What is the difference between propoganda and History?
Take two selections:
I publish below two accounts of the 'Nakba' the war in Israel/Palestine in 1948.
"Al-Nakbah
By Hesham Tillawi
"I am particularly amazed by the flight of the Arabs. This is a
more extraordinary episode in the annals of this country than the
establishment of a Jewish state. Truly astonishing is that the
Arabs have disappeared from a whole section of the country,"
wrote the first Israeli foreign minister Moshe Sharette on June 16
1948.
SAFSAF- a Palestinian village- 52 men tied with a rope and
dropped into a well and shot. 10 more were killed. Women
pleaded for mercy, three were raped, and a girl aged 14 was
raped. Another 4 were killed. This was a scene from 1948.
" They do it in the middle of the nights. Quietly, stealthily. In
large groups. Well organized militias-armed and all. A crowed of
about 50 religious settlers. Came in the night to two houses in
Israeli-annexed, Arab East Jerusalem, Sheikh Jarah, over the
Green line. They threw a child out of the broken window they had
entered by. A two-year old flying baby, falling from the 2nd story
window…" This was a scene from the end of April 2003. As
reported in Haaretz on April 29,2003, this group of terrorists were
escorted to this location by Tourism Minister Benny Elon of
Sharon government. From 1948 until now the scene had not
changed much. 1948 saw the birth of "Israel" and the birth of the
Palestinian refugee problem. The British Mandate over
Palestine was ending on May 14, 1948. The British were
supposed to bear responsibility for preserving law and order
until midnight, May 14, 1948. On several occasions they
defended Jewish settlements and neighborhoods. They did not,
however attempt to prevent the advance of the Haganah- Jewish
terrorist group- or the flight and expulsion of the Arabs. In some
cases they even helped the Arabs leave their homes. At the
same time they coordinated the transfer of many aspects of
government with the Jewish agency. This smooth transfer of
power was Britain's final contribution to the Jewish national
home.
By the end of the fighting in 1949, almost a million
Palestinians were forced off their land. More than 400 of the 500
Arab villages in Palestine had been taken over by the Israelis.
The inhabitants of these villages were driven out or fled in terror,
their land was confiscated and they were forbidden to return to
their land
Early May 1948 speaking to the People's Council, Israel's
first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion claimed that no Jewish
settlement to date had been abandoned in the war- in contrast
with " some hundreds Arab settlements" He asserted that "the
Arabs had abandoned cities with great ease, after the first
defeat, even though no danger of destruction or massacre
confronted them. Indeed it was revealed with overwhelming
clarity which people is bound with strong bonds to this land".
But in fact it was exactly the danger of destruction and the
massacres that were the cause of the Arab abandonment of
their homes. At the same moment that Ben-Gurion was saying
that, the Palmah- a Jewish terrorist group-was massacring
some seventy Arab prisoners near Ein az Zeitun and several
Arabs in the village itself.
To help Sherret's with his amazement and to expose
Ben-Gurion's lies that the Palestinians were in no danger when
they left their homes in 1948 let us look at a small sample of
what was happening in 1948:
At Sabbarin, the village fled after 20 were killed in the village, =
an IZL armored car fired at the fleeing villagers. "More than one
hundred old people, women and children, who had not fled from
Sabbarin and other villages, were held for few days behind
barbed wires at an assembly point in Sabbarin, after which they
were expelled to the Arab town of Umm al Fahm. The Jewish
troops combed the villages to ascertain that they were empty and
to make sure they remain empty. In the town of Lydda, a
massacre took place. 300 to 400 Israeli troops entered the town.
They were ordered to shoot at any thing that moves. The town
people took fright at the sounds of shooting outside believing
that a massacre was taken place, they rushed into the streets,
and were cut down by Jewish fire. In accordance with the Zionist
plan, the Haganah and other Zionist groups launched a series of
military attacks, the fully anticipated result of which was the
Arabs' flight from Palestine. These attacks were the most
important single factor in the exodus of April-June from both the
cities and villages. This is demonstrated clearly by the fact that
each exodus occurred during and in the immediate wake of each
military assault. No town was abandoned by the bulk of its
population before Jewish attack. Haifa, an Arab city of 70,000
strong Palestinians in 1947. In April 1948, an attack on Arab
refinery workers caused some 15,000 to 20,000 to flee the city.
The attacking Jewish forces brought in Jeeps broadcasting
recorded horror sounds including shrieks, wails and anguished
moans of Arab women. The wail of sirens and the clang of
firearm bells, interrupted by a sepulchral voice calling in Arabic:
Save your souls, all ye faithful, flee for your lives. According to an
eyewitness's account of a Haganah officer: "the threats to use
poison gas and atomic weapons against the Arabs made the
Arabs of Haifa flee the city." By the end of the war, only 3500
Arabs remained in the city. Watching the Arabs flee Ben-Gurion
exclaimed, "What a beautiful sight". David Ben-Gurion was the
architect of the 1948 War and the expulsion of the Arabs. As far
back as the late 1930s, Ben-Gurion said: "I support compulsory
transfer. I don't see in it anything immoral".
Ad Dawayima in late October. A soldier eyewitness
described how the IDF, capturing the village " without a fight first
killed about 80-100 Arab men, women and children. The children
they killed by breaking their heads with sticks. There was not a
house without dead. The remaining Arabs were then closed off
in houses without food and water, as the village was
systematically razed". SA'SA- cases of mass murder, over 1000
dead. People lifted white flags. A sacrifice was offered to feed the
troops. The whole village was expelled. Saliha- 94 were blown
up with a house.
The Palestinians left their homes for two reasons, the first
and for most they were expelled from their homes by force, and
the second, they were afraid for their lives from the terror and the
horror stories they had heard of the Jews massacring men,
women, and children as they had done in the village of Deir
Yassin. The Jewish campaign of ethnic cleansing started way
before Israel became a state, and before the British army left the
country. On April 3 1948 the Haganah, forced the 994 residents
of Khirbet Azzun to leave their village. On April 10, the 620 Arab
residents of Ad Dumeir, the 910 Bedouins from Arab an-Nufeiat,
and 340 Bedouins of Arab al-foqara were expelled from their
homes. On April 15, some 650 Arabs from Miska and an
uncounted number from Khirbet as-Sarkas were kicked out of
their homes. On May 12 1948, 600 residents of Najd and 1200
residents of Sumsum were forced out. Zarnuga and Kaukaba,
with population of 2600 and, 1870 were forced out on May 27 19
48 by the Givati Brigade and 800 Arabs from the village of Huj
were forced out on May 28th. Arab Rubin's 1550 residents were
expelled on June 1st, and Yibna with a population of 5920, was
emptied by force on June 4th .
This was only a partial list of what had happened in
Palestine in 1948. None of these expellees were allowed to
return to their villages once the war was over. One of the most
famous massacres took place at the village of Deir Yassin in the
hills on the outskirts of Jerusalem. Its residents were
considered passive, peaceful and friendly to the Jews. Its
leaders had agreed with an adjacent Jewish neighborhood,
Givat Shaul, that each side would prevent its own people from
attacking the other side. The city had not been in any way a threat
militarily to the Jews. The Irgun and Lehi Jewish terrorist groups
headed by Menachem Begin laid plans for an attack on the
village. A force of 120 men went into the village. One of its
leaders, Benzion Cohen, later said of the men who participated
in the attack, "The majority was for liquidation of all men, in the
village and any other force that opposed us, whether it be old
people, women, or children." 256 people were murdered in the
village. No one was spared. Old men, women and children.
Pregnant women were killed and their babies were cut out of
their wombs with knives and daggers. Bodies were left in the
street for the others to see. Some of the survivors were put in the
back of trucks, blindfolded and hands bound were paraded
through the streets of the Jewish controlled side of Jerusalem.
News of this massacre sent shock waves through Arab
communities, where Deir Yassin quickly became a name of
infamy and a source of terrible fear for the Arab population of
Palestine. After this "excellent" and, "great" operation Menachem
Begin, who later became Israel's prime minister issued a
message to his troops: "Accept my congratulations on this
splendid act of conquest. Convey my regards to all the
commanders and soldiers. We shake your hands. We are all
proud of the excellent leadership and the fighting spirit in this
great attack. Tell the soldiers: you have made history in Israel
with your attack and your conquest. Continue thus until victory. As
in Deir Yassin, so everywhere, we will attack and smite the
enemy. God, God, Thou hast chosen us for conquest."
55 years and counting, the Palestinians are still faced with
the same atrocities they faced back in 1948. Thousands of
Palestinians killed by the Israeli army just in the last two years.
The Security Council of the United Nations issued resolution 181
back in 1948 requiring the return of all Palestinian refugees to
their homes, 55 years later, refugees are still refugees, and
Israel still a member of the United Nations.
The Palestinians have been asked to control their
extremists from attacking Israel, as a first step to satisfy the
Road Map requirements, but who will control the extremists'
government in Israel today?"
and
"
May 15th 2003
PAC-PRESS
AL-NAKBAH
The Palestinian American Congress (PAC) commemorates
today (May 15th) Al-Nakbah.
Activities to bring the Palestinian community together on this day
have been on going throughout this week. In New Jersey, an art
exhibit and a lecture; in New York, a picnic with music and poetry,
in Houston, an art exhibit, in California, a picnic and a gathering
to honor Rachel Corrie; and many more.
The following two articles shed some light on this tragic day:
Our colleague and National Board member Hesham Tillawi
wrote the second article named Al-Nakbah.
__________________________________________
Al -Nakba (Arabic for Catastrophe) is the expression that was
named after the historic and tragic event of the ETHNIC
CLEANSING (compulsory population transfer for political aims),
and DISPOSSESSION of the Palestinian people for the past five
and a half decades. In 1948, hundreds of thousands of
Palestinian native inhabitants were forced to abandon their
lands, homes and properties and flee from their homeland,
under the constant attacks of the Zionist gangs.
These gangs were funded by several countries and private
Jewish rich people, in an effort to create a national homeland for
the Jews.
Until this very day, the Zionist attempts to dislocate the
Palestinian people continue, taking several forms and names,
recently dubbed the policy of "Transfer". This policy represents a
firm and solid proof to the continuous efforts that have been
exerted for the past 55 years to forger facts and deny
Palestinians the right to return to their homeland, the right to live
freely and the right for self determination.
Palestinian refugees fled to different place; some fled to the
neighboring countries around Palestine, others fled inside
Palestine and lived in refugee camps, built for them by UN
agencies, and the others were dispersed in several countries
around the world.
All these refugees had a common dream ?? to go back to their
original homes. Generations and generations of refugees
passed, and with each remembrance day of Al-Nakba, this
dream is revived, and Palestinians in Diaspora look forward to
the day where they would go back again to their stolen Palestine.
Parents teach their children from where they originally came in
Palestine, and urge them to pass this heritage to their children."
and "Israel Uses Women, Children As Shields In Jenin: Witnesses
http://www.islam-online.net/English/News/2003-05/14/article11.shtmlphoto:
http://www.islam-online.net/English/News/2003-05/14/images/pic11.jpg Iraqi TV Starts Transmission Without Qur’an, Adhan
http://www.islam-online.net/English/News/2003-05/14/article07.shtml New Iraqi TV Complains of U.S. Censorship ...Censoring Quranic verses
http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=topNews&storyID=2733916 U.S. Iraq Commander Accused Of War Crimes In Belgium
http://www.islam-online.net/English/News/2003-05/14/article10.shtml Is Your Computer Being Hijacked?
http://www.mercola.com/2003/may/14/spyware.htm Building bombed in Riyadh was a CIA front
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,3-679768,00.html Israel’s New Anti-Activist Strategy
http://www.rabble.ca/rabble_interview.shtml?x=21636 Iran's Khamenei Says US Planning To Invade Iran
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3023225.stm Fake Docs Prove Brit MP Galloway Smeared
http://www.rense.com/general37/gallos.htm The Israel Lobby and the Left: Uneasy Questions
http://www.leftcurve.org/LC27WebPages/IsraelLobby.htmlSent by Afrikom"
"Hassan El-Najjar:
Propaganda is the selective release of positive information about oneself or about one's group. This is what you did Michael. Israel is an occupying power that has been oppressing the Palestinian people for 36 years. Israelis are living in the homes of the Palestinians without compensating them or without allowing them to go back to their homes. Israel has denied Palestinians citizenship. These are the basics of the conflict that you have chosen to ignore, like all supporters of Israel. A just solution should include correcting these wrongs. Temporarily, it will be OK to have two states, but on the long run, there should be one state for Palestinians and Israelis. Democracy and economic prosperity will make coexistence possible.
The news photos are supposed to awaken human feelings inside people, including supporters of Israel. Sharon and his settlers are aggressive. Nobody should support their aggression, whether you're Jewish or not, you're human first. Israeli atrocities in the Palestinian territories should not be defended. Showing these atrocities in photos is not propaganda, it's the truth, simple and clear.
Cartoons represent the feelings of Arab cartoonist toward their oppressors, the aggressive Israelis. This is the truth, even if you don't want to admit it. Israel has launched wars against Arabs in 1948, 1949, 1956, 1967, 1978, 1982, and a continuous war since 2000. These wars were all fought on Arab lands. In particular the 1948/1949 war which ended in annexing Galilee, Auja, and most of the West Bank and Gaza to Israel (Look at the Partition Map, in the documents section). Contrary to what Israelis say, and you repeated, the 1948 war was an Israeli war of aggression against the Palestinian people. It is documented and known as Plan Dalet, according to which the Haganah (Israeli armed forces) attacked Palestinian villages and evicted Palestinians from their homes.
Criticizing Israel, particularly greedy settlers and their Sharon government is not anti-Semitic. You should refrain from that particularly when you deal with victims of Israel, Arabs generally and Palestinians in particular. More important is that Arabs are Semites and they are proud of their heritage. They cannot be anti-Semitic. Arabs and Muslims also cannot be anti-Jewish because they believe in the Bible and they claim all messengers of God as their own, namely Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Jesus Christ, and the Seal of the Prophets, Muhammed, Peace of God be to all of them.
Arabs, Muslims, and peace loving people all over the world criticize aggressive Zionist Israeli policies that have kept the conflict going on for 55 years, UNNECESSARILY. Nobody has monopoly on history. Truth has several aspects and can be seen from several angles and perspectives.
Finally, regarding your redlined statement that Palestinians never owned any lands, Palestinians are the only owners of Palestine. They have always been there since time immemorial, long before Abraham came to Canaan and Philistia. They believed in his message and followed him. They believed in the Old Testament, then they believed in the New Testament, when Jesus came. Then, when the message of Islam spread, they became Muslims. It is impossible for you or anyone in the world to deny that the Palestinian people (Muslims, Christians, and non-European Jews) represent this wonderful heritage, as they intermarried for thousands of years. They are the owners of the land. They have always been there. And they will be there forever, simply because God promised the Holy Land for them. He promised it to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and their descendants, not to followers of any religion. Sharon and the Israeli settlers are just fighting God. They can't win against Him (Read my Promised Land editorial for more information). Peace to you."
all from:
http://www.aljazeerah.info/Letters%20to%20the%20Editor/2003%20letters%20to%20the%20editor/May2003/Readers%20letters%20and%20contributions,%20May%2017,%202003.htmNow having read these 'history lessons' it is important to ask 'what is history'. Soem cynics say it is the propoganda of the victor and perhaps in some way this is true so much as it is the history of the events in general that souround the victor for some time afterwords, for instance we know of a widespread mexican rebellion in Texas in 1915 only barely, and we know of the tribes in the Balkans in the 3rd century only for those the Romans cared to write about, obvisouly those without whome the ROmans had no knowledge were not considered.
However oddly in the information age we would think there would be no debating single events, for instance the killing of refinery workers in Haifa in 1948, we know that it was Jews who were killed, not Arabs, yet here we see the opposite. The information age doesnt actually help at all. a single volume such as Gibbons rise and fall of Roman Empire is far more factual than modern day news. We have cultures to whome historical fact is not even part of their narrative. In fact history is dying everyday, even as more historian are trained to analyze the 'theory' and the debate' of history rather then unearth anything new.
It is in fact dying.