Israel and the environment
It is not perhaps suprising that there exists a decent amount of literature on israel and its impact on the environment. Usually this type of work takes the shape of work claiming Israels 'occupation' of Arab lands has created environmental havoc and desturction. From Israeli settlements to the military bases and today the concrete barriors that exist. The idea is simple, had Israel never won the 1967 war, ahd she never conquered the West Bank and Gaza the environment would be better. THis must be demonstrated on two levels. First it must be demonstrated what condition the environment was in prior to 1967 in these areas and then it must be proved that ISrael either made it worse or didnt allow it to fulfill its potential. As an aside these articles, doctoral thesis and even books such as Architecture of t he Occupation also allude tot he idea that within the 1948 borders of Israel the environment has deteriorated tragically.
Let us remind ourselves first of a few facts, that are undisputed, although perhaps unknown. 94% of Israeli land is publically owned. Only 6% is privatally owned and that is owned primarily by Arabs and the Greek Orthodox Church.
What was the situation of the Arabs in the West Bank before 1967? Most did not have running water, even in Jerusalem most did not have electricity or bathrooms in their homes. The West bank produced almost no agriculture for export although most villages did produce some for private or inter-West bank consumption. Certainly in the Golan and in parts of the West bank agriculture was produced to a sufiicient degree to be exported.
In order to prove that Israel destroyed the environment it must first be proved exactly what Israel did that was harmful. The building of military bases is sited as one example. However anyone who has visited a military base on the Israel style knows they are small. In the early days since few brigades had to be stationed in the West bank the military presence was almost non-existant. The second argument would be that Israel, by creating settlements destoryed the environment of the west bank. The settlements were build primarily on hill tops, or in a few blocs) none of which was one land that had hithertoo been farmed by anyone, although perhaps it had been graved by Shepards. In every case the settlements planted trees, numbering in the millions, and ISraeli settlements produced agriculture for export, especially in the case of the hothouses of Gaza. THeir is an argument that the settlements by increasing the number of people on the west bank, caused undue havoc by using too much water or creating waste. This is a nice idea, but if we consider that the total number of settlers, 250,000(7000 in Gaza and 13,000 in the golan) are roughly today equal to the number of Palestinians who fled in 1967, about 250,000 and went to Jordan and if we take into Palestinian birth rates(10 children per home) verus Israeli(3 children) we see that actually these territories would have more then a million more people today. Of the existing Arab cities on the West Bank anyone who has gone can tell you that they have no urban planning and they are prime examples of urban spralls. No Ppalestinian city has parks, or large cemetaries that in most city planners views serve as the 'lungs' of a city.
What of the concrete obstacles, roads, and the barrier. These many changes to the envirnment were a direct response to the second intifada. Yes new dirt roads were carved. Yes concrete obstalces were set up on main roads, to protect them from sniper fire, and the same was done to settlements such as Netxer Hasani or Kfar Darom in Gaza. None of the Jews on the west bank wanted to live behind barbed wire and conrete bunkers, they were forced to save their lives. THese obstalces are easily moveable and not perminent. Ther security fence has markings of greater perminance, however only 3% of it is wall, and those parts which make up 99% 0f the media photos, while appearing ugly, only accur in places, once again, where sniper fire took place, for instance across from Beit Jalla, Kalkilya, and East Jerusalem. A similar fence with concrete exists along the Mexican American border, in Cyprus and in Korea and we havent heard about the irreplaceable damage they have caused to the ecosystem.
In short what we are talking about is that these essays and books are of a political nature. In the books we see that when we talk about water usage, we dont hear about the entire watershed, that crosses the borders of all the middle eastern countries on Israels border, no we hear only of Israel. In the case of the ecosystem, we dont hear about the entire ecosystem for instance the jordan river valley, we hear about Israel. Is there comparable numebrs of literature on the Jordanian, Syrian or Egyptian environment? In fact we have no recorded works on these items. The truth, as we know, is that these Arab states have no environmental policy. Liberals and those who hate Israel, who pretend the environemnt is their concern, do so not out of a concern for the regions environment or ecosystem, they do write so out of a political hatred for Israel. They are Moral relativists in their acceptance that Jordan would never bother to plant trees, have large national parks(the majority of Israeli land which is KKL-JNF land is national park without fences or boundaries). The person who does his disengenous contrived thesis on the Israeli environment does so out of an acceptance that in Arab 'culture' the environemnt isnt important but that in Western 'culture' preservint he environment is important, thus we must never judge an Arab country for destroying the environemtn or damming rivers such as Syria tried to do with the Jordan or Egypt did with the Aswan High Dam, rather the environemnt doesnt matter in a non-Western country since thats a different culture and we must never critisize other cultures for destroying the environment. THe message is simple, an eagle flying in america must be protected, if it crosses into Mexico, well then it as an eagle no longer matters. ANy true scientist or ecological writer such as David Quammen or E.O Wilson will tell you that the world of animal life knows no borders and water belongs to no nation. The same liberals who wax poetic about the Native Americans who sopposedly lacked ideas of property, today beleive that the environemnt only matters in certain countries which must be held to higher standards, where we once again here the echoes of Kirkpatrics famous essay.
ISrael brought millions of trees to Israel, it forested a land that had not seen forests for more then a thousand years, it cultivated the land, and even drained the malarial swamps. This, to a liberal is horrible, becuase the land was not left a barren desert, since todays Liberal hates the envirnment, and only uses it to hold certain countries to high standards and to lie about its affects.
Seth J. Frantzman


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home