The Cursades, history and memory
Gloria Steinam says "They remmember the crusades". But why to 'they remmember? It is like wondering why when Hindus were killed in India it is described as 'incinerated' or 'immolated' in the newspaper or books. But when Hindus killed Muslims in subseuqent riots the Indians "burned the Muslims alive". Interesting. Why for instance in Koran Sura 4:35 is it said in Arabic to 'beat' your wife but in the translation to 'scourge' her or 'reprimand here'. Why?
Indeed some people apparently conceive history differently. While Muslims remmember the crusades, the west barely remmember the Holocaust. Serbs are said to have a 'victims' complex because they remmember years of imperialism at the hands of the Ottomans and the Nazi slaughter of 10 percent of their people. But the French dont remmember last year. Why? Is it true that Muslims remmember the crusades any more than the Mongolian destruction of Baghdad? In fact it is rather recent that the crusades were ever mentioned by Muslims and then only at the behest of westerners who taught them to hate the Crusades, but in traditional muslim history the crusades were no different than any other conflict, or the loss of Spain or such. BU why doesnt the west recall the 1000 year Islamic crusade in easern Europe and SPain, the battles for vienna and Paris, the enslavement of europeans, the genocide by MUslims of europeans? Why? because europe has a short memory. WHy doesnt the church or the crhistians recall the fate of the armenians, the assyrians, the copts or the former christians of nroth africa or the maronites or the Greeks at Smyrna? Why does Salonika get a book, but the Jewel of the Mediteranean, Smyrna, no one mentions her Greek past. Not her or Odessa. There is a reason. We are increasingly forgetful because we want to love the other and we are therefore not allowed to recall history, but some people do remmember, they remmember the nazis, the holocaust and the armenian genocide and they recall the Muslim colonization and crusades against europe.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home