Post-Capitalist, Progressive, anti-Moral Relativist, Anti-Islamist. Reporting from the front lines of the war against Liberalism, Islamism, Nazism and Communism

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Frantzman Weekly Newsletter 21

To Subscribe email sfrantzman@hotmail.com

Seth J. Frantzman
Newsletter 21
March 18th, 2007
Empire, diversity and tolerance

A new book entitled Rome and Jerusalem has arrived on the bookshelves. Ideally this should have been an interesting topic. It covers the period roughly from the birth of Christ(1 AD) to 200 A.D. The book seeks to examine the Roman empire and the Jewish people and interaction between the two and the eventual semi-destruction of the latter. It should have been as interesting as The Pity of it All by Amos Elon. Unfortunately, like so many books today, it decided that the first century A.D needed to be examined through the lens of the 21st century and that means through post-modernism, moral relativism and of course ‘racism’(this word is applied to the Crusaders as well today, despite that ridiculous assertion).
This book contains a chapter with the title ‘diversity and tolerance’ and seeks to imply that the Roman empire was sort of a modern Harvard University, diverse, enlightened, progressive, open-minded, sexually aware, sort of a mecca of liberalism, like the Upper West Side, or Paris. The evidence given is that Roman statues and carvings showed the diverse peoples of the empire. Not only that but within the empire there were a gargantuan number of minorities and cultures and, get this, not only that but they were allowed in Rome as well.
But let us apply this rule, the visual recognition of diversity and the manifestation of it, to the British empire or any empire for that matter. It is strange that were we to read the literature on other empires, especially those founded by Europeans between 1492 and 1900 that we would not find the words ‘diversity and tolerance’ in the same sentence. We would find words like ‘racism’ and ‘eurocentrism’ and ‘imperialism’ and ‘colonialism’ and ‘genocide’ in writings. But if we recall the various expos held in Europe during the 19th century that celebrated empire we would see in pictures quite a number of diverse characters. In fact even in the 16th century the Spanish used to bring back natives from the New World to show case them, to show case their diversity. We would find in these expos 6 foot Sudanese, Sikhs, Gurkas, Jains, various Hindus, Bedouins, Buddhist monks, Pathans, Malays, Xhosas, Zulus and any other number of people from throughout the English empire. Surely that is ‘diversity’. Surely that means tolerance. But it has not been regarded as so. Does it mean that we must wait for another 1500 years or so, the time since Rome fell, to have books written about the British empire and other empires that call them ‘diverse’?
The truth is that modern liberal thought mistakes diversity and tolerance, finding it where it does not exist and accusing cultures of racism that usually lack it the most. That is why, inevitably it seems, nations in the modern world that are the most diverse(Israel, the United States, Russia) are all called ‘virulently racist’. Countries with absolutely no diversity, such as Japan and Saudi Arabia, don’t seem to get this label. The message is sort of along the lines of the Moynihan doctrine(Patrick Moynihan was a powerful U.S senator and U.S ambassador to the United Nations who coined the phrase “Accusations of human rights abuse are directly proportional to the amount of human rights a country has” which is to say those countries accused of human rights abuses are usually the ones that have the best records in defending them and are the freest). Accusations of racism go hand in hand with the amount of diversity in a given country, the more diverse, the more it is accused of racism today. But not Rome. Rome was not ‘racist’. In truth Rome was not racist because the very idea of Racism is mostly a canard when applied to any people, culture or system that existed before 1850. Racism is a specific idea. It cannot be applied to the Crusaders for instance. The Crusaders didn’t have any notion of race. They were European semi-nobles, from a hugely diverse(there it is again) group of statelets and principalities who converged on the Holy Land to reclaim it for Christendom after it had been colonized by Arabs and Turks, then collectively called Saracens. Oh but the reader reminds us, the Crusaders were mean, they massacred Jews in the Rhineland, they murdered Muslims, didn’t they.
Yes they did, but not because of ‘race’. There was no difference racially between the Crusaders and the people they fought.(just as there is no racial difference between Jews and Arabs, but that doesn’t stop the comparisons to apartheid in Israel). Racism is a dumb term and it should be discarded by anyone who wants to have their research or opinions taken seriously. However it seems to appear everywhere in all sorts of disciplines about all sorts of things that it shouldn’t. Take the canard that “Islam is not racist”. What does that mean? Is Christianity ‘racist’? Is Hinduism ‘racist’? What moron decided that religion can be racist? Is the Navajo nation racist because one cannot join it? Social Darwinism is racist and the secular-pagan National Socialism of Hitler was racist. These ideas were racist because they developed directly from the pseudo-sciences(as Anthropology and Biblical Criticism did) of the 19th century. They happened to believe that racial attributes and people’s ‘blood’ determined to a large measure everything one needed to know about people. That idea doesn’t derive itself from religion and it is not found among indigenous people, it derives itself from modernity and has been grafted on to all sorts of things. The Sudanese genocide of black Africans by White Arabs is indeed racist, but only in our modern view of the term, it has been going on for 1500 years and while based on the different skin colors between the people it is not completely accurate to describe it as having been ‘racist’, perhaps better to say it has had ‘racial overtones’, perhaps better to simply tell the truth: It is Arabs murdering Blacks because one hates the other. Honesty is the cure for causing modern labels to stop being used for ancient and old things.



Ethnocentrism

There is a new heresy among the liberal classes and academics and intellectuals and progressives and people of thoughts. This is the heresy of calling things ‘ethnocentric’. The very idea of ethnocentrism is about as old as ‘ethnic-cleansing’, so it dates from the 1990s(the two terms go hand in hand actually). Sometime in the 1960s western rebellious students and their equally critique minded professors who wanted to ‘tear it all down man’ and ‘smash the idols’ of the University and the national ethic, decided that most of social sciences had been polluted by ‘Eurocentrism’. This meant any ideas like ‘civilization’ and ‘modernity’ and ‘capitalism’ and ‘the state’ and ‘the west’ and other value judgments had to go. In place of them arrived not only ‘gender studies’ and various departments for the study of minorities(Native-Americans, African-Americans, Jews, Mexicans, Asians) but also the idea that all the departments devoted to the study of world history had to be revamped.
This process worked slowly. The publication of Edward Said’s Orientalism, written by a white Christian about how the west dares to perceive the non-west as different and dares to judge it caused everyone to believe that non-western peoples should be study with sympathy and with an attempt to understand them from their point of view. This was later taken further so that departments for the studies of non-westerners imported those very people to study themselves. Students were forced to study ‘non-western civilization’ during their course of college. Eventually this sifted its way down to high schools so that all studies of the self(for instance Western Civilization) disappeared and were replaced with ‘world history’ and various little snippets of the histories of other places. China, Mexico and everybody else got their fifteen minutes of fame within the education system. This produced a generation of students, and is now producing a second, who know nothing about their own history or culture or religion and know even less about everyone else, because they have been forced to learn ‘something about everything’. But if they have been lucky they might know the history of Taoism and the importance of the Hanbali school of Islamic law, and there their knowledge will end.
During this period those same people campaigning for more diversity in the education system in terms of subjects taught and peoples learned about, desired to eradicate racism. Affirmative action and quotas for minorities were only part of a general crusade to whipe out racism. Students were taught about African-American history and all minorities. Students were given incessant lessons about the horrors of slavery and the Holocaust.
However eventually people realized that for all intents and purposes racism had to a large degree been defeated in the schools and academia. Euro-centrism had certainly gone away, there was no study of Europe or anything western unless it was the study of how Europe was ‘racist’ and ‘colonialist’ and the birthplace of the Holocaust. But people realized this was not enough. They began to coin the word ‘ethnocentrism’. This word had the added benefit that it could be applied to almost anything.
The first time I heard it and it shocked me was in a media studies class in Jerusalem on Holocaust Remembrance day. While discussing the way in which the media is coerced, god forbid, to show Holocaust movies and play depressing music on the memorial day an America female student shouted out “isn’t this all very ethnocentric, only the Jewish narrative is told, what about all the other people who suffered?” There is was. Holocaust remembrance day must go, it was not racist, in the sense that it wasn’t hateful, but it was ethnocentric. It valued Jewish suffering above the suffering of others. It implied somehow that the suffering of the Jews was unique, that they should be remembered, at least it implied that Jews should concentrate the suffering of their own people.
But ethnocentrism appears everywhere. A book on Egyptian policies towards nomadic Bedouins accused the Egyptian government of being ‘ethnocentric’ because it saw the Bedouins as uncivilized and no modern. The reason ethnocentrism had to be coined was because those people who saw racism defeated realized that the very pride of people for their own religion and heritage was itself dangerous, it wasn’t always manifested in racism, many times it was manifested in memorials or celebrations, but it was ethno-centric, because it valued one people over another.
The corollary of ethnocentrism is that people should not have pride in themselves, their national institutions or anything that ties them to other people around them. It is the ultimate belief in self loathing and self hate. People should not identify themselves. The very process of identification is itself ethnocentric because it shows that one believes they are a member of a group and thus those non-members become the ‘other’ and thus there is hatred and discrimination.
This is why after Sept. 11 Americans were told by their intellectual pashas to ask ‘why do they hate us?’ Americans were asked to investigate the reasons for the hatred of the terrorists, we were asked to ‘understand the terrorist motives’ and implicitly we were asked to blame ourselves: ‘American meddling in the middle east and American foreign policy sincerely offended others and they, being weak, saw this reaction as their only way to strike back, in fact in their minds they had waited since the time of the Crusades and colonialism to get back at the west for its destructiveness.’ The idea of ‘ethnocentrism’ was responsible for this response. If one goes back to December 8th, 1941 they do not find that the high pashas of intellectualism wanted Americans to explore ‘why they hate us.’ People implicitly understood that when people hate you it is not your job as the victim to reach out and understand the perpetrator. The rape victim does not have to consul her rapist, she does not have to ‘understand’ him and ‘his motives’. The doctrine of ethnocentrism however says that one must always understand others and put others before the self.
It is strange therefore that ethnocentrism is not applied to all people equally. The Arabs were not asked to wonder why the crusaders hated them. African-Americans and Mexicans and everyone else is not asked to cease their parades and ‘ethnocentrism’. Only certain people are accused of ethnocentrism. Again it is usually diverse countries with the most immigrants who are accused of being ethnocentric.
But the worst thing about this heresy is that it is wrong. People should be ethnocentric. They should be proud of themselves and their history. There is nothing wrong with recalling the Holocaust for a Jew or recalling the ‘Great Patriotic War’ for a Russian. There is nothing wrong with being proud of ones religion and culture. Pride is not root of all nationalism and hatred. Pride is healthy and decent. It is the lack of pride that leads to many terrible things. The recent events that have found converts to Islam accused of planning various terrorist operations, show the degree to which lack of pride can leave a vacuum that is then filled with the pride of the other and thus hatred. Must one recall that it was German patriots, noblemen in fact, who planned the assassination of Hitler in 1943 and 1944. Erwin Rommel, a key player in the plot, was a proud German, he was ‘ethnocentric’.
The more we hear about ethnocentrism the more we are forced to learn about the ‘other’ and the more we are forced to understand the world from his perspective and the more we are forced then ourselves to become whatever idiocy happens to be sweeping the world at a given moment, it is the reason so many on the left became proud admirers of Stalinsim and Islamism, because they are always searching to adopt the ideology and pathos of the ‘other’ to prove that they are not ethno-centric. It is why they hated the orientalists because the original orientalists adopted the clothing and manners of the other without adopting his worldview. T.E Lawrence, John Bagot Glubb and Richard Burton all admired the other(in this case the Bedouins) but did not adopt their worldview, nor did they discard their own. But take the case of John Bagot Glubb’s son. Glubb, also known as Glubb Pasha, was the commander of the Arab Legion which he built from scratch in the 1920s to control and defend Jordan, then a British protectorate. Glubb named his son Godfrey, after the Crusader knight. His son, infected with new ideas of ethnocentrism, and having inherited from his father a respect for Islam and the Arabs, converted to Islam. Glubb Pasha never converted because he was not infected with this idea. But the son identified more with Saladin than Churchill. This is the difference. The abandonment of the self and conversion to the other not only begets extremism but also results in the death of the self. For the liberal this means also the death of diversity. Once opposition to ethnocentrism infects small national groups it can spread among them and cause them to disappear. This has resulted in the ‘melting pot’ of America, the rejection in many cases of ethno-centrism for an American identity. In that case it is positive. But it is not positive when it means small national groups that are fragile are encouraged to leave behind their national holidays and their memorial days and their love of themselves and their language and life-style and way of dress and customs.

Liberalism and its abhorrence for diversity, its abhorrence for people liking to be who they are, liberalism’s interests in calling everyone’s religion a cult and the church a ‘cultic site’ and its interest in applying anthropology to indigenous peoples rather than applying history to them, denies them a right to exist, and destroys people and culture and kills the spirit of people. Those who call things ‘ethnocentric’ are doomed to die for they no longer have anything to be proud of, and once someone abandons the idea that his culture is good and positive they immediately convert to some other culture and they disappear.



“They lived together since time immemorial”

This phrase seems to repeat itself all too often. Just in the last two weeks it has been applied to Iraq and Thailand. This is the phrase that those who have no sense of history use when they can’t figure out why people are in conflict, it is used by the naïve who truly believe that the natural state of people and things is peace, rather than the Hobbesian struggle.
In Thailand two weeks ago a number of articles appeared concerning the Islamic Malay insurgency in the south of the country where 3,000 people have been killed in two years. Mostly this has been Muslim Malays murdering Buddhist Thais and the Thai military killing Muslims. All the scenes of a classic ‘religion of peace’ operation are exhibited including the ‘peaceful’ beheading of Buddhist monks and terrorists blowing up schools. But we are informed that this is alarming because these people “lived in peace as neighbors for generations…now Buddhists will not frequent Muslim villages due to fear and the Muslims are afraid to go to Thai villages.” Amazing. These people lived in perfect harmony and now they hate one another, there is a ‘cycle of violence’ and now magically they have all morphed into hateful communities who cannot live together. They ‘demand separation’ and ‘self-determination’ and ‘independence’.
In Iraq we are being told that ‘Sunni and Shia lived together in peace for many generations, they intermarried, they shopped at eachothers stores, and yet now communities are fleeing eachother, whole areas have become Sunni or Shia.’ Amazing. These people lived in perfect harmony, didn’t they? For generations. The same story was told of Yugoslavia in the 1990s, they had all married eachother and lived in harmony and ‘shopped at eachothers stores’ This is a classic story that repeats itself everywhere. We are always being told that some communities coexisted for some long period of time and then inexplicably they went at each others throats. The Turks and Armenians, the Jews and the Germans, the Tutsis and Hutus in Rwanda, the Blacks and the Whites in the old south. Whoops. Not that last one.
But the Old South might shed more light on this phenomenon than we realize. Remember the canard that goes along with these stories. The stories always begin with: ‘people X lived with people Y for time Z’. Then there is the second assertion that: ‘people X shopped from the stores of people Y and sometimes married people Y’. Then ‘people X killed all of people Y’ or ‘people Y became terrorists’ or ‘people X rioted against people Y and drove them out of town.’
It is always presented as some conundrum. Sometimes there is evidence of some recent event. For instance the Jews and the Blacks at Crown heights were supposed to have lived in perfect harmony for generations until Rebbe Schnerson’s motorcade ran over a black kid and then suddenly there were riots in the 1990s.
Let us return to the Old South. The blacks and the whites got along in the old south. They shopped at eachothers stores. They didn’t intermarry very much(perhaps because it was illegal) but we are assured that there were ‘illicit relationships’ and Strom Thurmond did produce a number of children with a black woman. They coexisted. There was ‘peace’. But we Americans are intelligent enough to know that this was not true. There was peace, but it is the peace that takes place when one people is kept beneath the other. The explosion of violence that began in the 1960s following the Brown V. Board of Education decisions and Rosa Parks’ bus boycott and culminated in the Freedom rides, was not something that came from no where. Yet Americans who are perfectly familiar with all the times in American history when the appearance of coexistence degenerated into bloodshed seem to be perplexed by the occurrence elsewhere. Indeed the west and everyone else is similarly perplexed. But that is because they are forgetful.
If you ask the Serbs how they coexisted with their neighbors they will have another story. If you ask the Shia in Iraq they will have another story. The Armenians, the German Jews, the Thais, everyone else will have a more accurate story about the reality of the situation. Let us recall the explosion of violence in 1948 in India and in Palestine. Both resulted in all the non-Muslims forced to flee a Muslim area and atrocities and war. They also resulted in the creation of India and Israel. We are told on both occasions of communities that ‘coexisted’.
This coexistence is a lie and scam in each of these cases. There is one thing that links them all. Each is linked by there being two or more groups. These groups are not equal. One is the minority and the other the majority. In the past one dominated the other.





This can be seen graphically like this:

Country/area Groups Former dominance 100 years ago Minority


Yugoslavia Serbs/Bosniaks Muslim Bosnians and Turks neither
Palestine Jews/Arabs Muslim Arabs Jews
India Hindus/Muslims Muslim Mughals Muslims
Thailand Thais/Muslims Muslim Malay sultanate Muslims
Germany Jews/Germans Christian Germans Jews
Turkey Armenians/Turks Muslim Ottomans Armenians
Turkey Armenians/Greeks Muslim Ottomans Greeks
Azerbaijan Armenians/Azeris Muslims Armenians
Old South Blacks/Whites Whites Blacks
Rwanda Tutsis/Hutus Hutus Tutsi
Iraq Sunnis/Shia Sunni Sunni
Chechnya Russians/Chechans Muslims Russians
Sri Lanka Buddhists/Hindus Hindus Hindus
Kashmir Sikhs/Muslims Muslims then Sikhs Sikhs
Nigeria Christians/Muslims Muslims Muslims
Sudan Blacks/Arabs Arabs Arabs
South Africa Blacks/Whites Whites Whites


These places are not mysteries, these people did not coexist. One group was always dominant. One group, usually for many years, suppressed and dominated the other. The minority group, or sometimes the majority was forced to live as second class citizens and they were forced to be subservient. Many times sexual violence and the raping of the women of one by the other was common. Slavery was sometimes common with the dominant one enslaving the other one. The subservient one sometimes did work in certain shops and the dominant one did indeed shop in his shops. But shopping in a person’s shop is not the same as coexisting. It is not the same as being equal. Usually these areas underwent some change, a foreign power or a revolution swept away an old system and a new system was put in place. Usually after some period of time this led immediately to violence and separation of the two peoples and sometimes destruction and complete cleansing of one. In a number of instances it resulted from one group finally being given equality with the other group. This list is incomplete in the extreme. There are examples in almost every country of situations like this, sometimes more violent and sometimes less so and with different results. The greatest degrees of violence frequently followed what appeared to be a greatest revolution.
The truth is that coexistence is mostly a myth when there are two groups of people. In almost all cases one intimidates the other. One group is usually to blame for the majority of rapes of the other group. One group furnishes more criminals than the other. One group dominates the other. One group hates the other, secretly or implicitly. One group enslaves the other. One group colonizes the other and invades the space of the other taking over the land of the other and destroying his institutions and way of life. Many cases the history is one that many years back saw a great battle between the two and the subjugation of one. But modern writers miss all this. They miss the reality of events and they miss the point that the ‘cycle of violence’ is not a cycle, it is a history, it is not circular but linear. It has a past, it doesn’t just come from nowhere.
Everytime you read the word ‘coexistence’ you should ask yourself what is really being said. The term is applied to situations like the ‘Golden Age of Muslim Spain’ between the 8th and 15th centuries. But this ‘Golden age’ was predicated not only on a system of Muslims enslaving non-Muslims, but on a legal system that discriminated outright against non-Muslims in the form of taxation and religious rights to worship. It was coexistence in the same way that all oppressive regimes have minorities that are forced to coexist. But it is not ‘coexistence’ in the way it is always meant. There are very few examples of real coexistence. There are even less examples of people who “lived together in peace since time immemorial.”

Labels: