked to much havoc on our good senses, good riddance to them and their rhetoric of racial division and their double standards.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home