The Geneva convention is a european document about how EUropeans think they should conduct war among themselves, it predicates itself on a number of assumptions, it assumes states are organizated and that they have armies and that they are 'civilized' which is to say it assumes states dont want to commit mass murder of civilians.
But all the genocides of the 20th century and diversity of conflicts in the world, which is much bigger than Europe, proves it to be outdated. It should either be revised or abandoned. Let us review a few problems with the Geneva convention to understand its limitations. First of all it does not apply to a country's treatment of its own people. Thus when the Nazis choose to exterminate the Jews, the Geneva convention saw no problem, because it respects 'soviergnty'. In addition it had nothing to say about Stalin's Gulag.
The second problem revolves around the portion of the convention that the High Court of Israel used to judge targeted killings illegal. According to reports the court cited Article 51(3) of the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions which states: "Civilians shall enjoy the protection afforded by this section, unless and for such time as they take a direct part in hostilities".
But what this protocol doesnt say is how one defines a 'civilian'. In Europe in the 19th century it was obviosu who the civilians were, they were the peasants who didnt wear frilly uniforms and tights. But todays world is more nuanced. Under this article a civilian can temporarily become involved in histility but he never stops being a civilian, however for the period where he engages in hostilities he loses his protections under the conventions and becomes a 'civilian combatant.'
But apparently the judges didnt comprehend the English version of the Geneva convention. It is worthwhile therefore to quote. Civilians are not those according to the protocol of 1977 who are members of a "party" to a conflict even if such party is "not recognized by an adverse Party". This would mean a terrorist organization, which is a 'party' to a conflict and has internal discipline but is not neccearily recognized by the government.
In addition civilians are not those defined under Article 4 of the Third Geneva Convention, which is to say "members of militias" and those "of carrying arms openly". This also includes "paramilitary" units. All of this assumes that these people will "idenfity" themselves and that the "parties to a conflict" will notify eachother when they incorporate more forces into their armies. But when confronting armed terrorist organizations there is no doubt that these people are not civilians. The Geneva convention beleived that even these paramilitary organizations would "conduct their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war.(Article 4, Third convention, 2 section d)" In addition it notated that the convention applied to those "Inhabitants of a non-occupied territory, who on the approach of the enemy spontaneously take up arms to resist the invading forces, without having had time to form themselves into regular armed units, provided they carry arms openly and respect the laws and customs of war. (Article 4, third convention, 6)."
Lets summarize this for a momenr. Civilians are not those who engage in a conflict in an organized or semi-organized manner. There is some understanding that civilians, like soldiers, may go to war for a period, josining in combat by bearing arms, but then retire and return to be civilians. What if civilians violate the Geneva convention in their operations for instance in violating Article 37 of the 1977 protocol by using "perfidity" by "feigning of civilian, non-combatant status."
So who are all these 'civilians' the High Court spoke of? They are apparenlty all the members of Hamas and other terrorist organizations who are no bearing arms at any given moment and once they 'retire' from being directly involved in operations they are 'civilians'. However a more logical argument would be to see any member of Hamas as a combatant since under the law that is how every member of the IDF, Israeli police, settelment security and other security forces are seen under the convention. In short, why must Israel play under different rules? Hamas and the other terror organizations ruitinely feign civilians status.
The Geneva convention didnt forsee terrorism, it didnt understand it because no European army had ever dealt with such as thing, except rarely as with the German occupation of Belgium in 1914 or Napoleon in Spain in the early 1800s. The original Geneva conventions defined those civilians who engaged in combat as being outside the realm of international law, which is why the Germans and Russians in both World Wars simply shot partisans on site rather than detaining them in POW camps. Ironically when the Geneva convention was updated in 1977, in the after math of Vietnam and the Red Brigades and the Tupamarus(terror organizations), there was no attempt to classify how to deal with those people who join terror groups. However there was an attempt to further extend protections to civilians, and thus make it harder to imprison, arrest and kill them if they had joined terror groups or subversive groups but were not immediatly conducting operations. This was the logic under which the Israeli high court conducted itself. However this means terrorists gain more rights under the convention, and hence Israeli law, than normal army combatants. In wartime troops who are not engaged in fighting, for instance they are sleeping in transit or they are at the chow line, are still potential targets for wartime operations. They dont become civilians because they put down their M-16s to go to the bathroom. So why do members of terror organizations become civilians for every second they are not in the immediate possession of weapons. Furthermore since a suicide bomb belt is not a gun, one might well say it is not 'weapon in clear sight.' When the body is the weapon, thus the person, how can one be called upon not to fight him because he is a civilian at the same time.
The truth is that there is no such thing as a civilian in most of these cases. The Palestinian terrorist organizations and human rights organizationshave made the case that their suicide bombings are legal under the law because all Israelis are potentially available for call up to reserve duty and thus every person in Israel, except apparently Israeli-Arabs, is a combatant 100% of the time. This is sweet logic and it is endorsed in a tangential manner by Jimmy Carter and his fellow travellers. Under this logic since every Palestinian is a potential member of a terrorist organization than every palestinian is a combatant. One wonders if Amnesty international, Yes Gavul, Peace Now, Machsom Watch, Btselem, the organization against torture, doctors without borders, ISM, the association for civil rights in Israel and the other 250,000 organizations devoted to aiding Palestinians would like that definition.
Instead of resorting to these acrobatics it would be better to discard the Geneva convention entirely as a construcct of colonialistic, wealthy, arrogant Europeans who crafted a document that applied to them in the 19th century but never applied to anyone else. Most of us should recall that the same Europeans who subjected eachother to the 'laws of war' by the use of POW camps didnt give the same protections to anyone else whether those 'others' were Jews, Sikhs, Arabs or Zulus. The Europeans always knew that the definitions in the Geneva convention only applied to Christian white Europeans and that it never applied to 'native rebellions' or 'native disturbances' or 'the Jews'. After all the Nazis treated British POWs well in World War Two while they brutally massacred Russian POWs. Why? BEcause Russians were not seen as 'european'.
So why should ISrael submit to colonialism anymore. The idiocy and inadequacy and illogical nature of Geneva convention is a waste of time. A new body of law should be crafted that applies to the modern world and the present problems faced by states confronting ITOs(international terrorist organizations) and home-grown terror groups and how to define civilians in these terms. Certainly targeted assasinations dont infringe on anyone's human rights who is a member of a terror organization. Military operations in all wars, even in Europe, were targeted assasinations on a massive scale.
A Jpost article said today:
"According to the decision, the issue revolved around the question: when does a civilian lose the protection of that status? The court cited Article 51(3) of the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions which states:
"Civilians shall enjoy the protection afforded by this section, unless and for such time as they take a direct part in hostilities".
Thus, the court said, a civilian, in order to enjoy the protections afforded to him by international law during an armed conflict, must refrain from taking a direct part in the hostilities. A civilian who violates this principle and takes direct part in hostilities does not lose his status as a civilian, but as long as he is taking a direct part in hostilities he does not enjoy the protections granted to a civilian. He is subject to the risks of attack like those to which a combatant is subject.
For a targeted killing to be approved, the court stipulated four conditions that needed to be fulfilled to the best of the IDF's ability.
An individual could only be considered a target if strong evidence had been gathered of involvement in hostilities.
If any other method of stopping the attack was available, such as arrest, then it should be used before considering killing him. Only if trying to make an arrest poses such great risk to soldiers' lives can the army employ other means and kill him.
An independent investigation must be launched immediately after the operation. If an innocent civilian was harmed, then compensation should be paid.
Collateral damage must be proportional. For instance, shooting at a sniper who is targeting IDF troops is permissible even if an innocent bystander might be wounded. However, dropping a bomb from the air on a building that houses a terrorist but also houses many innocent civilians is not."